908 Reviews Werk neben dem Werk: Tagebuch und Autobiographie bei Robert Musil. By Con stanze Breuer. (Germanistische Texte und Studien, 82) Hildesheim: Olms. viii+356 pp. 49.80. ISBN 978-3-487-13944-9. Musil wrote around 1900 in his Tagebiicher that diaries are a sign of the times: they are the easiest and least disciplined form, so that in the future perhaps only diaries would be written. He attributed to the diary form both much and little importance, suggesting a paradox that is reflected in his own itinerary as a writer. Among Musil's firstwritings are fictional diary entries, found inwhat may, or may not, be real diaries; and at the end of his lifehe was writing other fictional diaries for his protagonist Ulrich, who, in the unpublished chapters ofDer Mann ohne Eigenschaften, iswriting them to describe his quest for something like Utopia. Musil apparently did not intend to publish themiscellany of manuscripts now called his diaries, and it isnot even clear what part of the extant unpublished novel manuscripts he would have published, ifany, had he lived long enough to finish the novel. In dealing with these complexities, the strength of Constanze Breuer's study of the diaries is to show that selected passages from them can illuminate some themes as well as the nature of fiction in several ofMusiFs works. Notably, these consi derations allow her, for example, to contest the idea that the final version ofDie Versuchung der stillen Veronika is to be understood as a diary. And she argues that the diaries show that MusiFs reaction to World War I is of paramount importance for understanding him. Much ofwhat is presented here is not new, although two of Breuers interpretations do strikeme as contributions to the ongoing debates about MusiFs work. First, Breuer argues that certain brief passages in the diaries suggest thatMu silwas using a religious framework for his enigmatic novella Die Amsel. Breuer contends that the three framed stories inDie Amsel refer obliquely toWhitsun, Epiphany, and Easter, but in such a way as to show that the 'secularization of religion' contests the possibility of religion today (p. 194). By referring obliquely to a religious model, the tale shows that the narrator's experience is 'incommen surable' with a religious explanation, for there is a break between the twoworlds. This rather ingenious interpretation perhaps draws upon interpretations of Kafka to show that the religious text exists in the narrative text even as the narrated text annuls it. Secondly, Breuer argues that the Utopian idea of 'another condition' thatUlrich seeks inDer Mann ohne Eigenschaften should be understood in terms of classical aesthetics. Breuer's interpretation of the 'other condition' is thatMusil wanted to develop the idea of an individual Utopia in order then to show that it could not exist; with this her interpretation affirms that the telos of the novel would have been a critique of its own Utopia from a rationalist viewpoint. In this regard it is similar to several recent interpretations, but Breuer draws upon the diaries, especially 'Heft 35', to argue in addition that the other condition is neither a mystical state nor Romantic effusiveness, but an aesthetic experience dependent MLR, 105.3, 201o 909 upon a recognition of the limitations of the subject (p. 329). Drawing analogies with Goethe's analysis of aesthetic sensation, Breuer's interpretation ispersuasive. It places Musil in themainstream of German aesthetics, and for the reader who finds that the other condition' is an opaque notion, she shows that Musil, like Joyce and Proust to whom he is so often compared, believed that somehow literature is a transcendental matter in a world without transcendence?and cannot offer a Utopian solution to the historical problems thathad driven Musil into exile. University of Missouri Allen Thiher Kafka lesen: Acht Textanalysen. By Marko Pajevic. Bonn: Bernstein. 2009. 112 pp. 12.80. ISBN 978-3-939431-37-4. 'Verkehrmit Gespenstern: Gothic und Moderne bei Franz Kafka. By Barry Murnane. (Klassische Moderne, 12) Wurzburg: Ergon. 2009. 413 pp. 48. ISBN 978-3-89913-599-2. These two new approaches toKafka could inmany ways hardly be more different. Marko Pajevic's Kafka lesen provides, as the title suggests, 'eine prazise Lekture' (p...