Food Plant Preferences Research Articles

Citizen science data reveals the need for keeping garden plant recommendations up-to-date to help pollinators

Widespread concern over declines in pollinating insects has led to numerous recommendations of which “pollinator-friendly” plants to grow and help turn urban environments into valuable habitat for such important wildlife. Whilst communicated widely by organisations and readily taken up by gardeners, the provenance, accuracy, specificity and timeliness of such recommendations remain unclear. Here we use data (6429 records) gathered through a UK-wide citizen science programme (BeeWatch) to determine food plant use by the nations’ bumblebee species, and show that much of the plant use recorded does not reflect practitioner recommendations: correlation between the practitioners’ bumblebee-friendly plant list (376 plants compiled from 14 different sources) and BeeWatch records (334 plants) was low (r = 0.57), and only marginally higher than the correlation between BeeWatch records and the practitioners’ pollinator-friendly plant list (465 plants from 9 different sources; r = 0.52). We found pollinator-friendly plant lists to lack independence (correlation between practitioners’ bumblebee-friendly and pollinator-friendly lists: r = 0.75), appropriateness and precision, thus failing to recognise the non-binary nature of food-plant preference (bumblebees used many plants, but only in small quantities, e.g. lavender—the most popular plant in the BeeWatch database—constituted, at most, only 11% of records for any one bumblebee species) and stark differences therein among species and pollinator groups. We call for the provision and use of up-to-date dynamic planting recommendations driven by live (citizen science) data, with the possibility to specify pollinator species or group, to powerfully support transformative personal learning journeys and pollinator-friendly management of garden spaces.

Bacterial symbionts support larval sap feeding and adult folivory in (semi-)aquatic reed beetles

Symbiotic microbes can enable their host to access untapped nutritional resources but may also constrain niche space by promoting specialization. Here, we reconstruct functional changes in the evolutionary history of the symbiosis between a group of (semi-)aquatic herbivorous insects and mutualistic bacteria. Sequencing the symbiont genomes across 26 species of reed beetles (Chrysomelidae, Donaciinae) spanning four genera indicates that the genome-eroded mutualists provide life stage-specific benefits to larvae and adults, respectively. In the plant sap-feeding larvae, the symbionts are inferred to synthesize most of the essential amino acids as well as the B vitamin riboflavin. The adult reed beetles’ folivory is likely supported by symbiont-encoded pectinases that complement the host-encoded set of cellulases, as revealed by transcriptome sequencing. However, mapping the occurrence of the symbionts’ pectinase genes and the hosts’ food plant preferences onto the beetles’ phylogeny reveals multiple independent losses of pectinase genes in lineages that switched to feeding on pectin-poor plants, presumably constraining their hosts’ subsequent adaptive potential.

Pupation Sites and Conservation of Frosted Elfins (Lycaenidae) in maryland, USA

The frosted elfin (Callophrys irus Godart) is a globally rare butterfly that inhabits disturbance-dependent habitats often managed by prescribed fire. Natural history observations and published data are equivocal on whether frosted elfin caterpillars pupate below or above the soil surface, and some evidence suggests that pupation sites differ for caterpillars that feed on lupine (Lupinus spp.) versus wild indigo (Baptisia spp.). Pupation site has important implications for management because pupae located beneath the soil surface will likely be afforded greater protection from fire than those above the soil surface. Our study of both lupine- and indigo-feeding larvae at a single site in Worcester County, Maryland, found that pupation occurs above the soil surface in the leaf litter 92% of the time, and does not differ significantly with food plant preference. We recommend that land managers using prescribed fire as a habitat management tool for frosted elfin habitat assume some level of pupal mortality in burned areas and utilize a rotational burn schedule that maintains areas of unburned refugia in high-density elfin areas. We also recommend that managers try to establish a metapopulation structure for frosted elfin to address the possibility of natural occurring fires.

