Food Contact Research Articles

Reuterin Enhances the Efficacy of Peracetic Acid Against Multi-species Dairy Biofilm.

Biofilms may contain pathogenic and spoilage bacteria and can become a recurring problem in the dairy sector, with a negative impact on product quality and consumer health. Peracetic acid (PAA) is one of the disinfectants most frequently used to control biofilm formation and persistence. Though effective, it cannot be used at high concentrations due to its corrosive effect on certain materials and because of toxicity concerns. The aim of this study was to test the possibility of PAA remaining bactericidal at lower concentrations by using it in conjunction with reuterin (3-hydroxypropionaldehyde). We evaluated the efficacy of PAA in pure form or as BioDestroy®, a PAA-based commercial disinfectant, on three-species biofilms formed by dairy-derived bacteria, namely Pseudomonas azotoformans PFlA1, Serratia liquefaciens Sl-LJJ01, and Bacillus licheniformis Bl-LJJ01. Minimum inhibitory concentrations of the three agents were determined for each bacterial species and the fractional inhibitory concentrations were then calculated using the checkerboard assay. The minimal biofilm eradication concentration (MBEC) of each antibacterial combination was then calculated against mixed-species biofilm. PAA, BioDestroy®, and reuterin showed antibiofilm activity against all bacteria within the mixed biofilm at respectively 760ppm, 450ppm, and 95.6mM. The MBEC was lowered significantly to 456ppm, 337.5ppm, and 71.7mM, when exposed to reuterin for 16h followed by contact with disinfectant. Combining reuterin with chemical disinfection shows promise in controlling biofilm on food contact surfaces, especially for harsh or extended treatments. Furthermore, systems with reuterin encapsulation and nanotechnologies could be developed for sustainable antimicrobial efficacy without manufacturing disruptions.

Inactivation of Hepatitis A Virus and Feline Calicivirus on Model Food Contact Surfaces by Ultraviolet Light (UV-C) Systems.

Food contact surfaces can harbor and transmit pathogens leading to outbreaks. Decontamination strategies that are user- and environmentally-friendly without toxic by-product formation are needed. Novel UV-C light-emitting diode (LED) technologies are being explored to deliver the required dose to inactivate viruses in food-processing environments. The objective of this study was to compare the effects of 279 nm UV-C LED to 254 nm UV-C against hepatitis A virus (HAV) and feline calicivirus (FCV, a cultivable human norovirus surrogate) on stainless-steel, ceramic, and glass surfaces. Viruses were surface spread on sterile stainless-steel or ceramic coupons (100 μL on 2 × 2 cm2), or glass discs (50 μL on 1 × 1 cm2), air-dried, and UV-C-treated for up to 3.75 min (surface dose = 0-49.2 mJ/cm2 for HAV and 0-24.6 mJ/cm2 for FCV). Each triplicate treatment was assayed in duplicate, and data were statistically analyzed. The D10-values for HAV treated with UV-C at 254 nm on stainless-steel, ceramic, and glass were 9.48 ± 0.34, 14.53 ± 2.52, and 6.91 ± 1.93 mJ/cm2, while with UV-C LED at 279 nm were 19.53 ± 2.45, 26.05 ± 0.60, and 8.77 ± 2.08 mJ/cm2, respectively. The D10-values for FCV treated with UV-C at 254 nm on stainless-steel, ceramic, and glass were 3.65 ± 0.06, 6.25 ± 1.90, and 4.69 ± 0.03 mJ/cm2, while with UV-C LED at 279 nm were 7.097 ± 2.11, 8.31 ± 2.12, and 7.88 ± 0.86 mJ/cm2, respectively. Higher 279 nm UV-C doses were needed to inactivate HAV and FCV compared to 254 nm UV-C on the tested surfaces. Novel UV-C LED systems using appropriate doses show promise to inactivate foodborne viruses on food contact surfaces.

