In order to meet environmental regulations and achieve resource efficiency in the series production of vehicles, recyclable polymer composites with a high strength-to-weight ratio are increasingly being used as materials for structural components. Particularly with thermoplastic fibre-reinforced polymers or organo-sheets, the advantage lies in the tailored mechanical properties of the final component by adapting the orientation of fibres based on the direction of loads. These components produced by thermoforming organo-sheets also offer a cost benefit and short cycle times. During the thermoforming process, the shear behaviour of the organo-sheet is the most dominant and determines the mechanical properties and quality of the resulting component. However, the current standard for characterising the shear behaviour of organo-sheets does not consider the strain and cooling rates inherent in the thermoforming process. This research investigates the influence of thermoforming process parameters on the shear behaviour of organo-sheets with a new methodology combining DSC and DMA experiments. During the thermoforming process, the transition of the matrix material from a molten state to a solid state is dictated by the crystallisation kinetics and their dependence on heating and cooling rates. Thus, non-isothermal DSC scans, which correspond to a temperature cycle in a thermoforming process, are used in the DSC experiments to establish the relationship between the recrystallisation temperature of the organo-sheet material and the cooling/heating rates in the thermoforming process. In order to achieve thermoforming-process-relevant cooling rates, fast scanning calorimetry (Flash DSC) is used in addition to conventional DSC measurements. DMA experiments carried out with 45° fibre orientation show that the recrystallisation temperature consequently influences the shear storage modulus of the organo-sheet. The results from DSC measurements show a shift of recrystallisation temperatures to lower temperatures as the cooling rate increases. The combined analysis of results from the DSC and DMA experiments supports the findings and shows the influence of the process temperature, cooling rate and strain rate on the recrystallisation temperature and, in turn, the shear behaviour of organo-sheets. Thus, a recommendation for establishing a new standard for characterising the shear behaviour of organo-sheets is made.