Facial Comfort Research Articles

Sensory function in the faces of patients with facial palsy: A prospective observational study using quantitative sensory testing.

To determine the sensory function of both sides of the face in patients with acute or chronic facial palsy. Prospective observational study. The standardized quantitative sensory testing (QST) protocol of the German Research Network on Neuropathic Pain (DFNS), including thermal or mechanical stimuli (touch, pain, vibration, and pressure), was used to investigate somatosensory function in the faces of patients. A patient-reported outcome measures for the assessment of disturbed facial comfort or facial pain, the facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale (FaCE) Facial Comfort Subscale, and the 36-Item Short Form Survey (SF-36) pain subdomain were used. A total of 29 patients (22 female, median age of 48 years; 7 acute palsy; 22 chronic palsy; House-Brackmann grade II-VI) were included. The median FaCE Facial Comfort Subscale score and the median SF-36 pain subdomain score were 50 and 100, respectively. Most patients had, at an individual level, a normal sensory function in all or most tests. On average, the frequencies for all parameters were not different between the paretic side and the contralateral side (all p > 0.05). Additionally, when z-scores were used to compare our patient sample with healthy controls from the DFNS reference database, there was no difference between the paretic side and the contralateral side (all p > 0.05). Furthermore, there were no differences between patients with acute facial palsy and those with chronic facial palsy (all p > 0.05). The FaCE Facial Comfort Subscale score and the SF-36 pain subdomain score did not correlate with the QST parameters (all p > 0.05). Patients with acute or chronic unilateral peripheral facial palsy had normal sensory function on the paretic and contralateral sides compared with the reference values of healthy controls, and there was no significant difference between the sides. The numbness frequently felt in the affected hemiface is not related to a peripheral sensory disorder and is most likely a manifestation of an unsolved cortical somatosensory-motor mismatch.

Experimental investigation of the effect of surgical masks on outdoor thermal comfort in Xiamen, China

The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly changed people's lifestyles, and wearing surgical masks in outdoor public spaces has become commonplace. However, few studies have explored the impact of wearing masks on outdoor thermal comfort in different seasons. From May 2021 to February 2022, a series of longitudinal experiments were conducted in Xiamen, China to examine the effect of wearing surgical masks on outdoor thermal comfort. Forty-two participants took part in the experiments with and without masks. During the experiments, the thermal perceptions of the subjects and environmental thermal parameters were collected. Differences in outdoor thermal comfort between subjects wearing masks and those not wearing masks were determined in summer, autumn, and winter. Results showed that 1) the subjects wearing masks had lower neutral temperatures, and this difference was particularly pronounced in summer and exacerbated by walking; 2) in warm environments, masks reduced thermal comfort, and discomfort associated with masks was worse when walking than when sitting; 3) wearing masks significantly worsened facial comfort and increased chest discomfort, as summer turned to winter, the impact of masks on facial comfort decreased; 4) radiation and air temperature were the environmental parameters with the greatest impact on outdoor thermal sensation. Subjects who wore masks preferred lower temperatures, radiation, and humidity, and higher wind speeds.

