Existing Survey Papers Research Articles

A comprehensive survey of research towards AI-enabled unmanned aerial systems in pre-, active-, and post-wildfire management

Wildfires have emerged as one of the most destructive natural disasters worldwide, causing catastrophic losses. These losses have underscored the urgent need to improve public knowledge and advance existing techniques in wildfire management. Recently, the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in wildfires, propelled by the integration of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) and deep learning models, has created an unprecedented momentum to implement and develop more effective wildfire management. Although existing survey papers have explored learning-based approaches in wildfire, drone use in disaster management, and wildfire risk assessment, a comprehensive review emphasizing the application of AI-enabled UAV systems and investigating the role of learning-based methods throughout the overall workflow of multi-stage wildfire management, including pre-fire (e.g., vision-based vegetation fuel measurement), active-fire (e.g., fire growth modeling), and post-fire tasks (e.g., evacuation planning) is notably lacking. This survey synthesizes and integrates state-of-the-science reviews and research at the nexus of wildfire observations and modeling, AI, and UAVs — topics at the forefront of advances in wildfire management, elucidating the role of AI in performing monitoring and actuation tasks from pre-fire, through the active-fire stage, to post-fire management. To this aim, we provide an extensive analysis of the existing remote sensing systems with a particular focus on the UAV advancements, device specifications, and sensor technologies relevant to wildfire management. We also examine the pre-fire and post-fire management approaches, including fuel monitoring, prevention strategies, as well as evacuation planning, damage assessment, and operation strategies. Additionally, we review and summarize a wide range of computer vision techniques in active-fire management, with an emphasis on Machine Learning (ML), Reinforcement Learning (RL), and Deep Learning (DL) algorithms for wildfire classification, segmentation, detection, and monitoring tasks. Ultimately, we underscore the substantial advancement in wildfire modeling through the integration of cutting-edge AI techniques and UAV-based data, providing novel insights and enhanced predictive capabilities to understand dynamic wildfire behavior.

One-sided discretization inequalities and sampling recovery

Recently, in a number of papers it was understood that results on sampling discretization and universal sampling discretization can successfully be used in the problem of sampling recovery. Moreover, it turns out that it is sufficient to only have a one-sided discretization inequality for some of these applications. This motivated us to write the present paper as a survey, which includes new results, with the focus on the one-sided discretization inequalities and their applications to sampling recovery. In this sense the paper complements the two existing survey papers on sampling discretization (Russian Math. Surveys, 74:4 (2019), 579-630 and J. Complexity, 71 (2022), 101653, 55 pp.). Bibliography: 50 titles.

A survey on preprocessing and classification techniques for acoustic scene

There are lots of research papers for ASC, and in recent years it is rapidly increasing. DCASE also provides different types of competition for the submission of several papers to solve the various tasks of ASC and it is the opportunity for the research scholars either to participate in those competitions or to provide the enhanced model for ASC. This paper provides details about the various recent approaches along with the block diagram used for pre-processing required before model development for ASC. It also includes a description of different recent techniques used for the classification of different sounds for ASC tasks. The comparative analysis for different recent available techniques both for pre-processing and classification has been done and summarized in this paper. It also describes the contributions towards the survey on ASC by comparing this paper with some existing survey papers based on several parameters like functionality described separately, results from description with quantifiable value, a dataset with proper quantifiable analysis, and pictorial representation of model discussed, etc. Finally, considering the benefits for eminent research scholars, this paper has also focused on the details for future directions for both pre-processing and classification for ASC.

DL4SciVis: A State-of-the-Art Survey on Deep Learning for Scientific Visualization.

Since 2016, we have witnessed the tremendous growth of artificial intelligence+visualization (AI+VIS) research. However, existing survey papers on AI+VIS focus on visual analytics and information visualization, not scientific visualization (SciVis). In this paper, we survey related deep learning (DL) works in SciVis, specifically in the direction of DL4SciVis: designing DL solutions for solving SciVis problems. To stay focused, we primarily consider works that handle scalar and vector field data but exclude mesh data. We classify and discuss these works along six dimensions: domain setting, research task, learning type, network architecture, loss function, and evaluation metric. The paper concludes with a discussion of the remaining gaps to fill along the discussed dimensions and the grand challenges we need to tackle as a community. This state-of-the-art survey guides SciVis researchers in gaining an overview of this emerging topic and points out future directions to grow this research.

Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI): What we know and what is left to attain Trustworthy Artificial Intelligence

Artificial intelligence (AI) is currently being utilized in a wide range of sophisticated applications, but the outcomes of many AI models are challenging to comprehend and trust due to their black-box nature. Usually, it is essential to understand the reasoning behind an AI model’s decision-making. Thus, the need for eXplainable AI (XAI) methods for improving trust in AI models has arisen. XAI has become a popular research subject within the AI field in recent years. Existing survey papers have tackled the concepts of XAI, its general terms, and post-hoc explainability methods but there have not been any reviews that have looked at the assessment methods, available tools, XAI datasets, and other related aspects. Therefore, in this comprehensive study, we provide readers with an overview of the current research and trends in this rapidly emerging area with a case study example. The study starts by explaining the background of XAI, common definitions, and summarizing recently proposed techniques in XAI for supervised machine learning. The review divides XAI techniques into four axes using a hierarchical categorization system: (i) data explainability, (ii) model explainability, (iii) post-hoc explainability, and (iv) assessment of explanations. We also introduce available evaluation metrics as well as open-source packages and datasets with future research directions. Then, the significance of explainability in terms of legal demands, user viewpoints, and application orientation is outlined, termed as XAI concerns. This paper advocates for tailoring explanation content to specific user types. An examination of XAI techniques and evaluation was conducted by looking at 410 critical articles, published between January 2016 and October 2022, in reputed journals and using a wide range of research databases as a source of information. The article is aimed at XAI researchers who are interested in making their AI models more trustworthy, as well as towards researchers from other disciplines who are looking for effective XAI methods to complete tasks with confidence while communicating meaning from data.

A Comprehensive Survey on Video Saliency Detection With Auditory Information: The Audio-Visual Consistency Perceptual is the Key!

Video saliency detection (VSD) aims at fast locating the most attractive objects/things/patterns in a given video clip. Existing VSD-related works have mainly relied on the visual system but paid less attention to the audio aspect. In contrast, our audio system is the most vital complementary part of our visual system. Also, audio-visual saliency detection (AVSD), one of the most representative research topics for mimicking human perceptual mechanisms, is currently in its infancy, and none of the existing survey papers have touched on it, especially from the perspective of saliency detection. Thus, the ultimate goal of this paper is to provide an extensive review to bridge the gap between audio-visual fusion and saliency detection. In addition, as another highlight of this review, we have provided a deep insight into key factors that could directly determine AVSD deep models’ performances. We claim that the audio-visual consistency degree (AVC) — a long-overlooked issue, can directly influence the effectiveness of using audio to benefit its visual counterpart when performing saliency detection. Moreover, to make the AVC issue more practical and valuable for future followers, we have newly equipped almost all existing publicly available AVSD datasets with additional frame-wise AVC labels. Based on these upgraded datasets, we have conducted extensive quantitative evaluations to ground our claim on the importance of AVC in the AVSD task. In a word, our ideas and new sets serve as a convenient platform with preliminaries and guidelines, all of which can potentially facilitate future works in further promoting state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance.

Audio deepfakes: A survey.

A deepfake is content or material that is synthetically generated or manipulated using artificial intelligence (AI) methods, to be passed off as real and can include audio, video, image, and text synthesis. The key difference between manual editing and deepfakes is that deepfakes are AI generated or AI manipulated and closely resemble authentic artifacts. In some cases, deepfakes can be fabricated using AI-generated content in its entirety. Deepfakes have started to have a major impact on society with more generation mechanisms emerging everyday. This article makes a contribution in understanding the landscape of deepfakes, and their detection and generation methods. We evaluate various categories of deepfakes especially in audio. The purpose of this survey is to provide readers with a deeper understanding of (1) different deepfake categories; (2) how they could be created and detected; (3) more specifically, how audio deepfakes are created and detected in more detail, which is the main focus of this paper. We found that generative adversarial networks (GANs), convolutional neural networks (CNNs), and deep neural networks (DNNs) are common ways of creating and detecting deepfakes. In our evaluation of over 150 methods, we found that the majority of the focus is on video deepfakes, and, in particular, the generation of video deepfakes. We found that for text deepfakes, there are more generation methods but very few robust methods for detection, including fake news detection, which has become a controversial area of research because of the potential heavy overlaps with human generation of fake content. Our study reveals a clear need to research audio deepfakes and particularly detection of audio deepfakes. This survey has been conducted with a different perspective, compared to existing survey papers that mostly focus on just video and image deepfakes. This survey mainly focuses on audio deepfakes that are overlooked in most of the existing surveys. This article's most important contribution is to critically analyze and provide a unique source of audio deepfake research, mostly ranging from 2016 to 2021. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first survey focusing on audio deepfakes generation and detection in English.