Antilisterial effect of alkyl polyglycosides biosurfactant and modes of action

Several outbreaks of Listeria monocytogenes originated mainly from contaminated contact surfaces. Thus, this study investigated the antilisterial effect of natural surfactants in terms of their use as a 2-in-1 sanitizing washer on a food contact surface and evaluated their modes of action. The antilisterial activity of alkyl polyglycosides (APGs), namely capryl glucoside (CA), coco glucoside (CG), and decyl glucoside (DG), was evaluated based on the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) and the minimum bactericidal concentration (MBC) using broth dilution assay. The results showed that CG had the strongest antilisterial activity. Therefore, CG was selected for further investigation. The time-kill assay showed a lethal effect of 0.5 % (w/w) CG by inactivating 4 Log reduction (99.99 %) of L. monocytogenes within 3 s. Furthermore, 1 % (w/w) CG with slight mechanical force in washing (by shaking) was efficient for sanitizing a stainless-steel coupon surface based on its ability to cause a total reduction of deposited L. monocytogenes (99.9 %) within 10 min. Scanning electron microscopy and applying Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy revealed that CG chemically disrupted the cell wall and plasma membrane of L. monocytogenes within 5 min after a gentle wash. The results showed it had potent antimicrobial activity and was bactericidal against L. monocytogenes. Overall, our results supported the use of CG as a natural antibacterial surfactant to alter the chemical sanitizer and the possibility of its practical use in the food industry and for household use.

Biofilm formation comparison of Vibrio parahaemolyticus on stainless steel and polypropylene while minimizing environmental impacts and transfer to grouper fish fillets

This study investigated the influence of food contact surface materials on the biofilm formation of Vibrio parahaemolyticus while attempting to minimize the impact of environmental factors. The response surface methodology (RSM), incorporating three controlled environmental factors (temperature, pH, and salinity), was employed to determine the optimal conditions for biofilm formation on stainless steel (SS) and polypropylene (PP) coupons. The RSM results demonstrated that pH was highly influential. After minimizing the impacts of environmental factors, initially V. parahaemolyticus adhered more rapidly on PP than SS. To adhere to SS, V. parahaemolyticus formed extra exopolysaccharide (EPS) and exhibited clustered stacking. Both PP and SS exhibited hydrophilic properties, but SS was more hydrophilic than PP. Finally, this study observed a higher transfer rate of biofilms from PP to fish fillets than from SS to fish fillets. The present findings suggest that the food industry should consider the material of food processing surfaces to prevent V. parahaemolyticus biofilm formation and thus to enhance food safety.

Characterization of a novel phage SPX1 and biological control for biofilm of Shewanella in shrimp and food contact surfaces

Shewanella putrefaciens, commonly found in seafood, forms tenacious biofilms on various surfaces, contributing to spoilage and cross-contamination. Bacteriophages, owing to their potent lytic capabilities, have emerged as novel and safe options for preventing and eliminating contaminants across various foods and food processing environments. In this study, a novel phage SPX1 was isolated, characterized by a high burst size (43.81 ± 3.01 PFU/CFU) and a short latent period (10 min). SPX1 belongs to the Caudoviricetes class, exhibits resistance to chloroform, and sensitivity to ultraviolet. It shows stability over a wide range of temperatures (30–50 °C) and pH levels (3−11). The genome of phage SPX1 consists of 53,428 bp with 49.72 % G + C composition, and lacks tRNAs or virulence factors. Genome analysis revealed the presence of two endolysins, confirming its biofilm-removal capacity. Following the treatment of shrimp surface biofilm with the optimal MOI of 0.001 of phage SPX1 for 5 h, the bacterial count decreased by 1.84 ± 0.1 log10 CFU/cm2 (> 98.5 %). Biofilms on the surfaces of the three common materials used in shrimp processing and transportation also showed varying degrees of reduction: glass (1.98 ± 0.01 log10 CFU/cm2), stainless steel (1.93 ± 0.05 log10 CFU/cm2), and polyethylene (1.38 ± 0.1 log10 CFU/cm2). The study will contribute to phage as a novel and potent biocontrol agent for effectively managing S. putrefaciens and its biofilm, ensuring a reduction in spoilage bacteria contamination during the aquaculture, processing, and transportation of seafood products.

