Formation Of Otoconia Research Articles

Structure and function of the proton channel OTOP1

OTOP1 belongs to the otopetrin family of membrane proteins that form proton channels in cells of diverse types. In mammals, OTOP1 is involved in sour transduction in taste cells and contributes to otoconia formation in the inner ear. From the structural point of view, otopetrins, including OTOP1, represent a quasi-tetramer consisting of four α-barrels. The exact transport pathways mediating proton flux through the OTOP1 channel and gating units modulating its activity are still a matter of debate. This review discusses current data on structural and functional features of OTOP1. Suggested proton transport pathways, regulatory mechanisms, and key amino acid residues determining functionality of the otopetrins are considered. The existing kinetic models of OTOP1 are discussed as well. Based on revealed functional properties, OTOP1 is suggested to operate as a logical XOR element that allows for proton flux only if transmembrane pH gradient exists.

Behavioral and neural responses to high-strength magnetic fields are reduced in otolith mutant mice.

Static high magnetic fields (MFs) interact with the vestibular system of humans and rodents. In rats and mice, exposure to MFs causes perturbations such as head movements, circular locomotion, suppressed rearing, nystagmus, and conditioned taste aversion acquisition. To test the role of otoconia, two mutant mouse models were examined, head-tilt Nox3het (het) and tilted Otop1 (tlt), with mutations, respectively, in Nox3, encoding the NADPH oxidase 3 enzyme, and Otop1, encoding the otopetrin 1 proton channel, which are normally expressed in the otolith organs, and are critical for otoconia formation. Consequently, both mutants show a near complete loss of otoconia in the utricle and saccule, and are nonresponsive to linear acceleration. Mice were exposed to a 14.1 Tesla MF for 30 min. After exposure, locomotor activity, conditioned taste aversion and c-Fos (in het) were assessed. Wild-type mice exposed to the MF showed suppressed rearing, increased latency to rear, locomotor circling, and c-Fos in brainstem nuclei related to vestibular processing (prepositus, spinal vestibular, and supragenual nuclei). Mutant het mice showed no response to the magnet and were similar to sham animals in all assays. Unlike het, tlt mutants exposed to the MF showed significant locomotor circling and suppressed rearing compared with sham controls, although they failed to acquire a taste aversion. The residual responsiveness of tlt versus het mice might reflect a greater semicircular deficit in het mice. These results demonstrate the necessity of the otoconia for the full effect of exposure to high MFs, but also suggest a semicircular contribution.

Quantitative analysis and correlative evaluation of video-oculography, micro-computed tomography, and histopathology in Pendrin-null mice

Patients with SLC26A4 mutations exhibit highly variable hearing loss and vestibular dysfunction. Although Slc26a4 mutant mice similarly exhibit vestibular deficits, including circling behavior, head tilting, and torticollis, the underlying pathogenesis of the vestibular symptoms remains unclear, hindering its effective management for patients with SLC26A4 mutations. In this study, we evaluated the equilibrium function using the inspection equipment, which can record eye movements against rotational, gravitational, and thermal stimulations. Moreover, we correlated the degree of functional impairment with the morphological alterations observed in Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice. The rotational stimulus and ice water caloric tests revealed considerable impairment of the semicircular canal, while the tilted gravitational stimulus test showed a severe functional decline of the otolithic system in Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice. Generally, the degree of impairment was more severe in circling Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice than in non-circling Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice. In non-circling Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice, the semicircular canal function was normal. Micro-computed tomography results showed enlargement of the vestibular aqueduct and bony semicircular canals but no correlative relationship between the severity of the caloric response and the size of bony labyrinths. Giant otoconia and a significant decrease in total otolith volume in the saccule and utricle were observed in Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice. However, the giant otoconia were not overly dislocated in the bony otolithic system and ectopic otoconia were absent in the semicircular canal. The number and morphology of the utricular hair cells in Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice were not significantly reduced compared to those in Slc26a4Δ/+ mice. Collectively, we can conclude that vestibular impairments are mainly associated with otoconia formation and morphology rather than hair cell degeneration. In addition, severe disturbances of semicircular canals cause circling behavior in Slc26a4Δ/Δ mice. Our comprehensive morphological and functional assessments apply to mouse models of other genetic diseases with vestibular impairment.