On building machine learning pipelines for Android malware detection: a procedural survey of practices, challenges and opportunities

As the smartphone market leader, Android has been a prominent target for malware attacks. The number of malicious applications (apps) identified for it has increased continually over the past decade, creating an immense challenge for all parties involved. For market holders and researchers, in particular, the large number of samples has made manual malware detection unfeasible, leading to an influx of research that investigate Machine Learning (ML) approaches to automate this process. However, while some of the proposed approaches achieve high performance, rapidly evolving Android malware has made them unable to maintain their accuracy over time. This has created a need in the community to conduct further research, and build more flexible ML pipelines. Doing so, however, is currently hindered by a lack of systematic overview of the existing literature, to learn from and improve upon the existing solutions. Existing survey papers often focus only on parts of the ML process (e.g., data collection or model deployment), while omitting other important stages, such as model evaluation and explanation. In this paper, we address this problem with a review of 42 highly-cited papers, spanning a decade of research (from 2011 to 2021). We introduce a novel procedural taxonomy of the published literature, covering how they have used ML algorithms, what features they have engineered, which dimensionality reduction techniques they have employed, what datasets they have employed for training, and what their evaluation and explanation strategies are. Drawing from this taxonomy, we also identify gaps in knowledge and provide ideas for improvement and future work.

Recent Iris and Ocular Recognition Methods in High- and Low-Resolution Images: A Survey

Among biometrics, iris and ocular recognition systems are the methods that recognize eye features in an image. Such iris and ocular regions must have a certain image resolution to achieve a high recognition performance; otherwise, the risk of performance degradation arises. This is even more critical in the case of iris recognition where detailed patterns are used. In cases where such low-resolution images are acquired and the acquisition apparatus and environment cannot be improved, recognition performance can be enhanced by obtaining high-resolution images with methods such as super-resolution reconstruction. However, previous survey papers have mainly summarized studies on high-resolution iris and ocular recognition, but do not provide detailed summaries of studies on low-resolution iris and ocular recognition. Therefore, we investigated high-resolution iris and ocular recognition methods and introduced in detail the low-resolution iris and ocular recognition methods and methods of solving the low-resolution problem. Furthermore, since existing survey papers have focused on and summarized studies on traditional handcrafted feature-based iris and ocular recognition, this survey paper also introduced the latest deep learning-based methods in detail.

Comparative Analysis of Relational Database Watermarking Techniques: An Empirical Study

Digital watermarking is considered one of the most promising techniques to verify the authenticity and integrity of digital data. It is used for a wide range of applications, e.g., copyright protection, tamper detection, traitor tracing, maintaining the integrity of data, etc. In the past two decades, a wide range of algorithms for relational database watermarking has been proposed. Even though a number of surveys exist in the literature, they are unable to provide insightful guidance to choose the right watermarking technique for a given application. In this paper, we provide an exhaustive empirical study and thorough comparative analysis of various relational database watermarking techniques in the literature. Our work is different from the existing survey papers as we consider both distortion-based and distortion-free techniques along with a rigorous experimental analysis demonstrating a detailed comparison on robustness, data usability, and computational cost with considerable empirical evidence.

Constrained Localization: A Survey

Indoor localization techniques have been extensively studied in the last decade. The well-established technologies enable the development of Real-Time Location Systems (RTLS). A good body of publications emerged, with several survey papers that provide a deep analysis of the research advances. Existing survey papers focus on either a specific technique and technology or on a general overview of indoor localization research. However, there is a need for a use case-driven survey on both recent academic research and commercial trends, as well as a hands-on evaluation of commercial solutions. This work aims at helping researchers select the appropriate technology and technique suitable for developing low-cost, low-power localization system, capable of providing centimeter level accuracy. The article is both a survey on recent academic research and a hands-on evaluation of commercial solutions. We introduce a specific use case as a guiding application throughout this article: localizing low-cost low-power miniature wireless swarm robots. We define a taxonomy and classify academic research according to five criteria: Line of Sight (LoS) requirement, accuracy, update rate, battery life, cost. We discuss localization fundamentals, the different technologies and techniques, as well as recent commercial developments and trends. Besides the traditional taxonomy and survey, this article also presents a hands-on evaluation of popular commercial localization solutions based on Bluetooth Angle of Arrival (AoA) and Ultra-Wideband (UWB). We conclude this article by discussing the five most important open research challenges: lightweight filtering algorithms, zero infrastructure dependency, low-power operation, security, and standardization.