Food Plants International database of edible plants of the world, a free resource for all

Fitting food plants into biomes or zones where they grow most naturally remains a challenge and an on-going task. Because the target is feeding people well, agro-sociology must be integral to this agro-ecological task. The increasing pressure on scarce water supplies and growing awareness of environmental pollution and food contamination makes this long-term goal highly desirable. Enriching diets and eating lower on the food chain where plants predominate over meat offers sustainable hope for the future. The Food Plants International database covering 27,000 edible plant species continues to make a significant contribution towards this goal. Increasingly attention is being given to people's food plant preferences and improved ways of preparation to ensuring good nutrition as well as appealing meals. The presentation will provide disks of the database and highlight ways it can be used to focus attention on attractive foods produced sustainably based on a wide range of locally well-adapted food plant resources. The database documents 4,973 edible plants in India, 1,170 in Sri Lanka and 11,155 for the broader Asia region.

Feeding Behavior of Phayre’s Leaf Monkey (Trachypithecus phayrei) and Capped Langur (Trachypithecus pileatus) in Dampa Tiger Reserve, Mizoram

A study on feeding behavior of two primate species viz; Phayre’s leaf monkey (Trachypithecus phayrei, Blyth, 1847) and capped langur (Trachypithecus pileatus Blyth, 1843) was conducted during summer season (March–May, 2014) in Dampa Tiger Reserve (DTR), Mizoram, India. Study was carried out in the Terei range of forest reserve. A total of 87 plant species including bamboo were recorded in the area. Both species of primates (T. phayrei and T. pileatus) were studied for their food plant selection, diet composition, time budget for activities during day. Selection of trees to sleep at night was also observed. Capped langur selected 7 food plant species whereas Phayre’s leaf monkey selected 8 food plants. 40% of the plant species were common to both the primate species; however they showed a distinct variation in food plant preference. Phayre’s leaf monkey spent S 90% of feeding time on Musa ornata, Melacana baccifera and Dendrocalamus longispathus and S 80% Musa balbisiana, Gmelina arborea and Buetneria pilosa; an indication of preference for bamboo species and climbers. Capped langur spent feeding time S 90% on Ficus maclellendi and Ficus semicordata while other species were given comparatively less time. Both the species had consumed young leaves, flowers and fruits in their diet that constitute nearly 80% of the diet. Food items were drawn from different plants. The Phayre’s preferred Dendrocalamus longispathus, (98%) as sleeping site while the Capped langur selected Ficus benghalensis (90%) to sleep at night. Both the species are folivorous in nature but the selection of food plants, source of diet components and plants used to sleep at night were different that indicates that both species has distinct niche within the same habitat type; a very strong survival strategy.

Deidamia inscriptum(Lettered Sphinx Moth) Caterpillars Feeding onOxydendrum arboreum(Sourwood) and Their Predation by Black Bears in Northeast Tennessee

Abstract An outbreak of Deidamia inscriptum (Lettered Sphinx Moth) caterpillars was noted in northeast Tennessee where Oxydendrum arboreum (Sourwood) trees were defoliated. Nearly all published literature and online resources list only plants in the grape family (Vitaceae) as larval food plants. Food-plant preference trials using fresh leaves of 3 woody plant species showed that Deidamia caterpillars from this region had a preference for Sourwood over Parthenocissus quinquefolia (Virginia Creeper), and rejected Acer rubrum (Red Maple), a non-host species. Ursus americanus (Black Bear) were feeding on the caterpillars as evidenced by bent and broken Sourwood saplings bearing claw marks and by abundant sphingid remains in bear scat.

Integrating Insect Life History and Food Plant Phenology: Flexible Maternal Choice Is Adaptive.

Experience of insect herbivores and their natural enemies in the natal habitat is considered to affect their likelihood of accepting a similar habitat or plant/host during dispersal. Growing phenology of food plants and the number of generations in the insects further determines lability of insect behavioural responses at eclosion. We studied the effect of rearing history on oviposition preference in a multivoltine herbivore (Pieris brassicae), and foraging behaviour in the endoparasitoid wasp (Cotesia glomerata) a specialist enemy of P. brassicae. Different generations of the insects are obligatorily associated with different plants in the Brassicaceae, e.g., Brassica rapa, Brassica nigra and Sinapis arvensis, exhibiting different seasonal phenologies in The Netherlands. Food plant preference of adults was examined when the insects had been reared on each of the three plant species for one generation. Rearing history only marginally affected oviposition preference of P. brassicae butterflies, but they never preferred the plant on which they had been reared. C. glomerata had a clear preference for host-infested B. rapa plants, irrespective of rearing history. Higher levels of the glucosinolate breakdown product 3-butenyl isothiocyanate in the headspace of B. rapa plants could explain enhanced attractiveness. Our results reveal the potential importance of flexible plant choice for female multivoltine insects in nature.