QS2: Outcomes Of Pediatric Dynamic Facial Reanimation After Two Decades

Purpose:Pediatric facial paralysis has substantial functional consequences in a growing child including impaired quality of life. Microneurovascular facial reanimation is the gold standard for smile reconstruction; however, quantitative data are lacking regarding long-term outcomes, particularly beyond 10 years. The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the long-term surgical and patient-reported outcomes after dynamic reconstruction of unilateral facial paralysis in childhood.Methods:A cross-sectional study was performed of patients in our institutional facial paralysis database (1978-2008) who underwent dynamic reconstruction of unilateral facial paralysis 20 or more years ago. All patients were treated as children with a staged cross face nerve graft and free functioning muscle transfer. Frontal facial photographs in repose and maximal smile prior to surgery, within 2 years post-surgery, and at long term follow-up were analyzed using the MEEI Face-Gram software for commissure excursion. Patient-reported outcomes were obtained using the FaCE Scale for subjective facial impairment and disability, as well as the FACE-Q Satisfaction with Outcome and FACE-Q Social Function scales. Results are reported as median [IQR] and non-parametric statistical analysis was performed with alpha of 0.05.Results:Eleven patients were included with long term follow-up of 23.7 [5.6] years (6 females, 5 males; 5 congenital, 6 acquired; age at surgery 7.3 [6.3] years). For surgical quantitative measures, commissure excursion significantly improved from prior to surgery (-1.3 [7.4] mm) compared to follow up within 2 years post-surgery (7.0 [1.7] mm) (p<0.05) and from prior to surgery compared to long term follow-up (8.3 [4.9] mm) (p<0.001). There was no statistically significant difference in commissure excursion within 2 years post-surgery and at long term follow-up (p>0.05). For patient-reported outcomes, median FaCE Scale scores showed good function for social function (81/100), oral function (88/100), facial comfort (92/100), and overall score (75/100). On the FACE-Q Satisfaction with Outcome scale, 10/11 respondents somewhat agreed or definitely agreed with the statement, “I am pleased with the result.” On the FACE-Q Social Function scale, 10/11 respondents somewhat agreed or definitely agreed with the statements, “I make a good first impression” and “I feel confident when I participate in group situations.”Conclusion:Dynamic reconstruction of unilateral facial paralysis in young children improves commissure excursion that is maintained at long-term follow up. As adults, these patients report a high level of satisfaction and social functioning with their smile reconstruction.

Evaluating Quality of Life After Facial Reanimation Using the Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale in a Series of Pediatric Patients.

Facial palsy can have significant functional and psychological impact. Dynamic facial reanimation methods have provided means of restoration of smile. There remains a dearth of quality of life data in children. The authors aim to assess patient reported outcomes in this underreported population. A retrospective review was performed of pediatric patients with facial palsy who had dynamic facial reanimation from 2009 to 2017 at a single institution. Patients were sent a digital Facial Clinimetric Evaluation (FaCE) questionnaire, a validated tool to assess patient quality of life. FaCE statements are grouped into 6 categories: facial movement, facial comfort, oral function, eye comfort, lacrimal control, and social control. Twenty patients met inclusion criteria. Fourteen successfully completed the survey. With normal function being 100, our cohort scored: facial movement 38.7 ± 14.3; facial comfort 67.3 ± 23, oral function 75 ± 22.7, eye comfort 68.75 ± 18.2, lacrimal control 53.6 ± 32.5, social function 64.3 ± 25.6. The overall FaCE score was 61.07 ± 10.85. The facial movement subscores were lower for brow raise 16.1 ± 33.4 relative to smiling 53.6 ± 29.2 and lip pucker, 46.4 ± 23.7. No correlation was found between facial movement scores and total scores (R2 < 0.01). There was a strong negative correlation between total scores and time since procedure (Spearman's rho R = -0.45). Our pediatric facial reanimation cohort demonstrated excellent social function, in contrast to a relatively lower facial movement score. The low facial movement score was mediated by low score for brow raise and was not correlated to overall FaCE score. Interestingly, overall FaCE score tended to decrease with time from procedure.

Main prognostic factors and physical therapy modalities associated with functional recovery in patients with peripheral facial paralysis

ABSTRACT Patients with peripheral facial paralysis (PFP) have some degree of recovery. The aim of this study was to evaluate prognostic factors and physical therapy modalities associated with functional recovery in patients with PFP. This is a cohort study with 33 patients. We collected the following variables of patients who underwent treatment at the rehabilitation center: age, sex, risk factors, affected side, degree of facial paralysis (House-Brackmann scale), start of rehabilitation, and therapy modality (kinesiotherapy only; kinesiotherapy with excitomotor electrotherapy; and kinesiotherapy with excitomotor electrotherapy and photobiomodulation therapy). The outcomes were: degree of facial movement (House-Brackmann) and face scale applied 90 days after treatment. Degree of PFP was associated with functional recovery (RR=0.51, 95% CI: 0.51-0.98; p=0.036). The facial movement was associated with the time to start rehabilitation (r=−0.37; p=0.033). Lower facial comfort was observed among women, worse ocular comfort was associated with diabetes mellitus, worse tear control with prior PFP, and worse social function with the degree of PFP. Our results indicate that the all modalities present in this study showed the same result in PFP. Recovery of PFP was associated with degree of nerve dysfunction, the length of time to onset of rehabilitation, female sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, and previous PFP, all of which were associated with worse outcomes on the face scale.