A Survey on Model-Based Fault Detection Techniques for Linear Time-Invariant Systems with Numerical Analysis

With the ongoing increase in complexity, less tolerance to performance degradation and safety requirements of practical systems has increased the necessity of fault detection (FD) as early as possible. During the last few decades, many research findings have been developed in fault diagnosis that addresses the issue of fault detection and isolation in linear and nonlinear systems. The paper’s objective is to present a survey on various state-of-art model-based FD techniques developed for linear time-invariant (LTI) systems for the interested readers to learn about recent development in this field. Model-based FD techniques for LTI systems are classified as parameter-estimation methods, parity-space-based methods, and observer-based methods. The background and recent progress, in context to fault detection, of each of these methods and their practical applications are discussed in this paper. Furthermore, two different FD techniques are compared via analytical equations and simulation results obtained from the DC motor model. In the end, possible future research directions in model-based FD, particularly for the LTI system, are highlighted for prosperous researchers. A comparison and emerging research topic make this contribution different from the existing survey papers on FD.

Opportunistic Large Array Propagation Models: A Comprehensive Survey.

Enabled by the fifth-generation (5G) and beyond 5G communications, large-scale deployments of Internet-of-Things (IoT) networks are expected in various application fields to handle massive machine-type communication (mMTC) services. Device-to-device (D2D) communications can be an effective solution in massive IoT networks to overcome the inherent hardware limitations of small devices. In such D2D scenarios, given that a receiver can benefit from the signal-to-noise-ratio (SNR) advantage through diversity and array gains, cooperative transmission (CT) can be employed, so that multiple IoT nodes can create a virtual antenna array. In particular, Opportunistic Large Array (OLA), which is one type of CT technique, is known to provide fast, energy-efficient, and reliable broadcasting and unicasting without prior coordination, which can be exploited in future mMTC applications. However, OLA-based protocol design and operation are subject to network models to characterize the propagation behavior and evaluate the performance. Further, it has been shown through some experimental studies that the most widely-used model in prior studies on OLA is not accurate for networks with networks with low node density. Therefore, stochastic models using quasi-stationary Markov chain are introduced, which are more complex but more exact to estimate the key performance metrics of the OLA transmissions in practice. Considering the fact that such propagation models should be selected carefully depending on system parameters such as network topology and channel environments, we provide a comprehensive survey on the analytical models and framework of the OLA propagation in the literature, which is not available in the existing survey papers on OLA protocols. In addition, we introduce energy-efficient OLA techniques, which are of paramount importance in energy-limited IoT networks. Furthermore, we discuss future research directions to combine OLA with emerging technologies.

Authentication strategies in vehicular communications: a taxonomy and framework

In intelligent vehicular networks, vehicles have enhanced sensing capabilities and carry computing and communication platforms to enable new versatile systems known as Vehicular Communication (VC) systems. Vehicles communicate with other vehicles and with nearby fixed equipment to support different applications, including those which increase driver awareness of the surroundings. This should result in improved safety and may optimize traffic. However, VC systems are vulnerable to cyber attacks involving message manipulation. Research aimed at tackling this problem has resulted in the proposal of multiple authentication protocols. Several existing survey papers have attempted to classify some of these protocols based on a limited set of characteristics. However, to date there is no generic framework to support the comparison of these protocols and provide guidance for design and evaluation. Most existing classifications either use computation complexity of cryptographic techniques as a criterion, or they fail to make connections between different important aspects of authentication. This paper provides such a framework, proposing a new taxonomy to enable a consistent means of classifying authentication schemes based upon seven main criteria. The main contribution of this study is a framework to enable protocol designers and investigators to adequately compare and select authentication schemes when deciding on particular protocols to implement in an application. Our framework can be applied in design, making choices appropriate for the intended context in both intra-vehicle and inter-vehicle communications. We demonstrate the application of our framework using two different types of case study: individual analysis and hypothetical design. Additionally, this work makes several related contributions. We present the network model, outline the applications, list the communication patterns and the underlying standards, and discuss the necessity of using cryptography and key management in VC systems. We also review the threats, authentication, and privacy requirements in vehicular networks.