Cibacron blue 3G-A is a novel inhibitor of Otopetrin 1 (OTOP1), a proton channel

Otopetrin 1 (OTOP1) is a proton (H+) channel which detects acidic stimuli in sour taste receptor cells and plays some sort of role in the formation of otoconia in the inner ear. Although it is known that zinc ion (Zn2+) inhibits OTOP1, Zn2+ requires high concentrations (mM order) to inhibit OTOP1 sufficiently, and no other inhibitors have been found. Therefore, to identify a novel inhibitor, we screened a chemical library (LOPAC1280) by whole-cell patch clamp recordings, measuring proton currents of heterologously-expressed mouse OTOP1. From the screening, we found that reactive blue 2 inhibited OTOP1 currents. Further evaluations of three analogues of reactive blue 2 revealed that cibacron blue 3G-A potently inhibited OTOP1 currents. Cibacron blue 3G-A inhibited OTOP1 currents in a concentration-dependent manner, and its 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) and the Hill coefficient were 5.0 μM and 1.1, respectively. The inhibition of OTOP1 currents by cibacron blue 3G-A was less affected by extracellular anion compositions, membrane potentials, and low pH than the inhibition by Zn2+. These results suggest that the inhibition of OTOP1 by cibacron blue 3G-A is neither likely to be a pore-blocking inhibition nor a competitive inhibition. Furthermore, our findings revealed that cibacron blue 3G-A can be used as a novel inhibitor of OTOP1 especially under the conditions in which OTOP1 activity is evaluated such as low pH.

Zinc activation of OTOP proton channels identifies structural elements of the gating apparatus.

Otopetrin proteins (OTOPs) form proton-selective ion channels that are expressed in diverse cell types where they mediate detection of acids or regulation of pH. In vertebrates there are three family members: OTOP1 is required for formation of otoconia in the vestibular system and it forms the receptor for sour taste, while the functions of OTOP2 and OTOP3 are not yet known. Importantly, the gating mechanisms of any of the OTOP channels are not well understood. Here, we show that zinc (Zn2+), as well as other transition metals including copper (Cu2+), potently activates murine OTOP3 (mOTOP3). Zn2+ pre-exposure increases the magnitude of mOTOP3 currents to a subsequent acid stimulus by as much as 10-fold. In contrast, mOTOP2 currents are insensitive to activation by Zn2+. Swapping the extracellular tm 11-12 linker between mOTOP3 and mOTOP2 was sufficient to eliminate Zn2+ activation of mOTOP3 and confer Zn2+ activation on mOTOP2. Mutation to alanine of H531 and E535 within the tm 11-12 linker and H234 and E238 within the 5-6 linker reduced or eliminated activation of mOTOP3 by Zn2+, indicating that these residues likely contribute to the Zn2+ activating site. Kinetic modeling of the data is consistent with Zn2+ stabilizing the opn2+en state of the channel, competing with H+ for activation of the channels. These results establish the tm 11-12 and tm 5-6 linkers as part of the gating apparatus of OTOP channels and a target for drug discovery. Zn2+ is an essential micronutrient and its activation of OTOP channels will undoubtedly have important physiological sequelae.

N′-terminal- and Ca2+-induced stabilization of high-order oligomers of full-length Danio rerio and Homo sapiens otolin-1

Otolin-1 is a C1q family member and a major component of the organic matrix of fish otoliths and human otoconia. To date, the protein molecular properties have not been characterized. In this work, we describe biochemical characterization and comparative studies on saccular-specific otolin-1 derived from Danio rerio and Homo sapiens. Due to the low abundance of proteins in the otoconial matrix, we developed a production and purification method for both recombinant homologues of otolin-1. Danio rerio and Homo sapiens otolin-1 forms higher-order oligomers that can be partially disrupted under reducing conditions. The presence of Ca2+ stabilizes the oligomers and significantly increases the thermal stability of the proteins. Despite the high sequence coverage, the oligomerization of Danio rerio otolin-1 is more affected by the reducing conditions and presence of Ca2+ than the human homologue. The results show differences in molecular behaviour, which may be reflected in Danio rerio and Homo sapiens otolin-1 role in otolith and otoconia formation.

