Abstract Exploring the mechanisms modulating Japan Sea Rim (JSR) winter surface air temperature (JSRWT) holds significant scientific and societal importance. The present study unravels the counteracting impacts of El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and the Aleutian Low (AL) on JSRWT. Although ENSO and the AL have a significant positive correlation on interannual timescale, they exert totally opposite impacts on JSRWT. The positive Niño3.4 sea surface temperature anomalies (SSTA) usually lead to positive JSRWT anomalies, while an enhanced AL often results in negative JSRWT anomalies. The tropical convection anomalies associated with the positive Niño3.4 SSTA induce two tropical to extratropical Rossby wave trains, leading to a barotropic anomalous anticyclone over Northeast Asia, and thereby positive JSRWT anomalies. Conversely, the strengthened AL perturbs the westerly jet and induces an eastward-propagating Rossby wave train, leading to a barotropic anomalous cyclone over Northeast Asia and negative JSRWT anomalies. The northeastward-propagating Rossby wave induced by the ENSO-related tropical convection anomalies over the Indian Ocean offsets the downstream Rossby wave induced by the strengthened AL, leading to counteracting impacts of ENSO and the AL on JSRWT. Finally, a novel index for monitoring JSRWT is proposed based on the indices of ENSO and AL.