A survey on analysis and detection of Android ransomware

AbstractSmart‐phones have become a necessity for users due to their abundance of services such as global positioning system, Wi‐Fi, voice/video calls, SMS, camera, and so forth. It contains personal information of users including photos, documents, messages, and videos. Android‐based smart‐phones enriched with many applications (commonly known as apps) fascinates users to use this ubiquitous technology up to a full extent. With open architecture and 73% of market share, Android is the most popular mobile operating system (OS) among developers. At the same time, the increasing popularity of Android OS woos attackers or cyber‐criminals to exploit its vulnerabilities. The attackers write malicious code to harm the device and grab users' sensitive information. For example, ransomware (a form of malware) demands ransom from victims to liberate the ceased material for illegal financial gain. The existing survey papers cover the analysis and detection of generic Android malware. The focus of this survey paper is to present an in‐depth threat scenario of Android ransomware. This article not only provides a comprehensive survey on analysis and detection methods for Android ransomware since its beginning (2015) till date (2020); but also presents observations and suggestions for researchers and practitioners to carry out further research.

NOMA and 5G emerging technologies: A survey on issues and solution techniques

Power Domain Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (PD-NOMA) is a potential technology for the next generation of cellular networks. Compared to classical orthogonal multiple access (OMA) techniques, PD-NOMA leverages the distinct channel gains of users for multiplexing different signals in a single resource block (time, frequency, code) in power domain. This results in higher spectral efficiency, improved user fairness, better cell-edge throughput, increased reliability and connectivity and low-latency. The flexible combination of PD-NOMA with existing and emerging technologies such as heterogeneous networks (HetNets), multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO), massive MIMO, cooperative communication, cognitive radios (CRs), millimeter wave communication, simultaneous wireless information and power transfer (SWIPT), visible light communication (VLC), mobile edge computing (MEC), intelligent reflecting surfaces (IRS), unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), underwater communication etc., is expected to cause further enhancements in performance. Existing survey papers on NOMA mainly focus on its concept, comparison, issues and analysis without any categorization of different techniques to solve the issues related to it. This survey paper highlights the main issues and constraints of resource allocation, signaling, practical implementation and security aspects of NOMA and its integration with 5G and upcoming wireless technologies. Various solutions have been proposed in the literature that involve optimization, analytical, game theory, matching theory, graph theory and machine learning (ML) techniques. We present an in-depth analysis and comparison of these solutions with key insights emphasizing the feasibility and applicability for a qualitative analysis. We finally identify promising future research directions and challenges in the context of PD-NOMA’s application to the existing 5G and next generation wireless networks.

Designing web search UI for the elderly community: a systematic literature review

Now-a-days the number of older people or senior citizens are rapidly increasing across the world and their need for the internet is also increasing mostly for information searching to make them up to date with the current trends and news. Therefore, they need a search user interface that is to be elderly-friendly so as to communicate with the computing system and to attain better results for their search task. The user interface is the only way of communication between the users and the computing systems. Currently, available user interfaces focus only on youngsters' needs and their recommendations to attract them, but the need for seniors is neglected, because of which the elders could not handle these complicated user interfaces for their search task and attain their target information. Thus, this topic is in trend today by the researchers to build a new type of user interface that can cope up with the elderly needs and to improve their daily life. Even though there exists a considerable growth in this research area, there are no attempts made to analyze the existing studies systematically and utilize those ideas mentioned by various other researchers. Thus, in this systematic literature review, the existing methods of search user interfaces and the elderly user behaviors are well analyzed and then certain recommendations are proposed which are useful for future researches in this field. The objective of this systematic literature review (SLR) is to collect and analyze the facts that are proposed in existing research articles and existing designs of web search user interface that are related to the challenges, impact and limitations that elderly people are experiencing while doing a web search in their daily activities so as to gather information online. This SLR is organized by gathering all the existing survey papers and research papers that have been published over a specific period of time. These papers are systematically reviewed by some pre-defined reviewing strategy thereby making a conclusion regarding the design of user interface for the elderly community. A total of 30 studies are selected as primary subject for the literature survey regarding web search user interface for the elderly. From these selected studies, the data needed for the research are extracted using an approach of systematic mapping and are synthesized to acquire knowledge related to the current research topic. These studies are analyzed and synthesized in such a way that the knowledgeis used for answering the research questions formulated during the survey. The information regarding the user interface for interaction, the assistance provided to elderly by the existing user interfaces, the impact created by those UI’s on the elderly community and the research gaps and limitations that occur in existing researches and systems while communicating with the computing systems through a user interface for their daily internet search activities are extracted and some recommendations are proposed for future researchers. There are some more research gaps identified in the current state-of-the-art since most of the researches don’t focus on the aging of the elderly and their consequences while interacting with the computing system through a user interface. Thus, this research can help in finding a better understanding of elders and the difficulties faced by them while searching through the internet so as to develop a positive impact for the researchers to create an elderly-friendly user interface for web search activities.