Speech and Communicative Participation in Patients With Facial Paralysis

ImportanceProblems with speech in patients with facial paralysis are frequently noted by both clinicians and the patients themselves, but limited research exists describing how facial paralysis affects verbal communication.ObjectiveTo assess the influence of facial paralysis on communicative participation.Design, Setting, and ParticipantsA nationwide online survey of 160 adults with unilateral facial paralysis was conducted from March 1 to June 1, 2017. To assess communicative participation, respondents completed the Communicative Participation Item Bank (CPIB) Short Form questionnaire and the Facial Clinimetric Evaluation (FaCE) Scale.Main Outcomes and MeasuresThe CPIB Short Form and the correlation between the CPIB Short Form and FaCE Scale. In the CPIB, the level of interference in communication is rated on a 4-point Likert scale (where not at all = 3, a little = 2, quite a bit = 1, and very much = 0). Total scores for the 10 items range from 0 (worst) to 30 (best). The FaCE Scale is a 15-item instrument that produces an overall score ranging from 0 (worst) to 100 (best), with higher scores representing better function and higher quality of life.ResultsOf the 160 respondents, 145 (90.6%) were women and 15 were men (mean [SD] age, 45.1 [12.6] years). Most respondents reported having facial paralysis for more than 3 years. Causes of facial paralysis included Bell palsy (86 [53.8%]), tumor (41 [25.6%]), and other causes (33 [20.6%]), including infection, trauma, congenital defects, and surgical complications. The mean (SD) score on the CPIB Short Form was 0.16 (0.88) logits (range, –2.58 to 2.10 logits). The mean (SD) score of the FaCE Scale was 40.92 (16.05) (range, 0-83.3). Significant correlations were observed between the CPIB Short Form and overall FaCE Scale scores, as well as the Social Function, Oral Function, Facial Comfort, and Eye Comfort subdomains of the FaCE Scale, but not with the Facial Movement subdomain.Conclusions and RelevancePatients with facial paralysis in this study sample reported restrictions in communicative participation that were comparable with restrictions experienced by patients with other known communicative disorders, such as laryngectomy and head and neck cancer. We believe that communicative participation represents a unique domain of dysfunction and can help quantify the outcome of facial paralysis and provide an additional frame of reference when assessing treatment outcomes.

Long-Term Outcomes of Smile Reconstruction in Möbius Syndrome.

Gracilis muscle transplant is the standard of care for smile reconstruction in children with Möbius syndrome. The authors describe the long-term clinical efficacy, durability, and psychosocial impact of this approach at a mean follow-up of 20 years. Patients with Möbius syndrome who underwent gracilis muscle transfer between 1985 and 2005 were included in the study. The authors assessed midfacial movements using photographs and Scaled Measurement of Improvement in Lip Excursion measure, administered the patient-reported Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale, and used semistructured interviews. The mean age at surgery was 13.2 ±10.6 years and the mean follow-up was 20.4 ± 4.4 years postoperatively. Twenty-two gracilis muscle transplants were performed, all innervated by the motor nerve to the masseter. Photographic analysis using Scaled Measurement of Improvement in Lip Excursion software demonstrated that movement of the muscle was unchanged 20 years after surgery. Smile symmetry was stable long term. The overall mean Facial Clinimetric Evaluation score of the cohort was 62.3 ± 12.0. Facial comfort (86.4 ± 21.2) and social function (69.9 ± 18.5) subdomains were the highest. Although the facial movement subdomain score was 35.6 ± 12.4, the score related to smiling alone was 84.1 ± 20.2, indicating satisfaction with the midfacial reconstruction. Interview responses indicated high satisfaction with surgery; fulfilled expectations of social acceptance; improved communication; enhanced self-confidence; and a sense of increased facial symmetry, spontaneity, and smile excursion. Segmental gracilis muscle transplantation provides long-lasting, durable improvements in objective and patient-reported measures of facial function.

Nonmotor disabilities in patients with facial palsy measured by patient-reported outcome measures.