Organization of the Olfactory System of Nymphalidae Butterflies

Olfaction is in many species the most important sense, essential for food search, mate finding, and predator avoidance. Butterflies have been considered a microsmatic group of insects that mainly rely on vision due to their diurnal lifestyle. However, an emerging number of studies indicate that butterflies indeed use the sense of smell for locating food and oviposition sites. To unravel the neural substrates for olfaction, we performed an anatomical study of 2 related butterfly species that differ in food and host plant preference. We found many of the anatomical structures and pathways, as well as distribution of neuroactive substances, to resemble that of their nocturnal relatives among the Lepidoptera. The 2 species differed in the number of one type of olfactory sensilla, thus indicating a difference in sensitivity to certain compounds. Otherwise no differences could be observed. Our findings suggest that the olfactory system in Lepidoptera is well conserved despite the long evolutionary time since butterflies and moths diverged from a common ancestor.

What colour of flowers do Lepidoptera prefer for foraging?

Food plant preferences of some Lepidoptera species associated with particular colour of the flowers were investigated. Based on 1,329 field observations of 43 Lepidoptera and 66 plant species, Lepidoptera showed a high tendency (G-test, Gadj = 698.6, df = 6, P < 0.001) to use the yellow (29%) and pink (28%) coloured flowers for foraging. Compared to the other colours it was evident that plants with red flowers (2%) were not preferred. Moreover, the plants with red (H = 0.435) and yellow-white (H = 0.543) flowers were not visited by diverse Lepidoptera species. Although yellow and pink flowers were most frequently visited, the highest degrees of the Lepidoptera diversity values were associated with the plants having blue (H = 0.647) and purple (H = 0.634) flowers. Species of Nymphalidae were most numerous (14 spp.) in the study area and the members of this family were observed 430 times on 39 different plant species, but never on plants with red flowers. Pieris rapae was the most abundant species that occurred 136 times on a total of 21 different plant species of which eight had yellow flowers. But, this species has never been seen while feeding on red flowers.

The biology, ecology and economic importance of the pink scavenger caterpillar Pyroderces rileyi (Lepidoptera: Cosmopterigidae) on banana in Jamaica

AbstractThe pink scavenger caterpillar Pyroderces rileyi Walsingham (Lepidoptera: Cosmopterigidae) is a recent pest of bananas in Jamaica. The larval faecal pellets result in scarring of the banana fruit. The pest occurs on several crops, including cotton, sorghum and maize, across the world. Its biology in Jamaica, food plant preferences and impact of the recommended control method are examined. Adult trapping methods are investigated. Development from egg to adult took an average of approximately 37 days. The number of larvae increases with the age of the bunch, probably due to decreased amounts of latex as the bunch matures. Adult male moths were caught using traps baited with (E)‐11‐tetradecenyl acetate as a pheromone lure. Pheromone lures based on a related species, P. simplex Walsingham, were tested but a second minor (&lt; 10%) component, (E)‐11‐tetradecen‐1‐ol, present in P. simplex did not appreciably enhance the attractancy of the acetate component. Deflowering was effective as a control measure, significantly reducing adult numbers as well as the level of scarring. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley &amp; Sons, Ltd

Object-horning as advertising and marking behaviour in male bushbuck (Tragelaphus scriptus)?

