Form-induced Stress Research Articles

Double-averaging turbulence characteristics in seeping rough-bed streams

[1] Results of an experimental study on the effects of bed injection (upward seepage from the permeable bed) and suction (downward seepage) on the double-averaged (DA) turbulent flow characteristics over and within the interface of flow gravel beds are presented. The DA Reynolds shear stress within the interfacial sublayer undergoes a higher damping with suction and a lesser damping with injection, as compared to that with no seepage. The form-induced stress within the interfacial sublayer has a decelerating effect with no seepage and suction and an accelerating effect with injection. The quadrant analysis suggests that within the interfacial sublayer the sweep events in flows with injection and the ejection events with suction are the primary contributors toward the Reynolds shear stress production, while both the events in flows with no seepage are equally prevalent. In the roughness sublayer (form-induced and interfacial sublayers together), the mean duration of bursting increases with suction and decreases with injection, but the bursting events become less frequent with suction and more frequent with injection. The analysis of DA higher-order moments confirms that the seepage affects the Reynolds normal stress flux, the turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) flux, and the TKE budget. A downward-upstream flux of TKE is developed within the roughness sublayer with injection; while an upward-downstream flux of TKE is prevalent over the entire flow depth with suction. The significance of this study lies on the hydrodynamic process in such a physical system that may result in modifying the flow resistance, sediment entrainment, and morphological characteristics of a streambed.

Turbulence structure of open channel flows over permeable and impermeable beds: A comparative study

The behavior of turbulent open channel flows over permeable surfaces is not well understood. In particular, it is not clear how the surface and the subsurface flow within the permeable bed interact and influence each other. In order to clarify this issue we carried out two sets of experiments, one involving velocity measurements in open channel flows over an impermeable bed composed of a single layer of spheres, and another one where velocities were measured over and within a permeable bed made of five such layers. Comparison of surface flow velocity statistics between the two sets of experiments confirmed that bed permeability can significantly affect flow resistance. It was also confirmed that even in the hydraulically rough regime, the friction factors for the permeable bed increase with increasing Reynolds number. Such an increase in flow resistance implies a different distribution of normal form-induced stress between the permeable and impermeable bed cases. Subsurface flow measurements performed within the permeable bed revealed that there is an intense transport of turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) occurring from the surface to the subsurface flow. We provide evidence that the transport of TKE toward the lower bed levels is driven mainly by pressure fluctuations, whereas TKE transport due to turbulent velocity fluctuations is limited to a thinner layer placed in the upper part of the bed. It was also confirmed that the turbulence imposed by the surface flow gradually dissipates while penetrating within the porous medium. Dissipation occurs faster for the small scales than for the large ones, which instead are persistent, although weak, even at the lowest bed levels.

Double-averaged velocity and stress distributions for hydraulically-smooth and transitionally-rough turbulent flows

We analyse experimental measurements of turbulent open-channel flow over hydraulically-smooth and transitionally-rough beds using the double-averaging methodology. Oil with a viscosity of 15×10−6 m2/s is used instead of water so that transitional-range roughness Reynolds numbers can be achieved with large (11.1 mm) roughness elements, allowing spatial variations in the mean velocity field to more easily be measured. Distributions of double-averaged velocities, turbulence intensities, form-induced intensities, and viscous, Reynolds, form-induced and total shear stresses are studied with comparisons made between distributions for hydraulically-smooth, transitionally-rough, and fully-rough boundaries. Measured streamwise turbulence intensities for all experiments peaked at a constant distance from the bed (z++d+ = 15) when elevation scale is adjusted using the zero-plane displacement d for the logarithmic velocity distribution. This collapse suggests that turbulence intensity distributions may be useful in assessing appropriate values of d for transitionally-rough and fully-rough boundaries. Form-induced normal and shear stresses above the roughness tops were found to collapse towards a common curve independent of roughness Reynolds number.

Flow analysis in a channel with flexible vegetation using double-averaging method

The paper addresses the problem of the resistance due to vegetation in an open channel flow, characterized by partially and fully submerged vegetation formed by colonies of bushes. The flow is characterized by significant spatial variations of velocity between vertical profiles that make the traditional approach based on time averaging of turbulent fluctuations inconvenient. A more useful procedure, based on time and spatial averaging (Double-Averaging Method) is applied for the flow field analysis and characterization. The vertical distribution of mean velocity and turbulent stresses at different spatial locations has been measured with a 3D Acoustic Doppler Velocimeter (ADV) for two different vegetation densities where fully submerged real bushes (salix pentandra) have been used. Velocity measurements were completed together with the measurements of drag exerted on the flow by bushes at different flow depths. The analysis of velocity measurements allows depicting the fundamental characteristics of both the mean flow field and turbulence. The experimental data show that the contribution of form-induced stresses to the momentum balance cannot be neglected. The mean velocity profiles and the spatially averaged turbulent intensity profiles allow inferring that the vegetation density is a driving parameter for the development of a mixing layer at the canopy top in the case of submerged vegetation. Moreover, the net upward turbulent momentum flux, evaluated with the methodology proposed by Lu and Willmarth (1973), appears to be damped for increased vegetation density; this finding can rationally explain the reduction of the suspended sediment transport capacity typically observed in free surface flows over a vegetated bed.

On the significance of form-induced stress in rough wall turbulent boundary layers

This paper presents a review of recent experimental and numerical studies which deal with the analysis of form-induced stress in rough wall turbulent boundary layers. The aim of the paper is to assess the importance of this stress for various rough wall geometries and flow conditions. Analysis of the significance of form-induced stress is first performed by comparing its magnitude with the magnitude of Reynolds stress for each data set available in literature. Then, by selecting a special set of data, we analyze the comparison between the gradients of both stresses. We point out that the comparison of stress gradients gives a different perspective on the role of form-induced stress in rough wall boundary layers.