Determination of Some Element’s Migrants in Aqueous Simulant from Plastic Food Contact Products by Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer

Various chemicals present at different stages in the food supply chain can lead to the leaching of heavy metals. These metals can accumulate in the human body through the consumption of contaminated food. Consequently, it is necessary to validate an analytical technique for the quantification chemical that could contaminate food. This study presents a rapid, straightforward, and efficient analytical method for the direct quantification of some potentially toxic elements in aqueous simulants from plastic food contact products using an inductively coupled mass spectrometer (ICP-MS). The method’s validation encompassed the study of the estimated detection limits, practical quantification limits, linearity, accuracy, and measurement uncertainty of aluminium (Al), antimony (Sb), arsenic (As), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), cobalt (Co), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), lead (Pb), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni), and zinc (Zn) under optimized ICP-MS conditions. The estimated detection limits ranged from 7.5 × 10−4 to 0.074 mg/kg, while practical quantification limits spanned from 0.02 to 0.8 mg/kg. The average recoveries ± standard deviations at different spiking levels were varied between 85.7 ± 1.51 and 115.6 ± 0.88% with coefficients of variation between 0.42 and 5.85%. The method trueness was verified by using references materials (test material in aqueous acetic acid) purchased from Food Chemistry Proficiency Testing and Analysis (FAPAS) yielding satisfactory results within acceptable recovery and Z-score values. The method precision, in terms of relative standard deviation (RSD), was being below 4.22%. The method uncertainty expressed as expanded uncertainty of all validated elements was found to be ≤ 21.9%. Validated method was employed to determine specific elements in aqueous simulants of thirty commercial plastic food packaging samples, representing three distinct types of plastic polymers. The results showed that the mean concentrations, in mg/kg, were as follows: 2.04 (Al), 0.02 (As), 0.02 (Cd), 0.02 (Co), 0.06 (Cr), 0.41 (Cu), 1.55 (Fe), 0.09 (Mn), 0.15 (Ni), 0.07 (Pb), 0.05 (Sb), and 0.81 (Zn). Furthermore, 30% of analyzed samples exceeding the maximum permissible limits of Al for plastic materials and articles intended to come into contact with food.

Pulsed Light Technology: Is it Sustainable?

Abstract Pulsed light is a non-thermal method that was initially researched for microbial inactivation using high-power, broad-spectrum light pulses, with the UV-C light portion being the most lethal. This method was introduced to the Western hemisphere with the Hiramoto US patent in 1984 and was developed by PurePulse Technologies. It obtained the FDA approval for food use in 1996 and has been under continuous study and testing by academic institutions since 1998. It is linked to sustainable development goals 2, 3, 6, and 12, but its relation to goal 13 is particularly important, although hindered by lack of data. While numerous applications beyond microbial inactivation have been developed, only two are currently used industrially, namely, the decontamination of food contact surfaces for packaging and the enhancement of vitamin D concentration in edible fungi. Other potential applications include enzyme inactivation, phytochemical synthesis, water pollutant degradation, protein allergen inactivation, mycotoxin inactivation, modification of functional properties of proteins, and starch modification. The main advantage of pulsed light is its rapid effects although it is limited to surfaces and transparent liquids. Further refinement of dosimetry should facilitate the easier scaling up of laboratory results to more industrial applications. Information © The Author 2024

Extractable Perfluoroalkyl Carboxylic Acids and Sulfonates in Food Contact Materials: Development of a Simple Analytical Method with Ultrasonic Extraction, Dispersive Sorbent Clean-Up, and LC-MS/MS Quantification

Extractable Perfluoroalkyl Carboxylic Acids and Sulfonates in Food Contact Materials: Development of a Simple Analytical Method with Ultrasonic Extraction, Dispersive Sorbent Clean-Up, and LC-MS/MS Quantification

P19-36 Dietary exposure assessment to plasticisers migrating from food contact materials

P19-36 Dietary exposure assessment to plasticisers migrating from food contact materials

P04-06 The unspoken challenges of the use of polystyrene as food contact material

P04-06 The unspoken challenges of the use of polystyrene as food contact material

P16-06 Food Contact Chemicals (FCCs): risk assessment of combined exposure to endocrine disruptors chemicals

