The pre-melanosomal protein (Pmel17) is a human functional amyloid that supports melanin biosynthesis within melanocytes. This occurs in the melanosome, a membrane-bound organelle with an acidic intraluminal pH. The repeat region of Pmel17 (RPT, residues 315–444) has been previously shown to form amyloid aggregates under acidic melanosomal conditions, but not under neutral cytosolic conditions, when expressed and purified using a C-terminal hexa-histidine tag (RPT-His). Given the importance of protonation states in RPT-His aggregation, we questioned whether the histidine tag influenced the pH-dependent behavior. In this report, we generated a tagless RPT by inserting a tobacco etch virus (TEV) protease recognition sequence (ENLYGQ(G/S)) immediately upstream of a native glycine residue at position 312 in Pmel17. After purification of the fusion construct using a histidine tag, cleavage with TEV protease generated a fully native RPT (nRPT) spanning resides 312–444. We characterized the aggregation of nRPT, which formed amyloid fibrils under acidic conditions (pH ≤ 6) but not at neutral pH. Characterizing the morphologies of nRPT aggregates using transmission electron microscopy revealed a pH-dependent maturation from short, curved structures at pH 4 to paired, rod-like fibrils at pH 6. This was accompanied by a secondary structural transition from mixed random coil/β-sheet at pH 4 to canonical β-sheet at pH 6. We also show that pre-formed nRPT fibrils undergo disaggregation upon dilution into pH 7 buffer. More broadly, this strategy can be utilized to generate native amyloidogenic domains from larger proteins by utilizing intrinsic N-terminal glycine or serine residues.