Extracts of the Chilean soapbark tree, Quillaja Saponaria (QS) are the source of potent immune-stimulatory saponin compounds. This study compared the adjuvanticity and toxicity of QS-18 and QS-21, assessing the potential to substitute QS-18 in place of QS-21 for vaccine development. QS-18, the most abundant QS saponin fraction, has been largely overlooked due to safety concerns. We found that QS-18 spontaneously inserted into liposomes, thereby neutralizing hemolytic activity, and following administration did not induce local reactogenicity in a footpad swelling test in mice. With high-dose intramuscular administration, transient weight loss was minor, and QS-18 did not induce significantly more weight loss compared to a liposome vaccine adjuvant system lacking it. Two days after administration, no elevation of inflammatory cytokines was detected in murine serum. In a formulation including cobalt-porphyrin-phospholipid (CoPoP) for short peptide sequestration, QS-18 did not impact the formation of peptide nanoparticles. With immunization, QS-18 peptide particles induced higher levels of cancer neoepitope-specific and tumor-associated antigen-specific CD8+ T cells compared to QS-21 particles, without indication of greater toxicity based on mouse body weight. T cell receptor sequencing of antigen-specific CD8+ T cells showed that QS-18 induced significantly more T cell transcripts. In two murine cancer models, vaccination with QS-18 peptide particles induced a similar therapeutic effect as QS-21 particles, without indication of increased toxicity. Antigen-specific CD8+ T cells in the tumor microenvironment were found to express the exhaustion marker PD-1, pointing to the rationale for exploring combination therapy. Taken together, these data demonstrate that QS-18, when formulated in liposomes, can be a safe and effective adjuvant to induce tumor-inhibiting cellular responses in murine models with potential to facilitate or diminish costs of production for vaccine adjuvant systems. Further studies are warranted to assess liposomal QS-18 immunogic, reactogenic and toxicological profiles in mice and other animal species.
Read full abstract