Flexible Electronics Research Articles

Silver Nanoparticle-Decorated Cellulose Nanocrystal Reinforced Ionic Polymer Hydrogel With High Conductivity and Environmental Tolerance for Multifunctional Sensing and Emergency Alarm System.

Conductive hydrogels hold great promise for flexible electronics. However, the simultaneous achievement of satisfactory mechanical strength, outstanding environmental tolerance, high sensitivity, and multiple sensing applications in a single conductive hydrogel remains a significant challenge. Herein, ionic polymer-based hydrogels with a double conductive network consisting of [2-(methacryloyloxy)ethyl] trimethyl ammonium chloride (DMC), 2-hydroxyethyl acrylate (HEA) and silver nanoparticle decorated cellulose nanocrystal (CNC@Ag) are prepared by a facile one-pot method. The resultant hydrogel (CDH) exhibits high stretchability, satisfactory self-adhesion, excellent environment tolerance (from -60 to 60°C), long-term stability (60 days), effective UV-shielding, and strong antibacterial properties. Significantly, the CDH hydrogel displays high conductivity and rapid response due to its double conductive network of ionic polymer and CNC@Ag. Therefore, the CDH-assembled sensor can accurately detect signals from both strain and pressure deformations, exhibiting outstanding sensitivity and reliability for human motion detection, signal transmission, object recognition, and tactile sensing. More interestingly, collaborating with a development board, the CDH-based sensor can be developed as an emergency alarm to realize prompt alarms in dangerous situations. Overall, this work presents a strategy for the fabrication of conductive hydrogel with remarkable properties, making it possible for multifunctional sensing applications in wearable electronics.

Informatics-based design of polyaniline-carbon nanotube thermoelectric nanocomposite using ANN and GA

Abstract Conducting polymer and carbon nanotube (CNT) based nanocomposites have emerged as prospective thermoelectric (TE) materials due to their potential application in flexible electronics. Non-conventional charge and heat transport in these nanocomposites, presents the possibility to enhance the TE conversion efficiency, given by ZT. However, the highly non-linear and complex association of structure and composition with the overall TE properties have hindered the development of any general strategy to develop high ZT nanocomposites. Here, we implement artificial neural network (ANN) and genetic algorithm (GA) to develop data driven models followed by optimization to design high efficiency nanocomposites based on CNT dispersed in polyaniline (PANI) matrix. Our models suggest that CNT concentration plays the most crucial role in determining ZT. Non-dominated Pareto optimal solutions consisting of different combinations of design variables are obtained by multi-objective optimization. Although a range of optimal solutions span over different regions of the search space, in general we note that longer CNTs boost Seebeck coefficient (S) and electrical conductivity (σ), and smaller length lowers thermal conductivity (k), while higher diameter of CNTs increase S and lowers σ and k. The results provide a general guideline for developing CNT-PANI nanocomposites with enhanced TE figure of merit.

Nanomaterials for Flexible Neuromorphics.

The quest to imbue machines with intelligence akin to that of humans, through the development of adaptable neuromorphic devices and the creation of artificial neural systems, has long stood as a pivotal goal in both scientific inquiry and industrial advancement. Recent advancements in flexible neuromorphic electronics primarily rely on nanomaterials and polymers owing to their inherent uniformity, superior mechanical and electrical capabilities, and versatile functionalities. However, this field is still in its nascent stage, necessitating continuous efforts in materials innovation and device/system design. Therefore, it is imperative to conduct an extensive and comprehensive analysis to summarize current progress. This review highlights the advancements and applications of flexible neuromorphics, involving inorganic nanomaterials (zero-/one-/two-dimensional, and heterostructure), carbon-based nanomaterials such as carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and graphene, and polymers. Additionally, a comprehensive comparison and summary of the structural compositions, design strategies, key performance, and significant applications of these devices are provided. Furthermore, the challenges and future directions pertaining to materials/devices/systems associated with flexible neuromorphics are also addressed. The aim of this review is to shed light on the rapidly growing field of flexible neuromorphics, attract experts from diverse disciplines (e.g., electronics, materials science, neurobiology), and foster further innovation for its accelerated development.

