Beetle elytra (hardened forewings) are a promising source of inspiration to develop or enhance the performance of human-fabricated composite materials. The structures responsible for optical properties in the ultra-violet to visible spectrum (300–700 nm) have been extensively characterised, but we have limited knowledge of optical properties and their physical origin in the near-infrared (NIR; 700–1700 nm). We examined the elytra of three species of green scarab beetles (Xylonichus eucalypti, Anoplognathus prasinus and Paraschizognathus olivaceus) with very high NIR reflectance. We manually separated layers in the elytra to disambiguate their contributions to the overall optical response. We show that unlike other scarabs, nanostructures within the cuticle layer do not produce notable reflectance. Instead, the cuticle resembles a pigment-based filter with 50% transmittance in the NIR and absorption in the visible spectrum contributing to the green appearance. Each species has a layer below the cuticle that appears white to the naked eye and produces broadband reflectance, particularly in the near-infrared; however, the structure of the white underlay differs markedly between the three species. In A. prasinus and P. olivaceus, the structure is disordered (no regular, repeated elements at optical length scales); whereas in Xylonichus eucalypti, the white underlay was notably thinner and comprised quasi-ordered hollow cylindrical structures embedded in a chitin matrix. We modelled the coherent scattering produced by this structure to demonstrate that it is responsible for broadband visible and NIR reflectance. We discuss biological implications and technological applications of the composite structure of beetle elytra.