The existence of consistent trait-like inter-individual differences in the ability to sustain objective psychomotor vigilance and subjective alertness during periods of sleep deprivation has been well established. However, it has proven difficult to identify reliable cognitive, biological, or demographic variables that predict this capacity. In several different studies, our lab has found that the trait of introversion-extraversion appears to be predictive of this capacity, particularly for psychomotor vigilance. Here we explore whether this trait also predicts the ability to sustain higher-level executive functions of planning and sequencing abilities. 17 males and 5 females (Mage= 25.05, SD= 3.98) participated in a double-blind drug study (placebo N= 11; caffeine 200 mg every two hours between 0100 and 0700, N= 11) during 3 nights of sleep deprivation. Participants completed the Tower of London (TOL), a measure of planning and sequencing, after 4, 52, and 76 hours of total sleep deprivation. Baseline measures of personality traits (NEO-PI-R inventory), state and trait anger (STAXI-2), and odor identification ability (UPSIT) were collected before sleep loss. Stepwise linear regression was conducted to predict change in TOL performance, as measured by throughput (i.e., the average number of correct bead placements per minute), above and beyond the effects of caffeine. At 52 hours of sleep deprivation, better sustained TOL throughput was predicted by lower Extraversion (higher introversion; β=-.41, p=.048), which was above and beyond the effects of caffeine (β=.32, p=.12). At 76 hours of wakefulness, higher TOL throughput was predicted again by lower Extraversion (higher introversion; β=-.50, p=.01) as well as higher Conscientiousness (β=.40, p=.04), above and beyond the non-significant effect of caffeine (β=.16, p=.38). Consistent with prior work on psychomotor vigilance, the trait of introversion-extraversion was also predictive of the ability to sustain executive function capacities of planning and sequencing after two and three nights of sleep deprivation. Supported by the Knowledge Preservation Program at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research administered by the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education.
Read full abstract