Crack Development and Electrical Degradation in Chromium Thin Films Under Tensile Stress on PET Substrates

The mechanical and electrical deterioration of chromium (Cr) thin films sputtered onto polyethylene terephthalate (PET) substrates under tensile strain was studied. Understanding mechanical and electrical stability due to imposed strain is particularly important for device reliability, as the demand for flexible electronic devices increases. Cr thin films, widely spread across the field of electronic and sensor applications, face crack propagation with electrical degradation with tensile stress that can seriously compromise the performance. Accordingly, this study offers new findings on how Cr film thickness might influence crack formation and electrical resistance differently and also the general guidelines for flexible electronic component design with respect to long-term durability. Electrical resistances were measured while mechanically stretching 100- and 200 nm thin sheets. The study focused on crack development and propagation mechanisms in both film thicknesses and their effects on percentage change in electrical resistance (PCER). Scanning electronic microscopy (SEM) was used to characterize surface morphology and observe cracks as the strain rose. Early crack formation in 100 nm Cr films led to rapid PCER increases due to quick crack propagation and fast electrical degradation. Thicker 200 nm films, however, showed a more gradual PCER rise with fewer but deeper cracks, indicating a regulated strain response. Unlike the sharp PCER spike in 100 nm films, 200 nm samples were more variable, with three out of four showing a slight PCER decrease at the end, hinting at partial crack repair or conductive realignment before full failure. These results underscore the role of layer thickness in managing crack propagation and electrical stability, relevant for flexible electronics and strain sensors. This paper is aligned with the ninth goal of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, specifically Target 9.5: Enhance Research and Upgrade Industrial Technologies.

Bacterial Cellulose Applications in Electrochemical Energy Storage Devices.

Bacterial cellulose (BC) is produced via the fermentation of various microorganisms. It has an interconnected 3D porous network structure, strong water-locking ability, high mechanical strength, chemical stability, anti-shrinkage properties, renewability, biodegradability, and a low cost. BC-based materials and their derivatives have been utilized to fabricate advanced functional materials for electrochemical energy storage devices and flexible electronics. This review summarizes recent progress in the development of BC-related functional materials for electrochemical energy storage devices. The origin, components, and microstructure of BC are discussed, followed by the advantages of using BC in energy storage applications. Then, BC-related material design strategies in terms of solid electrolytes, binders, and separators, as well as BC-derived carbon nanofibers for electroactive materials are discussed. Finally, a short conclusion and outlook regarding current challenges and future research opportunities related to BC-based advanced functional materials for next-generation energy storage devices suggestions are proposed.

Multiscale Analyses of Strain-Enhanced Charge Transport in Conjugated Polymers.

The advancement of flexible and wearable electronics relies on semiconducting polymers that can endure mechanical deformation while maintaining high electrical performance under strain. In this study, we demonstrate that fine-tuning backbone rigidity through the molecular design of donor moieties significantly enhances both the mechanical and charge transport properties of diketopyrrolopyrrole (DPP)-based polymers. Specifically, the flexible DPP-4T (quaterthiophene) exhibited a persistence length of 20.4 nm in solution, while DPP-DTT (dithienothiophene) showed a longer persistence length of 32.8 nm due to its stiff backbone, as confirmed by small-angle neutron scattering and Monte Carlo simulations. This flexibility enabled DPP-4T to achieve a crack-onset strain exceeding 100% via the film-on-elastomer method and a fracture strain of over 30% in quasi-free-standing films. Additionally, DPP-4T demonstrated a 180% increase in hole mobility at 80% strain, driven by strain-induced chain alignment and backbone planarization. Utilizing a range of characterization techniques, including ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) spectroscopy, grazing incidence X-ray diffraction (XRD), and Raman spectroscopy, we characterized structural changes at multiple length scales under applied tensile strain. Notably, strain induced a transformation in chain conformation from a twisted to a flat structure, reducing the hopping energy barrier and enhancing charge transport. These structural rearrangements are crucial for sustaining efficient charge transport and ensuring the reliability of electronic performance under mechanical stress.