A free-ranging bushbuck (Tragelaphus scriptus) population was observed over a period of 3 years, thereby enabling long-term observations on object-horning behaviour (“horn-rubbing”, “ground-horning” and “horn-thrashing”) in male bushbuck. The primary aim of this study was to determine whether object-horning in male bushbuck serves as demarcation of a territory. Of the three male age classes investigated (territorial males, young-adult bachelors, sub-adult males) adult, territorial males tended to perform object-horning significantly more often than the members of the other two age classes. An analysis of whether territorial males performed object-horning more often in the presence of another individual, which would suggest that object-horning acts as a visual display, revealed that object-horning was predominantly performed when males were solitary. These results suggest that scent-marking and/or leaving visible traces on the vegetation or on the ground plays an important role in territory demarcation. No correlation was detected between food plant preferences and the frequency at which plant species were used for marking.

Taxonomy: DNA barcodes: recent successes and future prospects

Taxonomy: DNA barcodes: recent successes and future prospects

Do food-plant preferences of modern families of phytophagous insects and mites reflect past evolution with plants?

The evolutionary history of phytophagous insects and mites and of their food-plants is traced in the conservative preferences of modern-day insects for plants. Based on UK data in the Phytophagous Insects Data Bank, a correspondence analysis displays 182 insect families and 117 plant families in a bi-variate plot. The overall pattern suggests the expansion of diversity of insects and host plants from Gymnosperms to Dicots. Plots for phytophagous insect orders and major plant clades are described, with families provisionally ranked as evolutionarily basal, intermediate or advanced. There are blurred patterns of evolutionary advancement from basal insect families with more species on conifers and on ferns and Eurosid I trees. Intermediate families are commoner on Malpighiales and Fabales, and advanced insects more frequent on later evolved euasterids II (Asterales and Lamiales), Caryophyllales and Gramineae. Basal Hymenoptera have associations with conifers, basal Lepidoptera to Eurosid I trees, and Diptera are mainly advanced families on commelinids (grasses) and Asteraceae. Blurred traces of similar phylogenetic sequences are described for subfamilies within eight example insect families. Basal families and clades tend to have fewer species than derived advanced clades. Insect communities on plants should be seen in the light of this linked past evolutionary background. © 2003 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2003, 78, 51–83.

The habitat functions of vegetation in relation to the behaviour of the desert locust Schistocerca gregaria (Forskal) (Acrididae: Orthoptera) - a study in Mauritania (West Africa)

The functions of vegetation for the behaviour of gregarious desert locust hop- pers (Schistocerca gregaria (ForskaKl)) are considered in respect to different scales: single plant (taxon, life form), plant community (species composition, dominance, density), and patterns in vegetation and landscape. In the semi-desert of Mauritania, two typical desert locust habitats are phytosociologically characterized. The perennial communities of the tree and shrub layer belong to the alliance Acacio-Panicion with an oceanic Euphorbia balsamifera -Salvadora persica community in a dune-wadi complex characterized by Zy- gophyllum waterlotii , and a more continental Acacia ehrenbergiana -Panicum turgidum community in the inselberg landscape of the Mauritanides. The spatial-temporal move- ment of a hopper band was observed. Hopper band movement depends mainly on wind direction, but is also influenced by patterns in vegetation and landscape morphology. Places giving protection and for moulting are provided by perennials and dense vegetation patches. Length of stay is determined by predation, moulting and food availability. Feed- ing behaviour in the natural habitat depends on food plant preference and the availability of palatable plant species within the plant community. In this study, feeding damage is evaluated both qualitatively and quantitatively using the method Density Analysis with Estimation of Feeding Damage.

Butterfly Response to Microclimatic Conditions Following Ponderosa Pine Restoration