Purinergic signaling in the peripheral vestibular system.

The inner ear comprises the cochlea and vestibular system, which detect sound and acceleration stimulation, respectively. The function of the inner ear is regulated by ion transport activity among sensory epithelial cells, neuronal cells, non-sensory epithelial cells, and luminal fluid with a unique ionic composition of high [K+] and low [Na+], which enables normal hearing and balance maintenance. One of the important mechanisms regulating ion transport in the inner ear is purinergic signaling. Various purinergic receptors are distributed throughout inner ear epithelial cells and neuronal cells. To date, most studies have focused on the role of purinergic receptors in the cochlea, and few studies have examined these receptors in the vestibular system. As purinergic receptors play an important role in the cochlea, they would likely do the same in the vestibular system, which is fairly similar to the cochlea in cellular structure and function. Based on available studies performed to date, purinergic signaling is postulated to be involved in the regulation of ion homeostasis, protection of hair cells, otoconia formation, and regulation of electrical signaling from the sensory epithelium to vestibular neurons. In this review, the distribution and roles of purinergic receptors in the peripheral vestibular system are summarized and discussed.

Functional cooperation between two otoconial proteins Oc90 and Nox3.

Otoconia-related vertigo and balance deficits are common in humans, but the molecular etiology is unknown at present. In order to study mechanisms of otoconia formation and maintenance, we have investigated whether otoconin-90 (Oc90), the predominant otoconial constituent protein, and the NADPH oxidase Nox3, an essential regulatory protein for otoconia formation, are functionally interlinked. We performed balance behavioral, electrophysiological, morphological and molecular cellular analyses. Double heterozygous mutant mice for Oc90 and Nox3 show severe imbalance, albeit less profound than double null mutants. In contrast, single heterozygous mutant mice have normal balance. Double heterozygous mice have otoconia defects and double null mice have no otoconia. In addition, some hair bundles in the latter mice go through accelerated degeneration. In vitro calcification analysis in cells stably expressing these proteins singly and doubly shows much more intense calcification in the double transfectants. Oc90 and Nox3 augment each other's function, which is not only critical for otoconia formation but also for hair bundle maintenance.

Morphological Effect of Vitamin D Deficiency on Globular Substances in Mice.

Many authors, including us, elucidated that vitamin D deficiency was a risk factor for benign paroxysmal position vertigo. We speculated vitamin D deficiency was likely to intervene otoconia formation by globular substance (GS). Kunming mice were randomly divided into three groups: vitamin D sufficient group (12-wk standard control diet), vitamin D deficiency group (16-wk vitamin D deficiency diet), and vitamin D supplement group (16-wk vitamin D deficiency diet and followed 8-wk standard control diet). At 12, 16, and 24 weeks, blood was collected for measuring vitamin D and macula utriculi were obtained for research under scanning electron microscope (SEM). We randomly selected 10 SEM photographs of macula utriculi in each mouse, counted cilium and GS, and measured diameters of counted GS. The ratio of the number of GS to cilium in each SEM photograph was defined as density of GS. The diameter and density of GS were larger and higher in vitamin D deficiency group than sufficient group (p < 0.05; p < 0.05). There was no significant difference in density and diameters of GS between vitamin D deficiency and supplement group. The rough and grainy surface became smoother and smoother along with vitamin D deficiency, and reappeared after vitamin D supplement for 8 weeks. GS secreted as a precursor of mature otoconia is affected by vitamin D deficiency and vitamin D supplementation can mitigate the effects in mice. The density of GS, a quantitative method we designed, can quantify GS well.

Investigation of Serum Calcium and 25-Hydroxy Vitamin D Levels in Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo Patients.

Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) is characterized by recurrent attacks of vertigo caused by head movements. It occurs as a result of otoconia falling into the semicircular canal. Calcium and 25 hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] metabolism in the inner ear play an important role in otoconia formation and degeneration. Our aim in this study was to investigate the relationship between 25(OH)D levels and BPPV. This retrospective, case-controlled study included 52 patients with posterior canal BPPV and 52 controls aged 18 to 80 years. Age, sex, serum calcium, corrected calcium, and 25(OH)D levels of the BPPV and control group were compared. Twenty-three of the patients were male (44.2%) and 29 were female (55.8%). The average age was 55.6 years. The 25(OH)D level was 15.3 ng/mL in the BPPV group and 20.2 ng/mL in controls. There was no significant difference in 25(OH)D and albumin-corrected calcium values (P = .394; P = .084, respectively). In 80.7% of the BPPV group and 61.5% of the controls, 25(OH)D levels were 20 ng/mL and below. 25 hydroxyvitamin D deficiency was found statistically significantly more frequently in patients with BPPV (P = .030). In our study, serum 25(OH)D levels were found to be lower in patients with BPPV, and the rate of vitamin D deficiency was higher in these patients. Based on these results, it is recommended to examine the 25(OH)D levels of patients with BPPV at the time of diagnosis.

Retinoic acid synthesis and autoregulation mediate zonal patterning of vestibular organs and inner ear morphogenesis.

Retinoic acid (RA), a vitamin A (retinol) derivative, has pleiotropic functions during embryonic development. The synthesis of RA requires two enzymatic reactions: oxidation of retinol into retinaldehyde by alcohol dehydrogenases (ADHs) or retinol dehydrogenases (RDHs); and oxidation of retinaldehyde into RA by aldehyde dehydrogenases family 1, subfamily A (ALDH1as), such as ALDH1a1, ALDH1a2 and ALDH1a3. Levels of RA in tissues are regulated by spatiotemporal expression patterns of genes encoding RA-synthesizing and -degrading enzymes, such as cytochromeP450 26 (Cyp26 genes). Here, we show that RDH10 is important for both sensory and non-sensory formation of the vestibule of the inner ear. Mice deficient in Rdh10 exhibit failure of utricle-saccule separation, otoconial formation and zonal patterning of vestibular sensory organs. These phenotypes are similar to those of Aldh1a3 knockouts, and the sensory phenotype is complementary to that of Cyp26b1 knockouts. Together, these results demonstrate that RDH10 and ALDH1a3 are the key RA-synthesis enzymes involved in vestibular development. Furthermore, we discovered that RA induces Cyp26b1 expression in the developing vestibular sensory organs, which generates the differential RA signaling required for zonal patterning.

A mouse model for benign paroxysmal positional vertigo with genetic predisposition for displaced otoconia.

Abnormal formation of otoconia, the biominerals of the inner ear, results in balance disorders. The inertial mass of otoconia activates the underlying mechanosensory hair cells in response to change in head position primarily during linear and rotational acceleration. Otoconia associate exclusively with the two gravity receptors, the utricle and saccule. The cristae sensory epithelium is associated with an extracellular gelatinous matrix known as cupula, equivalent to otoconia. During head rotation, the inertia of endolymphatic fluids within the semicircular canals deflects the cupula of the corresponding crista and activates the underlying mechanosensory hair cells. It is believed that detached free-floating otoconia particles travel ectopically to the semicircular canal and cristae and are the culprit for benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV). The Slc26a4 mouse mutant harbors a missense mutation in pendrin. This mutation leads to impaired transport activity of pendrin and to defects in otoconia composition and distribution. All Slc26a4 loop/loop homozygous mutant mice are profoundly deaf but show inconsistent vestibular deficiency. A panel of behavioral tests was utilized in order to generate a scoring method for vestibular function. A pathological finding of displaced otoconia was identified consistently in the inner ears of mutant mice with severe vestibular dysfunction. In this work, we present a mouse model with a genetic predisposition for ectopic otoconia with a clinical correlation to BPPV. This unique mouse model can serve as a platform for further investigation of BPPV pathophysiology, and for developing novel treatment approaches in a live animal model.

Structures of the otopetrin proton channels Otop1 and Otop3.

Otopetrins (Otop1–Otop3) comprise one of two known eukaryotic proton-selective channel families. Otop1 is required for otoconia formation and a candidate mammalian sour taste receptor. Here we report cryo-EM structures of zebrafish Otop1 and chicken Otop3 in lipid nanodiscs. The structures reveal a dimeric architecture, with each subunit forming twelve transmembrane helices divided into structurally similar amino (N) and carboxy (C) domains. Cholesterol-like molecules occupy various sites in Otop1 and Otop3 and occlude a central tunnel. In molecular dynamics simulations, hydrophilic vestibules formed by the N and C domains and in the intrasubunit interface between N and C domains form conduits for water entry into the membrane core, suggesting three potential proton conduction pathways. By mutagenesis, we test the roles of charged residues in each putative permeation pathway. Our results provide a structural basis for understanding selective proton permeation and gating of this conserved family of proton channels.

