Recently, Pearson, and Maddi (1966) presented evidence that the Similes Preference Inventory (SPI) may serve as a rapid screening device for assessing tendency toward variety. An inspection of the task posed by the SPI suggested the alternative hypothesis that preferential judgment for the ending to common similes (e.g., Hot as . . .) is linked to established traits within the personality sphere. Specifically, the purpose of the srudy was to investigate the relationship between performance on the SPI and the Sixteen Personality Factor (16 PF) Questionnaire. The SPI, 54 multiple-choice items, was administered to 162 (76 male, 86 female) undergraduates at Western Washington State College. Each item was scored on a fivepoint scale proposed by Pearson and Maddi (1966) yielding results whereby low total score indicated a tendency to select usual and common place endings to common similes, while a high total score indicated a tendency to select unusual and novel alternatives. A basic set of source traits in the personality sphere was measured with the 16 PF (Cattell & Eber, 1964) ; both Forms A and B were administered for maximum dependability of measurement (Meredith, 1966). At the first-order level, seven factors on the 16 PF correlated significantly with SPI total score. When these findings were ordered from most salient to least salient, tendency toward variety was associated with being imaginative (M+; r = .35, p < .01), assertive (E+; r = .27, p < .01), expedient (G-; r = -.25, p < .01), tender-minded (I+; r = .24, p < .01), sell-sufficient (Qcf; 7 = .19, p < .05), experimenting (QL+; r = .17, p < .05), and abstract-thinking (B+; r = .17, p < .05). In addition, standard weights for estimating S's endowment on the higher-order factors of the 16 PF were applied to transform Ss sten (standard 10-point) scores on the primaries to sten scores on the secondaries. In terms of the seven major higher-order factors, tendency toward variety was significantly relared to independence (r = .37, p < .01) and creativity (r = .28, p < .01). The remaining broad factors (anxiety, extraversion, tough poise, neurolicism, and leadership) were unrelated to SPI performance. The pattern of relationships suggests that preference for unusual simile endings is indicative of a self-directing, imaginative, flexible, and innovative type of person. However, the magnitude of the relationships portends caution in over-generalizing from the SPI to the real world. The present writer would concur with Pearson and Maddi (1966, p. 308) that a good deal of research is needed to support the clinical use of the instrument.
Read full abstract