AbstractEfforts to restore ponderosa pine ecosystems to open, park‐like conditions that predominated prior to European‐American settlement result in altered stand structure and increased landscape heterogeneity, potentially altering habitat suitability for invertebrates and other forest organisms. We examined the responses of two butterfly species, Colias eurytheme and Neophasia menapia, to microclimatic changes at structural edges created by experimental restoration treatments in northern Arizona. We monitored microclimate, including air temperature, light intensity, and vapor pressure deficit (VPD), on several mornings during butterfly releases. We placed adult butterflies at east‐ and west‐facing edges approximately one half‐hour before dawn to determine their behavioral response to microclimatic differences between east‐ and west‐facing edges. After sunrise, all three microclimatic variables were higher at east‐facing edges, and the difference in microclimate between the two edge orientations increased through early morning. For both species, butterflies placed at east‐facing edges flew earlier than butterflies at west‐facing edges. Colias eurytheme, an open‐habitat species, tended to move toward the treated forest during initial flight, while movements of Neophasia menapia, a forest‐dwelling species, did not differ from random flight. Our results indicate that butterflies respond to microclimatic factors associated with restoration treatments, while responses to structural changes in habitat vary among species, based on habitat and food plant preferences. These changes in forest structure and microclimate may affect the distribution of many mobile invertebrates in forested landscapes undergoing restoration treatments.

Dietary mixing in three generalist herbivores: nutrient complementation or toxin dilution?

We reared larvae of three generalist insect species on plants occurring in their habitats. Individuals of each species were kept either on mixed diets, or on each plant species separately. We measured food plant preference in the mixed-diet group and compared insect performance on single plants to the performance on the mixed diet. For all three insect species, food choice within the mixed-diet groups was non-random and delivered the best overall performance, thus fulfilling the criteria for self-selected diets. When a single diet was as good as the mixed diet for one particular aspect of performance (Adenostyles alliariae and Petasites albus for Miramella alpina; A. alliariae for Callimorpha dominula), it was never the most preferred food plant in the mixed-diet treatment. Whether the benefit achieved by mixing diets is due to nutrient complementation or toxin dilution, we argue that there is no easy way to distinguish between the two hypotheses on the basis of consumption and performance measurements, as has previously been proposed. From the interpretation of utilisation plots, the ANCOVA equivalent of nutritional indices, we were able to gain insight into where in the sequence from ingestion to growth (preingestive, predigestive or postdigestive) single diets caused differences from mixed diets. The elements of this control system which were influenced by single diets varied considerably, both within and between insect species. No food plant was toxic or deterrent to all experimental insect species; a food plant that caused consumption effects (preingestive) for one insect species could be dealt with metabolically (postdigestive) by another; different food plants could cause behavioural effects (preingestive), metabolic effects (postdigestive), or a combination of both effects, all within the same insect species. However, one generality did emerge: once a food was ingested, further growth-relevant effects occurred metabolically (postdigestive) rather than via differential egestion (digestibility).

The role of parasitoids in evolution of habitat and larval food plant preference by three Pieris butterflies

AbstractThis article attempts to explain that parasitoids provide the evolutionary pressure responsible for relationships between habitat use and larval food plant use in herbivorous insects. Three species of butterflies of the genus Pieris, P. rapae, P. melete, and P. napi use different sets of cruciferous plants. They prefer different habitats composed of similar sets of cruciferous plants. In our study, P. rapae used temporary habitats with ephemeral plants, P. melete used permanent habitat with persistent plants, although they also used temporary habitats, and P. napi used only permanent habitat. The choice experiment in the field cages indicated that each of the three butterfly species avoided oviposition on plants usually unused in its own habitat, but accepted the unused plants which grew outside its own habitat. Their habitat use and plant use were not explained by intrinsic plant quality examined in terms of larval performance. Pieris larvae collected from persistent plants or more long lasting habitats were more heavily parasitized by two specialist parasitoids, the braconid wasp Cotesia glomerata and the tachinid fly Epicampocera succincta. The results suggest that Pieris habitat and larval food plant use patterns can be explained by two principles. The evolution of habitat preference may have been driven by various factors including escape from parasitism. Once habitat preference has evolved, selection favors the evolution of larval food plant preferences by discriminating against unsuitable plants, including those which are associated with high parasitism pressures.