Methods for Detection of NOX-Derived Superoxide Radical Anion and Hydrogen Peroxide in Cells.

NADPH oxidases (NOX) are transmembrane enzymes, which catalyze the formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). In humans and most mammals, the NOX family comprises seven members, namely, NOX1-5 and the dual oxidases DUOX1 and 2. The primary product of most NOX isoforms is the superoxide radical anion O2ċ-, which is rapidly dismutated in hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), while NOX4 and DUOX mostly generate H2O2. ROS are multifunctional molecules in tissues, and NOX-derived ROS cellular functions are as diverse as microbial killing (NOX2), thyroid hormone synthesis (DUOX2), or otoconia formation in the inner ear (NOX3). NOX are potential pharmacological targets in numerous diseases such as diabetes, fibrosis, and brain ischemia, and NOX inhibitors are currently under development. Here we describe two cellular assays to detect extracellular O2ċ- and H2O2 in cells overexpressing specific NOX isoforms and their subunits.

Ectopic otoconial formation in the lagena of the pigeon inner ear.

ABSTRACTThe vertebrate inner ear contains vestibular receptors with dense crystals of calcium carbonate, the otoconia. The production and maintenance of otoconia is a delicate process, the perturbation of which can lead to severe vestibular dysfunction in humans. The details of these processes are not well understood. Here, we report the discovery of a new otoconial mass in the lagena of adult pigeons that was present in more than 70% of birds. Based on histological, tomographic and elemental analyses, we conclude that the structure likely represents an ectopically-formed otoconial assembly. Given its frequent natural occurrence, we suggest that the pigeon lagena is a valuable model system for investigating misregulated otoconial formation.This article has an associated First Person interview with the first author of the paper.

Spatiotemporal differences in otoconial gene expression.

Otoconia are minute biocrystals composed of glycoproteins, proteoglycans, and CaCO3 , and are indispensable for sensory processing in the utricle and saccule. Otoconia abnormalities and degeneration can cause or facilitate crystal dislocation to the ampulla, leading to vertigo and imbalance in humans. In order to better understand the molecular mechanism controlling otoconia formation and maintenance, we have examined the spatial and temporal expression differences of otoconial genes in the mouse inner ear at developmental, mature and aging stages using whole transcriptome sequencing (RNA-Seq) and quantitative RT-PCR. We show that the expression levels of most otoconial genes are much higher in the utricle and saccule compared with other inner ear tissues before postnatal stages in C57Bl/6J mice, and the expression of a few of these genes is restricted to the embryonic utricle and saccule. After the early postnatal stages, expression of all otoconial genes in the utricle and saccule is drastically reduced, while a few genes gain expression dominance in the aging ampulla, indicating a potential for ectopic debris formation in the latter tissue at old ages. The data suggest that the expression of otoconial genes is tightly regulated spatially and temporally during developmental stages and can become unregulated at aging stages. Birth Defects Research (Part A) 106:613-625, 2016. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Formation of the inner ear during embryonic and larval development of the cichlid fish (Oreochromis mossambicus)

ABSTRACTBackground: The vertebrate inner ear comprises mineralized elements, namely the otoliths (fishes) or the otoconia (mammals). These elements serve vestibular and auditory functions. The formation of otoconia and otoliths is described as a stepwise process, and in fish, it is generally divided into an aggregation of the otolith primordia from precursor particles and then a growth process that continues throughout life. Results: This study was undertaken to investigate the complex transition between these two steps. Therefore, we investigated the developmental profiles of several inner ear structural and calcium-binding proteins during the complete embryonic and larval development of the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus in parallel with the morphology of inner ear and especially otoliths. We show that the formation of otoliths is a highly regulated temporal and spatial process which takes place throughout embryonic and larval development. Conclusions: Based on our data we defined eight phases of otolith differentiation from the primordia to the mature otolith.

Vestibular dysfunction, altered macular structure and trait localization in A/J inbred mice.

