ABSTRACT In current simulation research, post-simulation discussions, so called debriefings, have been shown to be an effective means to learn from simulated experience. However, there is less consensus about which educational methods would guarantee successful debriefing outcomes. This article conducts a comparative study of post-simulation discussions in two professions with a longstanding history of simulation training: nursing and nautical education. We combine a literature review with a survey-based investigation (N = 168) to understand how instructors and facilitators implement their pedagogical ideas in debriefing practice. The results reveal consensus on the importance of debriefings, a shared emphasis on creating a space for self-reflection on practice in groups across practice areas. At the same time, differences emerge between nursing and nautical education in relation to the role of facilitators, focus on learning objectives, and views on instructional feedback and storytelling, both between and within educational fields.
Read full abstract