Compact Layer‐Free Perovskite Solar Cells with Low‐Temperature UVO Photochemical Annealed Mesoporous TiO2 Layers

In recent years, the field of perovskite solar cells (PSCs) has seen rapid development, with most high‐efficiency devices incorporating dense titanium dioxide (TiO2) barrier layers and mesoporous TiO2 layers to enhance selective electron transport. However, the manufacturing process requires high‐temperature sintering steps above 450 °C, leading to significant energy consumption. In addition, this requirement greatly limits the potential applications of PSCs in the field of flexible electronics. This study introduces a new method for preparing dense‐layer‐free mesoporous PSCs using low‐temperature UVO annealing of m‐TiO2. UVO annealing effectively removes residual organic components from m‐TiO2 precursor films, enhances the conductivity and wettability of the films, thereby reducing carrier recombination and improving the performance of PSCs. Research has shown that PSC with a 40 min UVO annealed m‐TiO2 layer exhibits a final photoelectric conversion efficiency of 17.79%, comparable to devices with traditional high‐temperature annealed m‐TiO2 PSCs. In addition, after 7 days at room temperature and ambient humidity, the unpackaged device maintains a maximum conversion efficiency of 84%. These findings indicate that UVO light annealing is a feasible alternative to high‐temperature annealing, providing a simpler, more cost‐effective, and energy‐saving method for the preparation of metal oxide electron transport layer in PSCs.

Cyanogel-Transformed Porous Palladium and Iron Framework Intermixed with rGO for Wearable Hydrogen Sensing.

Wearable hydrogen (H2) sensing is necessary to monitor the H2 leakage in its transportation and storage, of which ppm-concentration detection limit and fast response at room temperature are highly desired. Here, a wearable H2 sensing working at room temperature is developed with palladium and iron framework intermixed with reduced graphene oxide (rGO//Pd-Fe FW), which is synthesized by combined Pd-Fe cyanogel immobilized with graphene oxide as precursor and in situ reduction. As-prepared rGO//Pd-Fe FW is observed with porous FW structure composed of interconnected Pd-Fe nanoparticles, in which rGO is evenly intermixed. Beneficially, rGO//Pd-Fe FW exhibits 2ppm low detection limit and 2 s fast response (1 v/v% H2) at room temperature. Such excellent H2 sensing performance may be attributed to the synergistic effect of the optimized Pd-Fe FW's catalytic activity, boosted electron transfers between Pd hydride and rGO, and enriched adsorption sites over porous FW's surface. Practically, the perceptron learning algorithm combined with principal component analysis is conducted to identify the H2 leakage, and the wearable H2 sensing devices are built by integrating rGO//Pd-Fe FW over the paper and flexible printed circuit board with reliable sensing responses.

Environment-tolerant, inherently conductive and self-adhesive gelatin-based supramolecular eutectogel for flexible sensor

Although hydrogels have attracted increasing attention in the stretchable devices, the low adhesion properties and poor environmental adaptation still seriously restrict their development and application. Herein, we focused on the interaction between polymer networks with disperse media and their resultant influence on gel performance, and constructed self-adhesive and environment-tolerant gelatin/polyacrylamide supramolecular-polymer double-network (Gelatin/PAM SP-DN) eutectogels using multiple supramolecular interactions between natural macromolecule and well-designed deep eutectic solvent (DES). The dual networks of Gelatin/PAM SP-DN eutectogels produced significant supramolecular forces with DES, including hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interaction, contributing to enhance the energy dissipation capacity. Additionally, the Gelatin-PAM SP-DN eutectogels were more prone to generate strong bonding force to various substrates, showcasing both in-situ and ex-situ adhesion performance, and even being used for wet and underwater adhesion. The eutectogels revealed excellent environmental tolerance to maintain excellent mechanical flexibility, conductivity and adhesion at high and low temperatures, ensuring the constructed sensor to sensitively and reliably perceive strain, pressure and human motions over a wide temperature range. Also, the eutectogel demonstrated great potential as a temperature sensor. This work opens up a new horizon in the design of multifunctional and environment-tolerant natural macromolecule-based gel materials for flexible electronics, human-machine interaction and health diagnosis.

