PROFESSOR BALFOUR'S “Class Book of Botany” is too well and favourably known to botanists, whether teachers or learners, to require any introduction to our readers. It is, as far as we know, the only work which a lecturer can take in his hand as a safe text-book for the whole of such a course as is required to prepare students for our university or medical examinations. Every branch of botany, structural and morphological, physiological, systematic, geographical, and palæontological, is treated in so exhaustive a manner as to leave little to be desired. The illustrations also form, when enlarged, the very best set of diagrams that a lecturer can have. After this, it may seem hypercritical to find any fault with the new edition. We cannot, however, but regret that the opportunity was not taken of rendering the book still more complete by bringing it down to our present state of knowledge. As stated on the title-page, the additions and corrections are entirely confined to the department of organography, and, as far as they go, are valuable. In particular, the treatment of the subjects of carpology, inflorescence, and phyllotaxis, is rendered much more complete. In other departments we have no such additions, and we miss any reference to the recent labours of Hildebrand, Parlatore, and others, following those of Darwin in the department of fertilisation; of King, Strasburger, and many others in the structure of the reproductive organs of Cryptogams, or to the remarkable observations of Prillieux, Rose, and Brongniart on the movements of chlorophyll. In the department of vegetable palæontology in particular, Unger, Schimper, Heer, Ettingshausen, Dawson, and Carruthers have rendered the science of 1854 scarcely recognisable in 1870; and yet we find not a word added, even to the first edition. The fault appears to be that the book was “stereotyped.” Scientific works ought never to be stereotyped. The author has evidently been exceedingly cramped in the insertion of new matter, and the correction of errors has been rendered impossible. Thus we find repeated the old account of the mode of fertilisation in Parnassia, which has been shown by both English and Continental botanists to be erroneous, and illustrated by a drawing which is quite incorrect. The work is one, however, which is indispensable to the class-room, and should be in the hands of every teacher. Balfour's Class-book of Botany; being an Introduction to the Study of the Vegetable Kingdom. With upwards of 1,800 illustrations. Third edition. (Edinburgh: A. and C. Black, 1870.)