Local anesthetic toxicity has been well-documented to cause neuronal injury, death, and dysfunction, particularly in a susceptible nerve. To determine whether select local anesthetics affect neuron survival and/or functional recovery of an injured nerve. This report describes 6 separate experiments that test immediate or delayed application of local anesthetics in 3 nerve injury models. Adult C57/black6 male mice underwent a facial nerve sham, transection, or crush injury. Local anesthetic or saline was applied to the facial nerve at the time of injury (immediate) or 1 day after injury (delayed). Average percent facial motoneuron (FMN) survival was evaluated four-weeks after injury. Facial nerve regeneration was estimated by observing functional recovery of eye blink reflex and vibrissae movement after facial nerve crush injury. FMN survival after: transection + immediate treatment with ropivacaine (54.8%), bupivacaine (63.2%), or tetracaine (66.9%) was lower than saline (85.5%) and liposomal bupivacaine (85.0%); crush + immediate treatment with bupivacaine (92.8%) was lower than saline (100.7%) and liposomal bupivacaine (99.3%); sham + delayed treatment with bupivacaine (89.9%) was lower than saline (96.6%) and lidocaine (99.5%); transection + delayed treatment with bupivacaine (67.3%) was lower than saline (78.4%) and liposomal bupivacaine (77.6%); crush + delayed treatment with bupivacaine (85.3%) was lower than saline (97.9%) and lidocaine (96.0%). The average post-operative time for mice to fully recover after: crush + immediate treatment with bupivacaine (12.83 days) was longer than saline (11.08 days) and lidocaine (10.92 days); crush + delayed treatment with bupivacaine (16.79 days) was longer than saline (12.73 days) and lidocaine (11.14 days). Our data demonstrate that some local anesthetics, but not all, exacerbate motoneuron death and delay functional recovery after a peripheral nerve injury. These and future results may lead to clinical strategies that decrease the risk of neural deficit following peripheral nerve blocks with local anesthetics.