Color Evolution Research Articles

Human-driven evolution of color in a stonefly mimic.

Rapid adaptation is thought to be critical for the survival of species under global change, but our understanding of human-induced evolution in the wild remains limited. We show that widespread deforestation has underpinned repeated color shifts in wild insect populations. Specifically, loss of forest has led to color changes across lineages that mimic the warning coloration of a toxic forest stonefly. Predation experiments suggest that the relative fitness of color phenotypes varies between forested and deforested habitats. Genomic and coloration analyses of 1200 specimens show repeated selection at the ebony locus controlling color polymorphism across lineages. These findings represent an example of human-driven evolution linked to altered species interactions, highlighting the possibility for populations to adapt rapidly in the wake of sudden environmental change.

Interactions between sexual signaling and wing size drive ecology and evolution of wing colors in Odonata

Insect coloration has evolved in response to multiple pressures, and in Odonata (dragonflies and damselflies) a body of work supports a role of wing color in a variety of visual signals and potentially in thermoregulation. Previous efforts have focused primarily on melanistic coloration even though wings are often multicolored, and there has yet to be comprehensive comparative analyses of wing color across broad geographic regions and phylogenetic groups. Percher vs. flier flight-style, a trait with thermoregulatory and signaling consequences, has not yet been studied with regard to color. We used a new color clustering approach to quantify color across a dataset of over 8,000 odonate wing images representing 343 Nearctic species. We then utilized phylogenetically informed Bayesian zero-inflated mixture models to test how color varies with mean ambient temperature, body size, sex and flight-style. We found that wing coloration clustered into two groups across all specimens - light brown-yellow and black-dark brown - with black-dark brown being a much more cohesive grouping. Male perchers have a greater proportion of black-dark brown color on their wings as do species with longer wings. In colder climates, odonates were more likely to have black-dark brown color present, but we found no relationship between the proportion of black and temperature. Light brown-yellow showed similar scaling with wing length, but no relationship with temperature. Our results suggest that black-dark brown coloration may have a limited role in thermoregulation, while light brown-yellow does not have such a role. We also find that the odonate sexes are divergent in wing color in percher species only, suggesting a strong role for color in signaling in more territorial males. Our research contributes to an understanding of complex interactions driving ecological and evolutionary dynamics of color in animals.

Off-Axis Color Characteristics of Binary Neutron Star Merger Events: Applications for Space Multi-Band Variable Object Monitor and James Webb Space Telescope

With advancements in gravitational wave detection technology, an increasing number of binary neutron star (BNS) merger events are expected to be detected. Due to the narrow opening angle of jet cores, many BNS merger events occur off-axis, resulting in numerous gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) going undetected. Models suggest that kilonovae, which can be observed off-axis, offer more opportunities to be detected in the optical/near-infrared band as electromagnetic counterparts of BNS merger events. In this study, we calculate kilonova emission using a three-dimensional semi-analytical code and model the GRB afterglow emission with the open-source Python package afterglowpy at various inclination angles. Our results show that it is possible to identify the kilonova signal from the observed color evolution of BNS merger events. We also deduce the optimal observing window for SVOM/VT and JWST/NIRCam, which depends on the viewing angle, jet opening angle, and circumburst density. These parameters can be cross-checked with the multi-band afterglow fitting. We suggest that kilonovae are more likely to be identified at larger inclination angles, which can also help determine whether the observed signals without accompanying GRBs originate from BNS mergers.

Teaching a More Accurate Model of the Evolution of Human Skin Color

In popular materials designed to teach American students about the evolution of human skin color, students are guided toward a model in which ancestral latitude predicts levels of skin pigmentation. While this model agrees with data from people whose ancestors practiced intensive agriculture in Europe, Asia, and Africa, this model does not match data from other human populations across the globe, including the predicted skin pigmentation of ancient hunter-gatherer populations who maintained long-term settlements in these same regions. In this review, we discuss findings from ancient genome sequencing and provide guidance on teaching an updated model on the evolution of human skin color. (To increase accessibility for non-specialists, we present here a targeted rationale for updating classroom teaching practices, with a set of frequently asked questions regarding the current state of scientific research on this topic addressed in supplemental material.) With this update, we hope to help students avoid common misconceptions about human evolution—particularly, that the evolutionary pressures encountered by those who adopted a single human culture would apply to all humans, everywhere—and leverage authentic data and argumentation to convey the anti-racist reality that people with a wide range of skin colors thrived in high-latitude regions for many thousands of years, just as students with a wide range of skin colors can thrive in whatever place they currently call home.

