The discovery of a novel sphingolipid subclass, the (1-deoxy)sphingolipids, which lack the 1-hydroxy group, attracted considerable attention in the last decade, mainly due to their involvement in disease. They differed in their physico-chemical properties from the canonical (or 1-hydroxy) sphingolipids and they were more toxic when accumulated in cells, inducing neurodegeneration and other dysfunctions. (1-Deoxy)ceramides, (1-deoxy)dihydroceramides, and (1- deoxymethyl)dihydroceramides, the latter two containing a saturated sphingoid chain, have been studied in this work using differential scanning calorimetry, confocal fluorescence and atomic force microscopy, to evaluate their behavior in bilayers composed of mixtures of three or four lipids. When compared to canonical ceramides (Cer), a C16:0 (1-deoxy)Cer shows a lower miscibility in mixtures of the kind C16:0 sphingomyelin/cholesterol/XCer, where XCer is any (1-deoxy)ceramide, giving rise to the coexistence of a liquid-ordered phase and a gel phase. The latter resembles, in terms of thermotropic behavior and nanomechanical resistance, the gel phase of the C16:0 sphingomyelin/cholesterol/C16:0 Cer mixture [Busto et al., Biophys. J. 2014, 106, 621–630]. Differences are seen between the various C16:0 XCer under study in terms of nanomechanical resistance, bilayer thickness and bilayer topography. When examined in a more fluid environment (bilayers based on C24:1 SM), segregated gel phases are still present. Probably related to such lateral separation, XCer preserve the capacity for membrane permeation, but their effects are significantly lower than those of canonical ceramides. Moreover, C24:1 XCer show significantly lower membrane permeation capacity than their C16:0 counterparts. The above data may be relevant in the pathogenesis of certain sphingolipid-related diseases, including certain neuropathies, diabetes, and glycogen storage diseases.