Electrospun green fluorescent-highly anisotropic conductive Janus-type nanoribbon hydrogel array film for multiple stimulus response sensors

A new strategy aimed at significantly enhancing the anisotropic conductivity of hydrogel materials, along with a simple construction technology and design concept, are proposed. Anisotropic conductive hydrogel materials have attracted much attention from researchers in the field of flexible electronics for their inherent excellent properties. However, the anisotropic conductivity of the existing conductive hydrogels is not high and the preparation methods are complex. Herein, fluorescent-highly conductive anisotropic Janus-type nanoribbon hydrogel array film (named JNHAF) is successfully prepared using a combination of parallel electrospinning and post-polymerization as an example of the study. Highly oriented [2,7-dibromo-9-fluorenone (DF)/gelatin (GE)]//[carbon black (CB)/GE] Janus-type nanoribbon is used as the building block. The composition as well as the arrangement of Janus-type nanoribbons are microscopically designed and regulated to effectively separate the conductive and insulating materials, so that the samples can achieve highly anisotropic conductivity and obvious green fluorescence. When the mass ratio of GE to CB is 1:0.1, the conductive anisotropy ratio of JNHAF can reach 1.12 × 105. The degree of anisotropic conductivity of JNHAF is significantly improved compared with existing reported anisotropic conductive hydrogels, and the preparation method is simple. JNHAF responds quickly to light, tensile strain, and temperature, making it suitable for assembling multi-stimulus responsive sensors. JNHAF has excellent flexibility, degradability, mechanical properties and a certain degree of sensitivity (gauge factor of 4.29), and is used for human joint motion detection with an obvious response signal. The design idea and construction technology of this hydrogel breaks through the technical bottleneck of the low degree of anisotropy of conductive hydrogels, which will lead and expand the scientific frontiers of anisotropic conductive hydrogel materials, and provide novel design ideas and theoretical values for new hydrogel materials.

Volumetric 3D printing of ionic conductive elastomers for multifunctional flexible electronics

Flexible electronics based on ionic conductive elastomers (ICE) hold significant potential for applications in smart wearables, self-powered sensing, and human-computer interaction. However, current fabrication techniques constrain ICE-based ionic electronic components to simplified volumetric geometries, limiting their functionality. This work reports a volumetric 3D printing (V3DP) for fabricating flexible electronic components with excessive transparency, high conductivity, excellent thermal stability, and superior adhesion. By controlling the light dose, this printing technique enables precise modulation of the printed structures' mechanical properties. Furthermore, V3DP greatly improves the processing efficiency of high-viscosity ionic conductive liquids and makes it easier to prepare composite structures, combining different conductive mechanisms through unique overprinting. This study provides a promising strategy for preparing multifunctional, liquid-free, ionic flexible electronics, such as strain sensors and ionic-electronic triboelectric nanogenerators (iTENG).

High-strength polyvinyl alcohol/gelatin/LiCl dual-network conductive hydrogel for multifunctional sensors and supercapacitors

The synthesis of conductive hydrogels with high mechanical strength, toughness, optimal fracture growth rate and the capability to detect diverse human body movements poses a significant challenge in the realm of flexible electronics. In this study, a one-pot technique utilized effectively to fabricate conductive materials by doping LiCl into a mixture of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and gelatin. The PVA/gelatin/LiCl0.3(PGL) conductive hydrogel demonstrates exceptional robustness, flexibility, and resistance to deformation, enabling the monitoring of various physiological signals such as temperature and humidity. Additionally, the PGL demonstrates exceptional elongation properties (up to 1111.32 %), high lifting capacity (up to 25 kg), resistance to deformation, and sustained stability of peak signals even after 300 cycles at 50 % strain. The hydrogel electrolyte exhibits a conductivity of 2.114 S/m at 25 °C and a specific capacitance of up to 48.75 F/g, along with favorable mechanical and electrochemical characteristics. These findings suggest that the PVA/gelatin/LiCl0.3 hydrogel supercapacitor (PGLSC) conductive hydrogel shows significant potential for integration into flexible electronics and wearable technology devices.

Constructing a multifunctional reactive MXene-based additive for micro-crosslinking polyurea elastomer to achieve superior mechanical properties and enhanced fire safety

