This study was conducted to compare the effectiveness of microwave drying with that of conventional forced-air oven drying of rangeland forage species. The data show that a microwave oven can dry grass forage samples for biomass production estimates without significantly affecting their nitrogen or phosphorus levels. Drying in a microwave for 10 minutes was comparable to drying in a forced air oven at 55’ C for 24 hours. In range surveys, mine reclamation permit programs, and other range forage evaluations, large numbers of relatively small clipped forage samples must be dried. Because of the locations of these surveys and programs, many of the workers do not have access to ovens of the size or number capable of drying these samples. Microwave radiation and other drying methods have been evaluated for stopping microbial and physiological processes and for their effects on the chemical components of plant materials (Darrah et al. 1977; Mayland 1968; Mayland et al. 1978). Mayland et al. (1978) evaluated the effect of freeze drying and oven drying at 40, 56, 70 or loo0 C on the extractable phosphorus (P) in alfalfa and sugarbeets. They concluded that the freeze drying, which caused no loss in dry matter, also caused less organic P hydroloysis than did oven drying. Wolf and Carson (1973) reported that microwave heating of alfalfa samples for 30 seconds, followed by forced-air drying was adequate to inactivate respiration. Microwave treatThe authors are soil scientists, U.S. Department of Agriculture, SEA-AR, High Plains Grasslands Research Station, 8408 Hildreth Rd., Cheyenne, Wyoming 82001 and Laramie, Wyoming, respectively. This article is a contribution from the SEA-AR, U.S. Dep. Agr. in cooperation with the Wyoming Agricultural Experiment Station, published as Paper No. JA 1055, Journal Series, Wyoming Agricultural Experiment Station. This research was supported in part by funds from the Environmental Protection Agency, Interagency Agreement: EPA-IAG-D5-E763. 426 ment resulted in similar nonstructural carbohydrates in the tissue when compared to freeze-dried material. Darrah et al. (1977) found that microwave drying caused heat damage to alfalfa and an orchardgrass-ladino clover mixture after only 12 minutes and 2 minutes of exposure, respectively. Also, levels of acid-detergent-insoluble nitrogen (N) were increased when the alfalfa and grass-clover mixture were exposed to microwave drying. However, drying plant material at 100” C in forced air ovens caused more heat damage than microwave drying. Some state regulatory agencies are requiring that forage samples bedried at 1100 C, which is undoubtedly resulting in heat damage and possible carbon loss. We conducted this study to compare the effectiveness of microwave and standard ovens for drying of rangeland forage species. Microwave drying could be very useful for personnel who are required to dry many herbage samples at remote locations to evaluate whether mine reclamation meets the state and federal requirements. Materials and Methods Samples of a native grass mixture [western wheatgrass (Agropyron smithii Rydb.), blue (Bouteloua gracilis (H.G.K.) Lag. ex Griffiths), buffalograss (Buchloe dactyloides (Nutt.) Englem.)] and of crested wheatgrass (Agropyron cristatum (L.) Gaertn.) were collected in mid-June and mid-August 1979 at the High Plains Grasslands Research Station, Cheyenne, Wyoming. Sample sizes were about the same as would be harvested from native range sites and crested wheatgrass seedings using a 1.92-ft2 (0.18-m2) frame. The sample weights for native and crested wheatgrass were 30 and 60 g, representing yields of 1,680 and 3,360 kg/ha, respectively. Samples clipped in June were placed in small paper bags and dried for 7.5 and 10 minutes in a Litton/Minute Master’ micro‘Use of trade name does not imply endorsement of this product by the USDA, but is used for the information of the reader only. JOURNAL OF RANGE MANAGEMENT 34(5), September 1961 Table 1. The comparison of microwave drying and forced air drying on forage moisture content, nitrogen and phosphorus of crested wheatgrass and a native grass mixture. Drying treatment Native grass mixture Estimated % Moist. % N %P Crested wheatgrass Estimated % Moist. % N %P Mid-June harvest* Microwave 7.5 minutes 36a*** 10 minutes 50b 7.5 + 5 minutes 43ab Forced Air Oven 55” C @ 24 hrs 48b Late-August harvest*** Microwave 7.5 minutes 42a 10 minutes 54b 12.5 minutes 54b Forced Air Oven 55” C @iI 24 hrs 53b 1.7a 1.6a .19a .22a 34a 51b 47b -
Read full abstract