AbstractThe binary cation exchange processes, Na → Ca, Na → Mg, and Ca → Mg, were investigated at 298 K for a montmorillonitic soil separate (principally clay and silt) suspended in a 50 mol m−3 perchlorate background at pH 6, 6.6, or 7. The resulting exchange isotherms indicated some preference on the soil for Ca and Mg over Na, and for Ca over Mg. These preferences were attributed primarily to organic matter associated with the soil separate, since previous studies had shown that pure montmorillonite exhibits essentially no preference among the three cations under the same conditions as in the present experiments. The exchange isotherms at pH 6, 6.6, and 7 were congruent for all three binary exchange reactions, showing that, at these pH values, proton competition did not affect the exchange selectivity of the soil. The total adsorbed metal charge, Q0, however, increased with the pH value, as expected from the presence of organic matter in the soil, and varied with the surface composition of the exchanger. This variation was rationalized as a net effect of the ionic potential and Lewis acid softness properties of the exchangeable metal cations. Greater ionic potential was considered to result in greater proton displacing power, whereas greater Lewis acid softness was considered to result in stronger complex formation between a metal cation and organic functional groups. Thus, increasing ionic potential could produce an increase in Q0, but increasing Lewis acid softness could produce a decrease in exchangeability and consequent decrease in Q0. Ionic potential was the dominant consideration in Na → Mg exchange, whereas Lewis acid softness played the principal role in Na → Ca and Mg → Ca exchange.
Read full abstract