To describe changes of motor and nonmotor disabilities in patient with peripheral facial palsy (FP) during treatment using the patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) Facial Clinimetric Evaluation (FaCE), Facial Disability Index (FDI), and Short Form 36-Item Questionnaire (SF-36) and to analyze predictors for these changes Prospective, single-center longitudinal study. One hundred twenty patients with FP underwent at least two PROMs between 2012 and 2015. Predictors for changes of the PROMs were analyzed univariately using Pearson's correlation and multivariately using linear regression models. The mean interval between onset of FP to first presentation was 29 ± 64 months and between first and final assessment 8.7 ± 7.2 months. Initial House-Brackmann grading was 4.0 ± 1.3 and final House-Brackmann grading was 2.8 ± 1.6 (P < .001). All mean FaCE and FDI but only some SF-36 subscores improved over time (all P < .05). Adjuvant treatment was an independent predictor for improvement of the FaCE Facial Comfort subscore (P = .015) and a malignant tumor as primary disease for improvement of the FaCE Oral Function subscore (P = .044). Unemployment was a predictor for improvement of the FDI Social/Well-Being Function (P = .035). First assessment <90 days after onset was a predictor for improvement of the SF-36 Bodily Pain subscore (P = .025), a primary malignant disease for improvement of the SF-36 General Health perception (P = .004), and idiopathic FP for improvement of the SF-36 Social Functioning subscore (P = .017). Changes of motor function revealed by classical grading systems mostly do not correlate with changes of nonmotor disabilities during treatment of FP. Many other factors are associated with changes of PROMs during the FP treatment. 4. Laryngoscope, 126:1516-1523, 2016.

A National Survey of Facial Paralysis on the Quality of Life of Patients with Acoustic Neuroma

The aim of this survey was to objectively quantify the impact of facial palsy on the quality of life of acoustic neuroma patients. The Facial Clinimetric Evaluation (FaCE) Scale was emailed to all members of the British Acoustic Neuroma Association (BANA). Of the 880 BANA members contacted, 398 (45.2%) responded, of which, 178 indicated that they had facial paralysis. Surgery for acoustic neuroma accounted for 80% of facial paralysis. Treatment received for facial palsy varied considerably, although 33% reported not receiving any treatment. The commonest single treatment modality wads facial electrical stimulation (41%), followed by facial physiotherapy (39%). The most common surgical procedures were to the eye lid (50%), followed by nerve graft (12%), forehead lift (10%), muscle sling (9%), and face lift (9%). The overall mean total FaCE Scale score was 54.8 (range, 10-100, standard deviation [SD] 21.2). Both facial movement and eye comfort domains had the lowest mean scores of 41.3 (SD, 29.9) and 41.2 (SD 32.6) respectively. The mean total FaCE Scale score of female respondents was statistically lower (p = 0.03) than males (52.6 (SD 21.2) versus 58.8 (SD 20.7) respectively), as were the difference in mean domain scores for facial comfort, eye comfort and social function. The mean total FaCE Scale scores of respondents aged below 40 years were the lowest. Younger patients had the lowest social function domain scores of all age groups. Facial paralysis is a significant problem in patients with acoustic neuroma. Based on this survey, treatment for facial paralysis is often not offered and even when given, still leaves the patient with a significantly lowered quality of life. However, it should be remembered that this study has surveyed a skewed patient population and that overall, most acoustic neuroma patients do not suffer with facial paralysis.

Quality of life assessment in facial palsy: validation of the Dutch Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale.

This study aimed at validating an existing health-related quality of life questionnaire for patients with facial palsy for implementation in the Dutch language and culture. The Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale was translated into the Dutch language using a forward–backward translation method. A pilot test with the translated questionnaire was performed in 10 patients with facial palsy and 10 normal subjects. Finally, cross-cultural adaption was accomplished at our outpatient clinic for facial palsy. Analyses for internal consistency, test–retest reliability, construct validity and responsiveness were performed. Ninety-three patients completed the Dutch Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale, the Dutch Facial Disability Index, and the Dutch Short Form (36) Health Survey. Cronbach’s α, representing internal consistency, was 0.800. Test–retest reliability was shown by an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.737. Correlations with the House–Brackmann score, Sunnybrook score, Facial Disability Index physical function, and social/well-being function were −0.292, 0.570, 0.713, and 0.575, respectively. The SF-36 domains correlate best with the FaCE social function domain, with the strongest correlation between the both social function domains (r = 0.576). The FaCE score did statistically significantly increase in 35 patients receiving botulinum toxin type A (P = 0.042, Student t test). The domains ‘facial comfort’ and ‘social function’ improved statistically significantly as well (P = 0.022 and P = 0.046, respectively, Student t-test). The Dutch Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale shows good psychometric values and can be implemented in the management of Dutch-speaking patients with facial palsy in the Netherlands. Translation of the instrument into other languages may lead to widespread use, making evaluation and comparison possible among different providers.