Nanosecond pulsed laser coloring of the CrMnFeCoNi high entropy alloy

High-entropy alloys (HEAs) possess great potential for applications in the aerospace and military fields due to their excellent performance. Surface coloring can endow HEAs diverse functions. However, achieving a multi-color surface with minimal surface damage and cost remains a significant challenge. In this study, surface coloring of the CrMnFeCoNi HEA was attempted by nanosecond pulsed laser irradiation in air, and the multi-color surface was achieved. The evolution of surface color and morphology with laser parameters was analyzed. Then, five typical colors were selected, and the corresponding morphologies and chemical compositions were characterized by various techniques. The results showed that the change in oxide layer thickness as well as the formation of chromium-rich β-spinel and Cr (VI) compounds induced noticeable changes in surface color. Accordingly, complex surface patterns with various stable colors were prepared on the HEA surface, demonstrating the potential application of nanosecond pulsed laser coloring of HEAs.

Unraveling the color evolution and metabolic pathways of pelargonidin-3-O-glucoside during lactic acid fermentation of the strawberry juice color simulation system: A novel perspective through untargeted metabolomics

This study aimed to unraveling the color evolution and metabolic pathways of pelargonidin-3-O-glucoside (P3G) during lactic acid fermentation of the strawberry juice color simulation system. The results revealed that fermentation with both Lactobacillus plantarum and Lactobacillus acidophilus caused a decline in pH of the strawberry juice color simulation system and significantly accelerated the decrease in P3G content. The CIELAB space model pointed out that parameters a⁎ and b⁎ of the group treated with both lactic acid bacteria and P3G initially increased to a peak level and then gradually decreased, shifting the overall color towards orange and then gradually fading. Furthermore, untargeted metabolomics results revealed that P3G was progressively degraded and converted to pyruvate, methylparaben, 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid, p-anisic acid, and terephthalic acid, affecting the metabolic pathways of glycolysis, d-amino acids, benzoate degradation, aromatic compounds degradation, and aminobenzoate degradation in lactic acid bacteria.

Evolution of HOD and galaxy properties in filaments and nodes of the cosmic web

ABSTRACT We study the evolution of the halo occupation distribution (HOD) and galaxy properties of nodes and filamentary structures obtained by disperse from the Illustris TNG300-1 hydrodynamical simulation, in the redshift range $0 \le z \le 2$. We compute the HOD in filaments and nodes and fit the HOD parameters to study their evolution for both faint and bright galaxies. In nodes, the number of faint galaxies increases with decreasing redshift in the low-mass haloes, while no significant differences are seen in high-mass haloes. Limiting the HOD to bright galaxies shows that haloes increase in mass more than the number of bright galaxies they accrete. For filaments, no large differences in HOD are found for faint galaxies, although for brighter galaxies the behaviour is the same as in nodes. The HOD parametrization suggests that filaments have no effect on the mass required to host a galaxy (central or satellite), whereas nodes do. The results of the study indicate that with this parametrization, filaments do not seem to affect the stellar mass content of galaxies. In contrast, nodes appear to affect haloes with masses below approximately $10^{12.5} h^{-1} {\rm M}_{\odot }$ at local redshift. The analysis of the galaxy colour evolution shows a reddening towards lower redshift, although these processes seem to be more efficient in massive haloes, with a strong effect on bright galaxies. The general evolution suggests that the building of galaxy population within haloes is influenced by both the accretion of faint galaxies and the mass growth of the bright ones.

Early-time Observations of SN 2023wrk: A Luminous Type Ia Supernova with Significant Unburned Carbon in the Outer Ejecta

We present extensive photometric and spectroscopic observations of the nearby Type Ia supernova (SN) 2023wrk at a distance of about 40 Mpc. The earliest detection of this SN can be traced back to a few hours after the explosion. Within the first few days, the light curve shows a bump feature, while the B − V color is blue and remains nearly constant. The overall spectral evolution is similar to that of an SN 1991T/SN 1999aa-like SN Ia, while the C ii λ6580 absorption line appears to be unusually strong in the first spectrum taken at t ≈ −15.4 days after the maximum light. This carbon feature disappears quickly in subsequent evolution but it reappears at around the time of peak brightness. The complex evolution of the carbon line and the possible detection of Ni iii absorption around 4700 Å and 5300 Å in the earliest spectra indicate macroscopic mixing of fuel and ash. The strong carbon lines are likely related to the collision of SN ejecta with unbound carbon, consistent with the predictions of pulsational delayed-detonation or carbon-rich circumstellar-matter interaction models. Among those carbon-rich SNe Ia with strong C ii λ6580 absorption at very early times, the line-strength ratio of C ii to Si ii and the B − V color evolution are found to exhibit large diversity, which may be attributed to different properties of unbound carbon and outward-mixing 56Ni.

