The so-called Second Memoire of Evariste Galois, written in 1 830 and first published in 1 846, is notoriously difficult to understand. Already the title 'Des equations primitives qui sont solubles par radicaux' requires considerable thought. For, the word 'primitive', which has a standard meaning in the context of group theory now, had no such context or meaning when Galois used it. I have two goals in the present paper: first, to give an account of the development of the concept of primitivity in finite group theory in the 19th century; secondly, to provide commentary on the first part of the Second Memoire. These may appear to be two separate projects for which two separate papers would be appropriate. I combine them into one because, as the reader will see, they are in fact so closely related as to be almost inseparable. Hence my choice of an ambiguous title. I also have two categories of reader in mind: historians and mathematicians. For the former, but also because one cannot discuss the history of the mathematics without having the details in front of one, I give expositions of some basic theory of equations and groups. For the latter I rehearse some of the known facts about Galois' writings. Almost certainly the Second Memoire was written in 1830 (see [18, p. 494]). It was first published in 1846 by Liouville [15] and there have been several re-publications since, culminating in the critical edition of 1962 by Robert Bourgne and J.-P. Azra [18]. It is an unfinished first draft, nowhere near as much revised or as important as the Premier Memoire. Nevertheless, where the Premier Memoire describes what we now think of as Galois Theory, the Second Memoire focusses heavily on groups and, as we shall see, has had, through the work of Camille Jordan and others, an important influence on group theory. It provides moreover a significant piece of evidence about the workings of the mind of an extraordinarily creative and intuitive young genius. Either one of these facts would be reason to make it worthy of intensive study; together they are compelling. The Second Memoire is in two parts. The first is about finite soluble equations and groups, the second about the groups we now call AGL (2, p) and PSL (2, p). The present paper is concerned only with the first part I propose to write about the second part on some other occasion.
Read full abstract