Vision-Based Human Detection Techniques: A Descriptive Review

Cameras are being used everywhere for the safety and security of citizens in different countries. Using a machine to detect humans in a photo or a video frame is a very complicated and challenging task. Various techniques have been developed for this purpose, which mainly rely on Artificial Intelligence. This article aims to provide a comprehensive review and analysis of the literatures from a descriptive perspective, which is its main differentiator from the existing survey papers in this area. Firstly, the vision-based human detection techniques and classifiers are elucidated in conjunction with the variants of feature extraction techniques. Secondly, various pros and cons of such techniques are discussed. Then, an investigation has been conducted and reported based on the state-of-the-art human detection descriptors (e.g. Log-Average Miss Rate and accuracy). Although techniques such as Viola-Jones and Speeded-Up Robust Features can detect objects in real-time and overcome Scale-Invariant Feature Transform (SIFT) limitations, they are still sensitive to illuminated conditions. Other techniques such as SIFT, Bag of Words, Orthogonal Moments, and Histogram of oriented Gradients provide other interesting benefits which include insensitivity to occlusion and clutters, simplicity, low-order element construction and invariance to illuminated conditions; nevertheless, they are computationally expensive and sensitive to image rotation. A meticulous review along similar lines revealed that the Deformable Part-based Model performs relatively better due to its ability to deal with particular pose variations and multiple views, occlusion handling (partial) and is application-free while its counterparts focus on only a single aspect. This article highlights and provides a brief description of each available data-sets for human detection research. Various use-cases of human detection systems are also elaborated. Finally, various conclusions are derived based on the conducted review followed by recommendations for future directions and possibilities to further improve the speed and accuracy of human detection systems.

Современное состояние методов расчёта глобальной освещённости в задачах реалистичной компьютерной графики

Modern realistic computer graphics are based on light transport simulation. In this case, one of the main and difficult to calculate tasks is to calculate the global illumination, i.e. distribution of light in a virtual scene, taking into account multiple reflections and scattering of light and all kinds of its interaction with objects in the scene. Hundreds of publications and describing dozens of methods are devoted to this problem. In this state-of-the-art review, we would like not only to list and briefly describe these methods, but also to give some “map” of existing works, which will allow the reader to navigate, understand their advantages and disadvantages, and, thereby, choose a right method for themselves. Particular attention is paid to such characteristics of the methods as robustness and universality in relation to the used mathematical models, the transparency of the method verification, the possibility of efficient implementation on the GPU, as well as restrictions imposed on the scene or illumination phenomena. In contrast to the existing survey papers, not only the efficiency of the methods is analyzed, but also their limitations and the complexity of software implementation. In addition, we provide the results of our own numerical experiments with various methods that serve as illustrations for the conclusions.

Security Measurement in Industrial IoT with Cloud Computing Perspective: Taxonomy, Issues, and Future Directions

In recent years, cloud computing has gained massive popularity in information technology and the industrial Internet of things. It provides facilities to the users over the wireless channel. Many surveys have been carried out in cloud security and privacy. The existing survey papers do not specify the classifications on the basis of cloud computing components. Therefore, they fail to provide the techniques with their specialities as well as the previously available literature review is outdated. This paper presents the security for cloud computing models with a new aspect. Unlike the previously existing surveys, the literature review of this paper includes the latest research papers in the field of cloud security. Also, different classifications are made for cloud computing security on the basis of different cloud components that are used to secure the cloud models. Furthermore, a total of eleven (11) classifications are considered, which includes cloud components to secure the cloud systems. These classifications help the researchers to find out the desired technique used in a specific component to secure the cloud model. Moreover, the shortcoming of each component enables the researchers to design an optimal algorithm. Finally, future directions are given to highlight future research challenges that give paths to researchers.