Water-extractable cereal flour constituents influence bread loaf specific volume, suggesting a contribution to gas cell (de)stabilization in dough. However, the underlying mechanism remains largely unexplored. We studied the impact of incorporating five cereal flour aqueous extracts in model gluten-starch bread (doughs) on specific volume, dough extensional rheology, and protein extractability changes during bread making. Incorporating wheat, rye, or triticale flour aqueous extracts in gluten-starch doughs increased bread specific volume by 12–17%. There were no changes in dough rheology that could explain this specific volume increase, suggesting that other mechanisms relating to gas cell stabilization might be at play. Incorporating oat flour aqueous extracts decreased bread specific volume by 50%. This negative impact was related to poor dough strain hardening behavior, in turn probably explained by disruption of intermolecular glutenin disulfide bonds, as revealed by chromatography. While this study has provided a novel perspective on the mechanisms by which water-extractable cereal flour constituents influence bread volume, it also demonstrates that the compositional heterogeneity of the flour aqueous extracts needs to be addressed to allow an even better understanding of the role of water-extractable cereal flour constituents in stabilizing gas cells in bread dough.