Controlling and manipulating the propagation of surface plasmons has become a field of intense research given their potential in a wide range of applications, such as plasmonic circuits, optical trapping, sensors, and lensing. In this communication, we exploit classical optics techniques to design and evaluate the performance of plasmonic lenses with meniscus-like geometries. To do this, we use an adapted lens maker equation that incorporates the effective medium concepts of surface plasmons polaritons travelling in dielectric-metal and dielectric-dielectric-metal configurations. The design process for such plasmonic meniscus lenses is detailed and two different plasmonic focusing structures are evaluated: a plasmonic lens with a quasi-planar output surface and a plasmonic meniscus lens having a convex-concave input–output surface, respectively. The structures are designed to have an effective focal length of 2λ0 at the visible wavelength of 633 nm. A performance comparison of the two plasmonic lenses is shown, demonstrating improvements to the power enhancement, with a 22% and 16.5% increase when using 2D (ideal) or 3D (realistic plasmonic) meniscus designs, respectively, compared to the power enhancement obtained with convex-planar lenses. It is also shown that the depth of focus of the focal spot presents a 19.8% decrease when using meniscus lenses in 2D and a 34.3% decrease when using the proposed 3D plasmonic meniscus designs. The broadband response of a plasmonic meniscus lens (550–750 nm wavelength range) is also studied along with the influence of potential fabrication errors on the generated effective focal length. The proposed plasmonic lenses could be exploited as alternative focusing devices for surface plasmons polaritons in applications such as sensing.