Food Plant Choice of Pieris Butterflies as a Trade‐Off between Parasitoid Avoidance and Quality of Plants

This report assesses the role of specialist parasitoids in providing a major selection pressure for food plant preference in herbivorous insects. Three Pieris butterflies, P. rapae crucivora, P. melete, and P. napi japonica, use different sets of cruciferous larval food plants. P. rapae is oligophagous and uses ephemeral plants. P. melete is polyphagous and uses persistent plants, as well as all of the ephemeral plants used by P. rapae. On the other hand, P. napi is locally monophagous, using persistent Arabis. We assessed the intrinsic suitability of these crucifers by measuring survival rates, development times, and pupal mass of larvae growing on them at a constant temperature. All of the food plants of P. rapae, and P. melete are suitable for larvae of the three Pieris species. On the other hand, food plants of P. napi are the least suitable for all three species. Pieris species. On the other hand, food plants of P. napi are the least suitable for all three species. Pieris larvae have two specialist parasitoids, the braconid wasp Cotesia glomerata (formerly Apanteles glomeratus) and the tachinid fly Epicampocera succincta. In newly established habitats, P. rapae can avoid both parasitoids. In long—lasting habitats, however, P. rapae is heavily parasitized by both parasitoids. P. melete and P. napi, by contrast, live only in long—lasting habitats, where the parasitic pressure is potentially high. However, P. melete can partially avoid parasitism by killing the eggs of C. glomerata by encapsulation, through parasitized by E. succincta. On the other hand, P. napi seems to have evolved behavioral avoidance of parasitoids by specializing on Arabis plants. The different food plant preferences of the three Pieris species can be interpreted as resulting from differences in the balance of a trade—off between parasitoid avoidance and the intrinsic quality of potential food plants of Pieris species.

Food plant preferences and spatial dispersion patterns of the armoured ground cricket, Acanthoplus speiseri Brancsik (Orthoptera: Tettigoniidae)

Food plant preferences and spatial dispersion patterns of the armoured ground cricket, Acanthoplus speiseri Brancsik were investigated. The average numbers of the ground cricket found feeding on each food plant per transect in each of the three study areas were tested for differences at the 0.05 level of probability by Duncan’s multiple range test. The variance/mean ratio (S2/X) was used to analyse spatial dispersion patterns. A. speiseri fed on 12 plant species from the Compositeae, Gramineae and Solanaceae families. Hyparrhenia nyassae (Rendle) Stapf., (Gramineae) and Rottboelia exaitata Linn. f., (Gramineae), were the most preferred food plants. The armoured ground cricket densities on the two food plants were insignificantly different from each other. The cultivated plants, Zea mays L., and Sorghum vulgare Pers., were fed upon opportunistically by the ground crickets. The variance/mean ratio identified aggregation in the armoured ground cricket populations in all three study areas (S2/X > 1, P < 0.001). The significance of the findings on food plant preferences and dispersion patterns are discussed in relation to future sampling and control of A. speiseri.

Biochemical detoxication: mechanism of differential tiger swallowtail tolerance to phenolic glycosides.

Phenolic glycosides, commonly occurring allelochemicals in the plant family Salicaceae, are differentially toxic to subspecies of the eastern tiger swallowtail and responsible for striking differences in the abilities of Papilio glaucus canadensis and P.g. glaucus to utilize the Salicaceae as food plants. This research was designed to test the hypothesis that particularly high esterase activity confers resistance to phenolic glycosides in P.g. canadensis. I conducted larval survival trials in which the phenolic glycosides salicortin and tremulacin were administered with and without inhibitors of the major detoxication enzymes. Results for P.g. canadensis showed that when esterases were inhibited, toxicity of the phenolic glycosides increased greatly. None of the inhibitors significantly increased toxicity of the compounds to P.g. glaucus. I also conducted in vitro assays of the major detoxication enzymes (polysubstrate monooxygenases, esterases, and glutathione transferases) in larval midguts. Soluble esterase activity was 3-fold higher in P.g. canadensis than in P.g. glaucus. Moreover, esterase activity was inducible by prior consumption of phenolic glycosides in P.g. canadensis but not in P.g. glaucus. Glutathione transferases may also be involved in the terminal metabolism of phenolic glycosides. This is the first verified case of detoxication of an allelochemical by esterase enzymes in herbivores. The biochemical adaptation has played an important role in the evolution of food plant preferences in P. glaucus subspecies.