While research on the model minority stereotype has focused on white American attitudes, much less research has considered the ways in which Asian Americans understand this concept and its implications. Utilizing frameworks from social psychology and critical race theory we hypothesize that young foreign-born Asian Americans will more likely accept the model minority stereotype than native born Asian Americans due to their likely socialization in a context where their ethnic group was dominant. Further we hypothesize that young Asian Americans who accept the model minority stereotype also accept individualistic explanations for black inequality given that the stereotype implicates non-Asian minorities presumed incompetence and lack of effort on lower socioeconomic outcomes. Third, we hypothesize that US-born Asian Americans’ exposure to the racialized climate of the US will make their belief in the stereotype more salient in predicting individualistic attitudes toward black inequality. We employ OLS regression techniques using survey data from the first wave of the National Longitudinal Survey of Freshmen. We find that the mean level of acceptance to the stereotype does not differ by nativity. However that acceptance, regardless of nativity, is positively associated with individualist explanations for African American inequality. Further, foreign-born status is also linked to anti-black individualist sentiment. When we interact nativity status with belief in the stereotype, we find that foreign-born status is moderated in its effect on individualist beliefs toward African American inequality. Thus, we find that while young foreign-born Asian Americans are more individualistic in their views on racial inequality, native-born acceptance of the stereotype has a more pronounced effect. These findings suggest what we describe as a “choosing sides” logic; acceptance of the model minority stereotype reflects collusion with white dominance at the expense of alienation with other non-white minorities.