The widespread application of polyurea (PUA) in protective coatings typically requires excellent flame retardancy due to real-world usage scenarios. However, the addition of flame retardant additives often compromises the material’s mechanical properties. In this study, a multifunctional reactive additive, MX-SP-NH2, was creatively prepared by covalently grafting spirocyclic pentaerythritol bisphosphorate disphosphoryl chloride (SPDPC) onto MXene (Ti3C2Tx) surfaces, followed by the introduction of 1,3-propanediamine (PDA) by the reaction with SPDPC. MX-SP-NH2 was then incorporated into PUA, participating in its crosslinking process and significantly enhancing both its mechanical strength and flame retardancy. Compared to the control PUA sample, the micro-crosslinked PUA sample with just 1.0 wt% MX-SP-NH2 demonstrated a 184.3% increase in tensile strength, a 126.1% increase in elongation at break, and a 436.3% increase in toughness. The flammability characterization revealed that the peak heat release rate, peak smoke production rate, and peak CO production rate were reduced by 31.7%, 28.9%, and 61.5%, respectively, indicating a substantial improvement in fire safety. Additionally, the flame retardant PUA-based flexible strain sensors demonstrated stable electrical signal responsiveness. This work has opened up new potential applications of PUA in flexible electronics.

Silica conversion of polysilazanes by low-temperature plasma jet generated from Ar and water-vapor mixed gas

Perhydropolysilazane (PHPS), which contains no organic catalyst, chemically reacts with H2O in the atmosphere by heating it at 450 °C for more than 1 h to turn it into a SiO2 film. If silica conversion can be achieved at temperatures below 100 °C, which plastics can withstand, it may be applicable to a wide range of applications, such as flexible electronics. Here, we report a technique for forming SiO2 films with leakage current characteristics very close to those of thermally oxidized (THOX) films that works at a very low temperature of 52 °C with high speed. Using a 9-kV, 30-kHz power supply, a low-temperature plasma jet containing a gas mixture of Ar and water vapor irradiated an 8 nm thick PHPS thin film, inducing silica conversion at a maximum substrate temperature of 52 °C. The current density-electric field strength (J-E) characteristics of metal oxide semiconductor capacitors fabricated with this SiO2 film showed characteristics very close to those of THOX films. In addition, the mechanism of silica conversion of PHPS through low-temperature plasma jet irradiation using this gas mixture was clarified in real-time FT-IR measurements.

Optoelectronic effect of Al-based buffer layers on Al-doped ZnO thin transparent conductive films on flexible substrates

AZO (Al-doped ZnO) film is a transparent conductive film that offers a simple preparation process, low cost, non-toxicity, and excellent stability. It serves as a high-quality material extensively used in liquid crystal displays, solar cells, and other fields. In this study, AZO thin films were prepared on a PET substrate with an Al2O3 buffer layer using the magnetron sputtering method. The deposition parameters were optimized through the Taguchi method and Grey Correlation Analysis. The results demonstrate that the optimal deposition parameters for achieving superior photoelectric properties during the fabrication of AZO films are 100 W (radio frequency power), 1.0 Pa (sputtering pressure), 20 min (coating time), and 20°C (substrate temperature). Furthermore, the incorporation of an Al2O3 buffer layer enhances the quality of AZO film on PET substrate. This investigation successfully deposited uniform and highly efficient AZO thin films onto flexible PET substrates at low temperatures, thereby expanding their potential applications in flexible electronics.

Self-adhesive, mechanically strong, and conductive organogel for flexible/wearable electronics and underwater electronic skin

Due to their flexibility, self-healing ability, and biocompatibility, conductive hydrogels have become excellent candidates for flexible electronics. However, challenges remain, such as water evaporation when exposed to air, resulting in a loss of flexibility and conductivity. Additionally, traditional hydrogels quickly swell underwater, which causes irreversible damage to their structure and electrical properties. As a promising alternative, organogels have gained attention for overcoming these drawbacks. Here, we report a transparent, multifunctional organogel using ultraviolet-initiated polymerization, which exhibits excellent adhesion, robustness, electrical and interfacial stability, and super stretchability. By adjusting the concentration of the lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (LiTFSI), the conductivity of organogel could be easily regulated from non-conductive to conductive, obtaining non-conducting elastomer (NCE, without LiTFSI) and ion-conducting elastomer (ICE, with LiTFSI) with identical mechanical properties and superior adhesion due to the same composing polymer chains. This unique characteristic overcomes the interface mismatch problem of traditional flexible electronic devices. Moreover, a high-performance triboelectric nanogenerator (TENG) was designed (ICE-TENG) to achieve a maximum power density of 151.3 μW cm−2, which was utilized to power small electronics. Additionally, a strain sensor was constructed using the ICE, realizing underwater sensing and communication with high stability. This multifunctional organogel is promising for multi-functional human–machine interaction.

