ObjectivesThis study aims to present long-term follow-up results of the reverse dorsolateral proximal phalangeal island flap designed for reconstruction of large fingertip and pulp defects. MethodsWe examined 18 patients who underwent reverse dorsolateral proximal phalangeal island flap surgery to address ≥2.5 cm fingertip and pulp defects. Mean follow-up was 84.4 months. Sensitivity assessments were conducted using the Semmes–Weinstein monofilament and 2-point discrimination tests. Additionally, we evaluated finger joint active range of motion, complications and cold intolerance. ResultsMild venous congestion was observed in 5 flaps. Significant differences were observed in 2-point discrimination and Semmes-Weinstein monofilament tests between the injured and contralateral sides, specifically in the flaps, the dorsal side of the middle phalanx, and the donor site. The flap's mean static 2-point discrimination was 8.3 mm. Restricted distal interphalangeal joint extension was observed in 2 cases. Total active motion with the flap was good or excellent in the injured fingers, but with a significant difference between injured and contralateral fingers. Additionally, 42% of the injured fingers exhibited hook nail deformity, and 2 patients reported cold intolerance. Despite these issues, most patients has high scores for the appearance and satisfaction aspects of the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire. ConclusionIn moderate or larger fingertip defects, the reverse dorsolateral proximal phalangeal island flap serves as an alternative for reconstructing both fingertip and pulp issues. However, this option involves sacrificing some sensation in the dorsum of the middle phalangeal finger and the donor area. Level of evidenceIV, therapeutic study.