Simulated effects of head movement on contact pressures between headforms and N95 filtering facepiece respirators part 2: simulation.

Finite element (FE) filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs) were developed and mated to the new headforms with a cervical spine model. The FFRs from three manufacturers included three sizing systems: (i) a single one-size-fits all, (ii) an FFR with two sizes (S/M and M/L), and (iii) an FFR with three sizes (S, L/M, XL). Finite element method (FEM) simulations of 16 headform and respirator combinations (5 headforms and 6 respirators) were used to examine maximum contact pressure changes for five cases: static head, flexion, extension, left rotation, and right rotation. For each of the 16 headform and respirator combinations, maximum contact pressures of the static headform and motile headforms were compared using t-tests. Significant differences on the maximum contact pressures were found in the extension, left rotation and right rotation at the nose (P < 0.005), the left rotation at the top of right cheek (P = 0.03), and the extension at the bottom of left/right cheek (P = 0.01). When separately considering each headform and each FFR manufacturer, the effects of the four head movement cases on the nose maximum contact pressure changes were observed in the simulations with all five headforms and all FFR manufacturers. The effects of the left and right rotations on the chin maximum contact pressure changes were observed in the simulations with the small headform. It was also found that the use of a nose clip could reduce the impact of the head left/right rotations on nose maximum contact pressure changes. In addition, head movements changed pressure contours of the key nose area. Caused by the head movements, the maximum contact pressure changes may affect seal quality, and the increase of the maximum contact pressures could reduce the facial comfort level.

Subjective and objective outcome measures in the treatment of facial nerve synkinesis with onabotulinumtoxinA (Botox).

To evaluate the Sunnybrook Facial Grading System (SFGS) and Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale (FaCE Scale) instrument outcome measures pre- and 30-day posttreatment of facial nerve synkinesis with botulinum toxin with attempts to correlate the 2 scales. An IRB approved retrospective review of 22 patients with facial nerve synkinesis where the surgeon completed the SFGS and the patient completed the FaCE prior to receiving onabotulinumtoxinA therapy, the SFGS, and FaCE scales were completed again 1 month later. Of the 22 patients, 9 complete datasets were analyzed. Mean patient age was 59.8; 8 (89%) women and 1 (11%) men. Overall SFGS composite score decreased from 57.6 ± 20.9 to 45.2 ± 13.5, (p = 0.001). SFGS subdomain synkinesis significantly improved (p < 0.001), while voluntary movement significantly decreased (p = 0.002). A difference in the resting symmetry was not statistically significant (p = 0.08). The FaCE scale composite score significantly improved from 40.9 ± 9.5 to 47.6 ± 11.9, (p = 0.03). FaCE subdomains facial comfort (p = 0.005) and social function (p = 0.009) significantly improved, while oral function, eye comfort, facial movement, and lacrimal control did not. The Δ pre/post-SFGS composite score did not correlate with the Δ pre/post-FaCE composite score (rs= -0.318). Subdomain analysis demonstrated significant negative correlation between Δ pre/post-SFGS synkinesis score and Δ pre/post-FaCE eye comfort score (rs = -0.826, p < 0.01). Significant improvement was seen in objectively reported synkinesis following botulinum toxin therapy. An improvement was noted in the overall subjective facial nerve functioning following therapy along with improvement in social functioning and facial comfort. A meaningful negative correlation was noted when comparing the SFGS "synkinesis" subdomain with the FaCE scale subdomain "eye comfort", implying improvement in eye comfort with control of synkinesis.