Double-Averaged Open-Channel Flows with Small Relative Submergence

We investigate the turbulent structure of shallow open channel flows where the flow depth is too small (compared with the roughness height) to form a logarithmic layer but large enough to develop an outer layer where the flow is not directly influenced by the roughness elements. Since the log layer is not present, the displacement height d, which defines the position of the zero plane, and the shear velocity u* cannot be found by fitting the velocity data to the log law. However, these parameters are still very important because they are used for scaling flow statistics for the outer and roughness layers. In this paper we propose an alternative procedure for evaluating d in laboratory conditions, where d is found from additional experiments with the fully developed log layer. We also point out the appropriate procedure for evaluating the shear velocity u* for flows with low submergence. These procedures are applied to our own laboratory flume experiments with uniform sphere roughness, where velocities were measured using Particle Image Velocimetry. Results were interpreted within the framework of the double-averaged Navier–Stokes equations and include mean velocities, turbulence intensities, Reynolds stresses, and form-induced normal and shear stresses. The data collapse well and show that in flows without a developed log layer the structure of turbulence in the outer layer remains similar to that of flows with a log layer. This means that even though the roughness layer in the experiments reported herein was sufficiently high to prevent the development of the log layer, influence of the bed roughness did not spread further up into the outer layer. Furthermore, the results show that flow statistics do not depend on relative submergence except for the form-induced stresses which increase when relative submergence decreases.

Double-Averaging Concept for Rough-Bed Open-Channel and Overland Flows: Applications

The paper briefly outlines the double-averaging methodology for studying environmental rough-bed flows. It focuses on the applications of this methodology in environmental hydraulics by providing several examples illustrating advantages of this methodology over conventional approaches. Examples include: (1) identification of specific flow layers and flow types; (2) vertical distribution of the double-averaged velocity between the roughness tops and troughs; (3) vertical distribution of momentum fluxes and sinks for typical roughness types due to turbulence, mean flow heterogeneity, secondary currents, form drag, and viscous drag; (4) estimates of form-induced (dispersive) stresses and evaluation of their structure using quadrant analysis; and (5) closure development for mass-transfer-uptake processes for stream periphyton. These examples illustrate the advantages of the double-averaging methodology over conventional approaches as well as highlight its potential for studying flows over very rough beds, hig...

Spatially Averaged Turbulent Flow over Square Ribs

A series of experiments was undertaken to assess fully rough turbulent subcritical flow over two-dimensional transverse repeated-rib roughness of varying spacing λ∕h=1–16 (roughness spacing/height ratio), with h∕H=0.09 (roughness height/flow depth). Each of the 11 experiments involved centerline measurements of three-dimensional velocity vectors, water surface profiles, and bed pressures and forces. The structure of flow over rib roughness consists of a pair of principal vortices of opposite sign set up by the ribs. These vortices are superimposed on an overall double- (time and space)-averaged velocity profile that is (quasi-) logarithmic above roughness tops, and that below roughness tops changes with increasing rib spacing from exponential (λ∕h<10) to linear (λ∕h≥10) to logarithmic (λ∕h≫10) . The measured double-averaged velocity profiles are parameterized herein, and double-averaged Reynolds and form-induced stress profiles and trends are also identified. Maximum drag due to wall roughness is found to...

Bed-Load Effects on Hydrodynamics of Rough-Bed Open-Channel Flows

The extent to which turbulent structure is affected by bed-load transport is investigated experimentally using a nonporous fixed planar bed comprising mixed-sized granular sediment with a d50 of 1.95 mm. Three different sizes of sediment ~d50= 0.77, 1.99, and 3.96 mm! were fed into the flow at two different rates ~0.003 and 0.006 kg /m/s !, and subsequently transported as bed load. Particle image velocimetry ~PIV! was used to determine the turbulence characteristics over the fixed bed during clear water and sediment feed cases. Mean longitudinal flow velocities at any given depth were lower than their clear water counterparts for all but one of the mobile sediment cases. The exception was with the transport of fine grains at the higher feed rate. In this case, longitudinal mean flow velocities increased compared to the clear water condition. The coarse grains tended to augment bed roughness, but fine grains saturated the troughs and interstices in the bed topography, effectively causing the influence of bed irregularities to be smoothed. The PIV technique permitted examination of both temporal and spatial fluctuations in flow variables: therefore many results are presented in terms of double-averaged quantities ~in temporal and spatial domains!. In particular, the form-induced stress, which arises from spatially averaging the Reynolds averaged Navier-Stokes equations and is analogous to the Reynolds turbulent stress, contributed between 15 and 35% of the total measured shear stress in the roughness layer. Flow around protrusive roughness elements produced a significant proportion of the turbulent kinetic energy shear production, suggesting that this process is highly intermittent near rough beds.

Spatially Averaged Open-Channel Flow over Rough Bed

In this paper it is suggested that the double-averaged (in temporal and in spatial domains) momentum equations should be used as a natural basis for the hydraulics of rough-bed open-channel flows, especially with small relative submergence. The relationships for the vertical distribution of the total stress for the simplest case of 2D, steady, uniform, spatially averaged flow over a rough bed with flat free surface are derived. These relationships explicitly include the form-induced stresses and form drag as components of the total stress. Using this approach, we define three types of rough-bed flows: (1) Flow with high relative submergence; (2) flow with small relative submergence; and (3) flow over a partially inundated rough bed. The relationships for the double-averaged velocity distribution and hydraulic resistance for all three flow types are derived and compared with measurements where possible. The double-averaged turbulent and form-induced intensities and stresses for the case of regular spherical-segment-type roughness show the dominant role of the double-averaged turbulence stresses and form drag in momentum transfer in the near-bed region.