The “aromatic maturity” of winegrapes is not fully understood, particularly during the later stages of ripening. The contribution of grapes to wine aroma has historically been challenging to determine, given most aroma compounds originate from nonvolatile precursors. In this study, an analytical approach previously developed for red winegrapes was adapted to assess the “aroma potential” of Riesling from two vineyards in Essenheim and Durbach, Germany, during the 2022 vintage, by extracting and hydrolyzing aroma precursors in an anoxic model wine matrix. Following sensory and chemical analyses of the hydrolysates using flash profiling and gas chromatography, a multiple factor analysis revealed vineyard- and ripening-dependent changes to aroma, even after total soluble solids had plateaued. As samples matured, green apple and fresh/vegetal aromas were prominent among the Durbach hydrolysates, likely due to persistent concentrations of hexanol. Hydrolysates from both vineyards nonetheless developed more pronounced citrus fruit, tropical fruit, and floral aromas, reflecting increased concentrations of various norisoprenoids and terpenoids. Findings suggest delaying harvest past technological maturity could confer greater aromatic intensity and complexity. The analytical approach used here appears promising for future studies on other grape varieties and other factors that could influence aroma, such as viticultural practices and environmental conditions.