Flat Fold and Cup-Shaped N95 Filtering Facepiece Respirator Face Seal Area and Pressure Determinations: A Stereophotogrammetry Study

Twenty subjects underwent quantitative respirator fit testing with two styles (flat fold, cup-shaped) of N95 filtering facepiece respirators (N95 FFRs). Passing a fit test was followed by stereophotogrammetry to determine the face seal area and computation of seal pressure. There were significantly different seal pressures (p < 0.01) between standard size flat fold and cup-shaped N95 FFRs but no significant differences in face seal area. No significant differences were noted in fit factors, but more individuals passed fit testing wearing flat fold respirators. The ability of flat fold N95 FFRs, at lower seal pressures, to obtain similar fit factors as cup-shaped N95 FFR at higher seal pressures offers the possibility of enhanced facial comfort without a loss of protection. Stereophotogrammetry offers a relatively simple, non-invasive technology to evaluate various properties of N95 FFR fit.

The use of the facial clinimetric evaluation scale as a patient‐based grading system in bell's palsy

The severity of Bell's facial palsy is monitored through physician-graded instruments, like the House-Brackmann or Sunnybrook Facial Grading System (FGS). These instruments primarily measure the degree of facial muscle impairment and its resulting asymmetry, but neglect the other functional aspects of facial disability. The aim of this study is therefore to compare the FGS with a patient-graded quality-of-life (QOL) instrument, Facial Clinimetric Evaluation Scale (FaCE). Prospective longitudinal study. Twenty-one patients with newly diagnosed Bell's palsy were recruited. All patients received standard treatment with a corticosteroid. They were scored with the FGS at every visit, and they also completed the FaCE at baseline and when they recovered from their palsy. At presentation, there was a positive correlation between the FGS score and the total FaCE score (ρ = 0.63, P = .002). However, when individual domains of the FaCE score were analyzed separately, the domains of facial comfort and lacrimal score did not have significant correlation with the FGS. Similarly, at the end of follow-up, the amount of improvement in FGS and the amount of improvement in the FaCE domains of facial comfort, lacrimal control, and social function showed insignificant and low correlation (P < .05). This is the first longitudinal study comparing scores on the FGS and FaCE in patients with Bell's palsy. Our findings suggest that without patient-based QOL assessments such as the FaCE, certain functional aspects of facial disability may be overlooked by physician-graded instruments, which focus on facial aesthetics. 4.

Botulinum Toxin and Quality of Life in Patients With Facial Paralysis

To examine the effect botulinum toxin, a potent neurotoxin that causes temporary paralysis of hyperkinetic musculature, has on the quality of life (QOL) in the patient with facial paralysis. We surveyed patients with facial paralysis, using the previously validated Facial Clinimetric Evaluation QOL instrument, before and then again after therapeutic administration of botulinum toxin for the management of their facial hyperkinesis, and performed pair-wise comparisons to determine the effect on patient QOL. Prospective clinical study at an outpatient facial nerve center. The overall Facial Clinimetric Evaluation score improved from a mean (SD) of 51.7 (20.9) in the pretreatment group to 63.7 (17.8) in the posttreatment group (P < .05). Statistically significant improvements were noted in all subdomain scores, including Facial Movement, Facial Comfort, Oral Function, Eye Comfort, Lacrimal Control, and Social Function (P < .05 for all comparisons). Botulinum toxin has a well-established objective benefit in the control of facial hyperkinesis in patients with facial nerve disorders. This study establishes the associated QOL benefit and reaffirms its important role in the multimodality management of patients with facial nerve disorders.

Exercise Performance While Wearing a Tight-Fitting Powered Air Purifying Respirator with Limited Flow

Sixteen subjects exercised at 80–85% of maximal aerobic capacity on a treadmill while wearing a tight-fitting, FRM40-Turbo Powered Air Purifying Respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was powered by a DC power supply to give flow rates of 0%, 30%, 66%, 94%, and 100% of rated maximum blower capacity of 110 L/min. As flow rate was reduced, so was performance time. There was a 20% reduction in performance time as blower flow changed from 100% to 0% of maximum. Significant differences in breathing apparatus comfort and facial thermal comfort were found as flow rate varied. It was concluded that inadequate blower flow rate decreases performance time, facial cooling, and respirator comfort.