Steel fibers have been shown in numerous studies to enhance the shear performance of steel fiber reinforced concrete (SFRC) beams effectively, and to evaluate the shear behavior of these beams, a nonlinear finite element (NLFE) analysis is required. In the present study, from recent experimental results of asymmetrical loading tests on SFRC beams without stirrups, three NLFE models have been validated and further developed to evaluate the impact that the ratio of shear span-to-depth (a/d) and the compressive strength of steel fiber concrete (SFC) have on the shear behavior and shear strength of SFRC beams without stirrups. The validation shows a good agreement between the chosen NLFE model and the reported experimental results. Applying the NLFE model to five different values of the a/d ratio (e.g., 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.54, and 3.1) reveals a gradual decline in shear strength, while the ductility of the beam increases with the increase in ratio. Meanwhile, with increasing SFC compressive strength, the shear strength and ductility of SFRC beams without stirrups significantly increase for the same ratio of shear span-to-depth. Moreover, the failure mode of SFRC beams without stirrups dominantly depends on the a/d ratio.