A/J mice develop progressive hearing loss that begins before 1month of age and is attributed to cochlear hair cell degeneration. Screening tests indicated that this strain also develops early onset vestibular dysfunction and has otoconial deficits. The purpose of this study was to characterize the vestibular dysfunction and macular structural pathology over the lifespan of A/J mice. Vestibular function was measured using linear vestibular evoked potentials (VsEPs). Macular structural pathology was evaluated using light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, confocal microscopy and Western blotting. Individually, vestibular functional deficits in mice ranged from mild to profound. On average, A/J mice had significantly reduced vestibular sensitivity (elevated VsEP response thresholds and smaller amplitudes), whereas VsEP onset latency was prolonged compared to age-matched controls (C57BL/6). A limited age-related vestibular functional loss was also present. Structural analysis identified marked age-independent otoconial abnormalities in concert with some stereociliary bundle defects. Macular epithelia were incompletely covered by otoconial membranes with significantly reduced opacity and often contained abnormally large or giant otoconia as well as normal-appearing otoconia. Elevated expression of key otoconins (i.e., otoconin 90, otolin and keratin sulfate proteoglycan) ruled out the possibility of reduced levels contributing to otoconial dysgenesis. The phenotype of A/J was partially replicated in a consomic mouse strain (C57BL/6J-Chr 17(A/J)/NaJ), thus indicating that Chr 17(A/J) contained a trait locus for a new gene variant responsible to some extent for the A/J vestibular phenotype. Quantitative trait locus analysis identified additional epistatic influences associated with chromosomes 1, 4, 9 and X. Results indicate that the A/J phenotype represents a complex trait, and the A/J mouse strain presents a new model for the study of mechanisms underlying otoconial formation and maintenance.

Novel identification of matrix proteins involved in calcitic biomineralization.

Biomineralization is essential for the development of hard tissues in vertebrates, which includes both calcium phosphate and calcium carbonate structures. Calcitic mineralization by calcium carbonate is an important process in the formation of otoconia, which are gravity receptor organs located in the inner ear and are responsible for balance and for sensing linear acceleration. Deficiencies in the regulation of their biomineralization can lead to otoconia degeneration and eventually benign paroxysmal position vertigo (BPPV), which is the main cause of vertigo in humans. Eggshell formation in chicken is one of the fastest known biomineralization processes and is an excellent model for the study of calcitic biomineralization. Cross-analysis of proteomic data from two mineralized models, fertilized and unfertilized chicken eggshells, identified proteins associated with the mammillary cones that are the sites of initiation of eggshell formation. We hypothesize that these proteins regulate the earliest stages of eggshell calcification. The human homologs of these proteins are therefore potential candidates to play a role in otoconia biomineralization.

Effect of Otoconial Proteins Fetuin A, Osteopontin, and Otoconin 90 on the Nucleation and Growth of Calcite.

We investigated the roles of three proteins associated with the formation of otoconia including fetuin A, osteopontin (OPN), and otoconin 90 (OC90). In situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) studies of the effects of these proteins on the growth of atomic steps on calcite surfaces were performed to obtain insight into their effects on the growth kinetics. We also used scanning electron microscopy to examine the effects of these proteins on crystal morphology. All three proteins were found to be potent inhibitors of calcite growth, although fetuin A promoted growth at concentrations below about 40 nM and only became an inhibitor at higher concentrations. We then used in situ optical microscopy to observe calcite nucleation on films of these proteins adsorbed onto mica surfaces. By measuring the calcite nucleation rate as a function of supersaturation, the value of the interfacial energy that controls the free energy barrier to heterogeneous nucleation was determined for each protein. OPN and OC90 films led to significantly reduced interfacial energies as compared to the value for homogeneous calcite nucleation in bulk solution. The value for fetuin A was equal to that for bulk solution within experimental error. Zeta potential measurements showed all of the proteins possessed negative surface charge and varied in magnitude according to sequence fetuin A > OC90 > OPN. In addition, the interfacial energies exhibited an inverse scaling with the zeta potential. In analogy to previous measurements on polysaccharide films, this scaling indicates the differences between the proteins arise from the effect of protein surface charge on the solution–substrate interfacial energy.