In Search of Middle Indonesia: Middle Classes in Provincial TownsIn 2012, Indonesian Daily Kompas conducted a survey aiming to calculate actual number and define characteristics of what it called the of country's population. Involving 2,550 people above 17 years of age who lived in cities of Jakarta, Bandung, Yogyakarta, Surabaya, Makassar, and Medan, survey employed World Bank criteria of education level, occupation, and purchasing power parity (PPP) to determine categories of respondents. The survey result shows that 1% of respondents belonged to upper class, 3.6% to upper class, 50.2% to class, 39.6% to lower class, and 5.6% to lower class. In World Bank criteria this means that surveyed cohort groups, successively, earned and lived on than US$20 per day, between US$10 and 20, between US$4 and 10, between US$2 and 4, and less than US$2. This result echoes World Bank's own survey earlier that year as quoted by Daily Kompas, in which 56.5% of entire Indonesian population of 237 million in 2012-thus forming an actual number of 134 million people-is seen as belonging to category. Kompas and World Bank surveys represent analyses of socio-economic diversification of Indonesian population over past five years, which generally depicted a growing class. Whereas criteria used for grouping of surveyed respondents perform an established standard of income and expenditure method typical of economists, they do not satisfy other scholars who work on social, anthropological, and political aspects of demographic population. This edited volume, In Search of Middle Indonesia, is an attempt to break these established criteria and definition of middle and to offer an alternative to studying this paradigmatic term and phenomenon.In Search of Middle Indonesia explores expanding in Indonesia not by measuring people's consumption but by raising more relational, political (p. 2). Its basic premise is that class is not essentially a question of income or expenditure categories; it is a political concept, intended to explain why differences remain between behavior of rich and poor people over matters of common goods (p. 2). The authors in this book agree on statement that the possession of consumer durables says nothing about new political commitments and that simply reducing income threshold to poverty limit and calling everyone above that 'middle class' begs many analytical questions about political action (p. 3). While it does not abandon income and expenditure methodology, this book employs an ethnological approach to find answers to its prime question Why is Middle Indonesia so influential, locally and in Indonesia as a whole, though it is neither particularly rich nor particularly central in geographic terms? (p. 8). This book thus examines middle in terms of agencies and their characteristics of behaviors and seeks to clarify motives that prompt such behaviors by exploring ethnological rather than statistic data.In Search of Middle Indonesia is organized around three theoretical concepts, namely class, State, and everyday culture, each of which consists of three individual studies. Three of chapters concerning Kupang, East Nusa Tenggara emphasize previous studies some of authors have done on this provincial (see authors' biographies pp. vii-ix). Other studies focus on what authors consider middle towns, mostly provincial capitals. It has to be noted that selection of geographical locality of these studies reflects authors' shared consciousness of two points: importance of a non-Java centric approach and centrality of non-metropolitan urban lives in making of Indonesia's class.In first part of book, about class, Ben White overviews concept of Middle Indonesia based on Clifford Geertz's intermediate town (1963) and Robert and Helen Lynd's Middletown (1929; 1937). …
Read full abstract