P16-06 Food Contact Chemicals (FCCs): risk assessment of combined exposure to endocrine disruptors chemicals

Determination of Diffusion Coefficients of Bisphenol A (BPA) in Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET) to Estimate Migration of BPA from Recycled PET into Foods

Bisphenol A (BPA) is a known substance that is found in food contact materials as an intentionally added as well as a non-intentionally added substance. Traces of BPA were found as a non-intentionally added substance in recycled PET (rPET). In 2023, the EFSA proposed a new TDI of 0.0002 µg/kg bw/d, which is lower than the previous (temporary) TDI of 4 µg/kg bw/d by a factor of 20,000. The TDI of 0.0002 µg/kg bw/d would translate for a default 60 kg person eating one kilogram of food into a migration limit of 0.012 µg/kg in the food. This very low migration limit is a challenge to measuring BPA levels in food. A solution is to use migration modeling to establish maximum concentrations in rPET for different food contact applications. Precise diffusion coefficients for BPA in PET were determined within this study by use of migration kinetics. In June 2024, the European Commission proposed a new migration threshold limit for BPA of 1 µg/kg, which should be understood as a detection limit. From the results of this study, it can be concluded that a BPA concentration in the PET bottle wall of 297 mg/kg (3% acetic acid), 255 mg/kg (10% ethanol), and 192 mg/kg (20% ethanol) after storage for 365 d at 25 °C is in compliance with the migration threshold limit of 1 µg/kg. These maximum concentrations are far above the measured BPA concentrations on rPET bottles in Europe between 2019 and 2023. Therefore, the new proposed migration threshold limit for BPA cannot be exceeded.

Leaching of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from food contact materials with implications for waste disposal

Leaching of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) during the post-consumer disposal of food contact materials (FCMs) poses a potential environmental threat but has seldom been evaluated. This study characterized the leaching behavior of PFAS and unidentified precursors from six common FCMs and assessed the impact of environmental conditions on PFAS release during disposal. The total concentration of 21 PFAS ranged from 3.2 to 377 ng/g in FCMs, with PFAS leachability into water varying between 1.1–42.8 %. Increasing temperature promoted PFAS leaching, with leached nine primary PFAS (∑9PFAS) reaching 46.3, 70.4, and 102 ng/L at 35, 45, and 55 ℃, respectively. Thermodynamic analysis (∆G>0, ∆H>0, and ∆S<0) indicated hydrophobic interactions control PFAS leaching. The presence of dissolved organic matter in synthetic leachate increased the leached ∑9PFAS from 47.1 to 103 ng/L but decreased PFBS, PFOS, and 6:2 FTS leaching. The total release of seven perfluorocarboxylic acids (∑7PFCAs) from takeaway food packaging waste was estimated to be 0.3–8.2 kg/y to landfill leachate and 0.6–15.4 kg/y to incineration plant leachate, contributing 0.2–4.8 % and 0.1–3.2 % of total ∑7PFCAs in each leachate type. While the study presents a refined methodology for estimating PFAS release during disposal, future research is needed on the indirect contribution from precursors.

Advancing Analytical Techniques in PET and rPET: Development of an ICP-MS Method for the Analysis of Trace Metals and Rare Earth Elements.

Despite the extensive use of recycled polyethylene terephthalate (rPET) in food contact materials (FCMs), research on the presence of heavy metals (HMs) and rare earth elements (REEs) during various recycling stages (e.g., flakes, granules, and preforms) remains limited. This study aimed to address these gaps by validating a rapid and sensitive analytical method to quantify 26 HMs and 4 REEs in PET and rPET matrices. An ICP-MS method was validated per EURACHEM guidelines, assessing linearity, limits of detection (LOD), limits of quantification (LOQ), accuracy, and repeatability. The method was employed for initial screening of HMs and REEs classified as non-intentionally added substances (NIASs) in PET and rPET samples. The findings showed high accuracy and reliability, with recovery rates between 80% and 120%. Analysis revealed varying concentrations of HMs and REEs, with the highest levels in 100% rPET preforms, notably Zn, Cu, and Al among HMs, and La among REEs. The study identified critical contamination points during the recycling process, highlighting the need for targeted interventions. This research provides a crucial analytical framework for assessing HMs and REEs in PET and rPET, ensuring FCM safety compliance and supporting efforts to enhance rPET product safety, promoting public health protection and advancing the circular economy.

