In Imagining the Heartland: White Supremacy and the American Midwest, anthropologists Britt E. Halvorson and Joshua O. Reno jump into the hazy pool of assumptions and images associated with the Midwest and emerge with a compelling case for the ways in which banal, uninterrogated discourse about the region directly service and uphold White supremacy. Rejecting a static notion of region and instead referring to the Midwest as a knot of narratives or a canvas for nationalist projections, they pull together seemingly fragmented examples to show how Midwest Whiteness is created and recreated regardless of material reality. For example, they begin by showing how imagining heartlands as strongholds of virtuous White labor and property ownership propels and maintains settler colonialism and Indigenous dispossession in the United States and beyond. The core of the book then draws together a smattering of cultural products to make claims about how Whiteness operates, even—especially—when depictions do not explicitly address race. From Regionalist paintings and familiar images of an agrarian Midwest landscape to the poetry of Robert Bly or Henry Ford’s anti-Semitic publications, the region is often imagined as homogenous and insular, which in turn can be interpreted as either virtuous or deplorable. Either way, it bolsters nationalism and White supremacy by instructing observers on the features of ideal Whiteness. Similarly, a chapter co-authored with Jada Basdeo looks at fictional characters like Dorothy Gale and Clark Kent to show how the creation of “intimate others” informs audiences on the merits and shortcomings of “plain” Midwest Whiteness. Meanwhile, several classic horror films utilize the Midwest as a backdrop of White ordinariness and safety, even as the region’s actual historical serial killers are placed outside of the Midwest in film portrayals. Imagining the Heartland then culminates with a chapter co-authored with Lena Hanschka that shows how the now well-established mechanisms of White supremacy were deployed in mass media from 2010 to 2019 in depictions of the suffering White farmer or industrial worker in the Midwest.
Read full abstract