Time-dependent constitutive behaviors of a dynamically crosslinked glycerogel governed by bond kinetics and chain diffusion

Soft materials featuring dynamic networks represent a burgeoning frontier in materials science, offering multifaceted applications spanning soft robotics, biomaterials, and flexible electronics. Unraveling the time-dependent constitutive behavior of these materials, rooted in dynamic networks, stands as a pivotal pursuit for engineering advancements. Herein, we fabricate a tough and extreme-temperature-tolerant glycerogel with a polymer network crosslinked by metal-coordination crosslinkers and conduct a thorough analysis of its intricate mechanical responses across monotonic loading, relaxation, creep, and cyclic tests. We then develop a physically grounded constitutive model integrating the dynamics of crosslinker association/dissociation and polymer chain diffusion, furnishing a holistic framework to elucidate their interplay. We employ a statistical description, using density functions of chains in terms of end-to-end vectors, to characterize network reconfiguration. The evolution of chain density under external load, mediated by crosslinker kinetics and chain diffusion in a viscous medium, leads to intriguing variations in elastic energy and stress responses. Through meticulous experimental validation and numerical simulations, we demonstrate the efficacy of the model in forecasting the mechanical behavior of dynamic polymer networks under diverse loading scenarios, encompassing strain rate effects, stress relaxation, Mullins effect, and self-recovery phenomena. Our findings provide valuable insights into the design and optimization of dynamic network-based materials for diverse applications in biomedical and engineering fields.

Stretchable carbon Nanotube/Ecoflex conductive elastomer films toward multifunctional wearable electronics

Conductive elastomer films (CEFs) have found widespread applications toward flexible electronics and wearable devices. Silicones are particularly advantageous for fabricating high-performance CEFs. However, processing silicone/conductive filler composite prepolymers is challenging because of their high viscosity, especially when incorporating nanofillers like carbon nanotubes (CNTs) that can greatly increase the viscosity of silicone prepolymers. Herein, we present a simple, facile and versatile hexane-assisted air-spraying method for fabricating silicone-based CEFs from Ecoflex and CNTs. This method allows for processing CNT/Ecoflex prepolymers with CNT concentrations of 0.5 ∼ 5 wt%, resulting in stretchable CEFs with controllable structural, mechanical and electrical properties. We leveraged the distinct advantages of CNT/Ecoflex CEFs, including the excellent mechanoelectrical sensitivity, workable strain range and elasticity of the CNT1/Ecoflex group, and the high conductivity and low mechanoelectrical sensitivity of the CNT5/Ecoflex group. These properties enable their multifunctional applications as wearable and waterproof resistive strain sensors, multilayered capacitive pressure sensors, and wearable electric heaters. This work provides valuable insights into the development of high-performance and multifunctional silicone-based composite materials for advanced wearable electronics.

Compact Vital-Sensing Band with Uninterrupted Power Supply for Core Body Temperature and Pulse Rate Monitoring.

Although wearable devices for continuous monitoring of vital signs have undergone significant advancements, their need for frequent recharging precludes continuous operation, potentially leading to adverse outcomes being overlooked. Additionally, the scattered locations of the sensors hamper wearability. Herein, we present a compact vital-sensing band with uninterrupted power supply designed for continuous monitoring of core body temperature (CBT) and pulse rate. The band─which comprises two sensors, a power source (i.e., a flexible thermoelectric generator (TEG) and a battery), and a flexible circuit─is worn on the forearm. The CBT is calculated by measuring the skin temperature and heat flux, while a triboelectric nanogenerator-based self-powered pressure sensor is utilized for pulse rate monitoring. The TEG is a flexible unit that converts body heat into electricity, accumulating a total energy of 314 mJ (100%). Out of this total energy, only 43.2 mJ (7.2%) is utilized for CBT measurements, while the remaining 270.80 mJ (92.8%) is stored in the battery. This enables reliable and continuous operation of the vital-sensing band, highlighting its potential for use in healthcare applications.

Mass-loaded suspended piezoelectric micromachined ultrasonic transducer array towards flexible stretchable electronics evaluation

Mass-loaded suspended piezoelectric micromachined ultrasonic transducer array towards flexible stretchable electronics evaluation