Development of a solid food simulant to evaluate migration of chemicals from paper and board food contact materials to moist food

Food contact materials (FCMs) i.e. materials that food is packaged or handled in, must be safe for their intended use. European FCM legislation uses a risk-based approach, with a cornerstone of FCM’s safety evaluation being measurement of migration of substances from FCMs to food simulants. The standard methods mainly developed for plastic FCMs are not always suitable for less inert and moisture sensitive materials such as paper and board. However, these are becoming increasingly common as FCMs e.g. to replace single-use plastics. In addition, there is a drive to further use recycled materials. To support this development, new methods for assessing the safety of these materials are needed. In the present feasibility study, a hydrogel crosslinked through freeze-thawing of poly(vinyl alcohol) was evaluated as a food simulant for moist foods. The migration of surrogate compounds from a spiked paperboard to the hydrogel was determined and compared to the migration to a real moist food (a slice of apple), the commonly used modified polyphenylene oxide (MPPO) and a water extract. Migration of polar surrogates to the hydrogel correlated well with the migration to the apple slice. However, our results indicate that the hydrogel is less suitable as simulant for non-polar surrogates. Overall, the study demonstrates the potential of this hydrogel-based simulant for improving risk assessment of less inert FCMs.

β-Cyclodextrin/calix[4]arene hybrid porous organic polymer membrane for synergistic extraction of fluorescent whitening agents migrating from food contact materials

Acurate and sensitive determination of hazards from food contact materials is important to monitor food safety. It is necessary to excavate efficient adsorbent for simultaneous recognition and adsorption of food hazards of trace level for sample preparation. In this work, β-cyclodextrin and calix[4]arene were employed as hybrid functional monomers to prepare macrocyclic porous organic polymer (β-CD-CX4 POP). It was proved that the supramolecular cavities of β-CD-CX4 POP could form inclusion complexes with fluorescent whitening agents (FWAs) through host-guest recognition, which greatly improved the adsorption performance. The hydrophobic cavities of β-cyclodextrin and calix[4]arene of β-CD-CX4 POP exhibited synergistic effect for simultaneous recognition of FWAs. The high-throughput enrichment of FWAs was realized by β-CD-CX4 POP membranes coupled with a multiple-channel syringe pump. Based on membrane-based solid-phase extraction combined with UHPLC-MS/MS, a sensitive analytical method was established to determine six FWAs. The LODs was in range of 3-50 ng/L with the linear range of 0.02-100 μg/L. The developed method was used to quantify FWAs in bread wrapper and bread, and the spiked recoveries ranged from 78.1%-119% with RSD of 2.3%-9.7%. This work indicated that β-CD-CX4 POP was promising for the simultaneous recognition and adsorption of FWAs migrating from food contact materials.

Comparative study of the structure and durability of commercial silicate glasses for food consumption and cosmetic packaging

Four commercial glass compositions were investigated to understand their mechanisms of alteration in light of the current and future regulations on food contact materials. Lead crystal (fine glassware), soda-lime (food and cosmetic containers), borosilicate (cookware) and barium glass (tableware) powders and slabs were altered for 3 years, in acetic acid (4% vol) at pH = 2.4 and 70 °C. The leaching solution was analyzed by ICP-AES while glass slabs were investigated by ToF-SIMS and Spectroscopic Ellipsometry. As a result, in acidic medium, the polymerization of the silicate network as well as the glass composition impacted the alteration rates and depleted depths of alkalis and earth-alkalis elements. Yet the rate of hydrolysis measured from the release of Si, remained similar under identical alteration conditions, whatever the glass structure and composition. For lead crystal glass, repolymerization of the silicate network was observed in the course of alteration.

Identification and health risk assessment of volatile and semi-volatile migrants along with chemical elements in food contact water-borne coating paper

Water-borne coating paper, with its food contact potential, raises concerns due to unknown contaminants. Herein, the presence and migration of volatile and semi-volatile compounds, along with chemical elements from two water-borne coating paperboards were investigated using 4 % acetic acid, 50 % ethanol, and 95 % ethanol, while also evaluating associated health risks. The results showed that the overall migration to 95 % ethanol from both papers indicated the non-compliance with the reference limit of 10 mg/dm2. Utilizing an optimized direct immersion-solid-phase microextraction coupled to gas chromatography-mass spectrometry method, a total of 66 migrants were identified, among which 16 and 7 were classified as Cramer Ⅲ and Cramer Ⅱ, respectively, linked to coating and paper raw materials. Additionally, 28 chemical elements released from papers were analysed using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, where higher levels of elements (i.e., Na, K) were observed in the migration of 4 % acetic acid, potentially from additives or raw materials used in papermaking processes. More importantly, health risk assessment based on the Threshold of Toxicological Concern approach or worst-case dietary intake assumption indicated that, the estimated daily intake of most migrants and chemical elements through human exposure fell below toxicological reference values. However, certain migrants (e.g., 2-ethylhexyl acrylate, methyl benzoate, phenanthrene, and longifolene) exhibited concerning migration levels in 50 % ethanol and 95 % ethanol that exceed their safety thresholds and may pose health risks. Overall, understanding the migration and potential risk of migrants are imperative for ensuring the safety of using commercially available water-borne coating paper in food contact applications.

Microbiological safety assessment of restaurants and HACCP-certified kitchens in hotels: A study in eastern China

The Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) system plays a crucial role in ensuring food safety within food service establishments, effectively reducing the risk of foodborne diseases. This study focused on assessing the risk of microbe contamination in poultry-based cook-served food during meal preparation in four restaurants and five selected HACCP-certified hotels in eastern China. We examined samples collected from 26 poultry-based cooked dishes, 248 food contact surfaces, 252 non-food contact surfaces, and 121 hand swabs. Our findings indicated a favorable trend of compliance with Chinese national standards, as Escherichia coli and Campylobacter were not detected in any cooked food samples. However, the microbiological assessments revealed non-compliance with total plate count standards in 7 % of the cooked samples from restaurants. In contrast, both dine-in hotels and restaurants exhibited significant non-compliance with guidance concerning food and non-food contact surfaces. Furthermore, our study found that chefs' hand hygiene did not meet microbiological reference standards, even after washing. Notably, Campylobacter persisted at 27 % and 30 % on chefs' hands, posing a significant risk of cross-contamination and foodborne diseases. These findings emphasize the urgent necessity for enhanced supervision of hygiene procedures and process monitoring in the HACCP-certified establishments engaged in the preparation and serving of food. Targeted interventions and food safety education for different chef subgroups can enhance food handling practices and reduce the risk of foodborne diseases in independent food establishments.

Chemical and toxicological characterization of food contact recycled paperboard extracts

Food contact paperboard poses a potential risk of food contamination due to the possible release of chemicals (intentionally added or not), particularly in recycled paperboard. Water extractions were performed, according to wet food procedures, of paperboard samples collected from a manufacturer at the beginning and the end of a recycling production chain. Chemical analysis and hormonal activities in vitro of water extracts were studied. ICP–MS analysis confirmed the presence of 15 trace elements with lower concentrations after the recycling process, with the exception of chlorine. The chromatographic analyses demonstrated that the identified substances in the starting paperboard, before the recycling process, were approximately twice as high as in the end paperboard, after the recycling process. These substances included also natural wood products, chemical additives, and undesirable substances such as phthalates. Two major products (3,5-di-tert-butylphenol and methyl-2-pyrrolidone) were found in the starting and the end paperboard extracts, respectively. Two common substances were identified in both extracts: 2,4-di-tert-buthylphenol and dehydroabietic acid. Evaluation of potential endocrine disruption showed that the starting paperboard extract exhibited oestrogenic and antiandrogenic effects, while these effects nearly disappeared in the end paperboard extract. These results confirmed that the recycling process was effective in removing most of the contaminant substances.