Electroluminescent and photoluminescent light-emitting diodes from carbon dots and device architecture optimization.

Light emission from carbon dots (CDs) is of great interest in both electroluminescence and photoluminescence. Herein, we construct electroluminescent and photoluminescent light-emitting diodes (LEDs) from emitters of CDs. The electroluminescent LED with host-guest-doped dual emissive layers (EMLs) of [poly(9-vinylcarbazole) (PVK)-CDs] × 2 gives satisfactory electro-optical properties, with maximum luminance of 560 cd m-2 at 16 V, luminous efficiency of 0.183 cd A-1, power efficiency of 0.082 lm W-1, and external quantum efficiency of 0.25%, which are superior to the counterparts with single-EML of CDs, single-EML of [PVK-CDs], and triple-EMLs of [PVK-CDs] × 3. These enhanced properties are rationally ascribed to optimization of the device architecture, carrier balance improvement, and reduction in concentration-induced quenching. The electroluminescent LEDs also show color evolution from PVK to CDs, and/or to the PVK/CDs interface, with increasing driving voltages, owing to incomplete energy transfer from PVK to CDs. Highly efficient photoluminescent LEDs with 365- and 395-nm UV excitation are demonstrated. With a CDs : polyvinyl pyrrolidone ratio of 1 : 3, the 365-nm excited photoluminescent LED gives a maximum luminance of 512 347 cd m-2 with a power efficiency of 25.2 lm W-1, while the 395-nm excited photoluminescent device gives a maximum luminance of 670 954 cd m-2 with a power efficiency of 22.0 lm W-1, with both showing yellow emission. Our experiments provide some new ideas for broadening CD applications and advancing LEDs.

Caged AIEgens: Multicolor and White Emission Triggered by Mechanical Activation.

Aggregation-induced emission luminogens (AIEgens) that respond to mechanical force are increasingly used as force probes, memory devices, and advanced security systems. Most of the known mechanisms to modulate mechanoresponsive AIEgens have been based on changes in aggregation states, involving only physical alterations. Instances that employ covalent bond cleavage are still rare. We have developed a novel mechanochemical uncaging strategy to unveil AIEgens with diverse emission characteristics using engineered norborn-2-en-7-one (NEO) mechanophores. These NEO mechanophores were covalently integrated into polymer molecules and activated in both the solution and solid states. This activation resulted in highly tunable fluorescence upon immobilization through solidification or aggregation, producing blue, green, yellow, and orange-red emissions. By designing the caged and uncaged forms as donor-acceptor pairs for Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), we achieved multicolor mechanofluorescence, effectively broadening the color spectrum to include white emission. Additionally, we computationally explored the electronic structures of activated NEOs, providing insights into the observed regiochemical effects of the substituents. This understanding, together with the novel luminogenic characteristics of the caged and activated species, provides a highly tunable reporter that traces progress with continuous color evolution. This advancement paves the way for future applications of mechanoresponsive materials in areas like damage detection and bioimaging.

Testing for heterogeneous rates of discrete character evolution on phylogenies

Abstract Many hypotheses in the field of phylogenetic comparative biology involve specific changes in the rate or process of trait evolution. This is particularly true of approaches designed to connect macroevolutionary pattern to microevolutionary process. We present a method to test whether the rate of evolution of a discrete character has changed in one or more clades, lineages, or time periods. This method differs from other related approaches (such as the “covarion” model) in that the “regimes” in which the rate or process is postulated to have changed are specified a priori by the user, rather than inferred from the data. Similarly, it differs from methods designed to model a correlation between two binary traits in that the regimes mapped onto the tree are fixed. We apply our method to investigate the rate of dewlap colour and/or caudal vertebra number evolution in Caribbean and mainland clades of the diverse lizard genus Anolis. We find little evidence to support any difference in the evolutionary process between mainland and island evolution for either character. We also examine the statistical properties of the method more generally and show that it has acceptable type I error, parameter estimation, and power. Finally, we discuss some general issues of frequentist hypothesis testing and model adequacy, as well as the relationship of our method to existing models of heterogeneity in the rate of discrete character evolution on phylogenies.

Shining a Light on the Specimen Room: Enhancing Global Research on Bird Eggs through Standardized Digital Archives

Bird egg collections in natural history museums are valuable resources for studies such as how birds’ eggs may evolve under different environmental conditions, providing information that is critical in our changing world and of great interest to scientists. However, the millions of bird egg specimens, many collected over 100 years ago, are often not prioritized in digitized archives. To assess the current status of digitized egg specimens, we examined data available on open-source platforms such as iDigBio, based on the Marini et al. (2020) review of egg collections. Millions of bird egg specimens are preserved in museums worldwide, but only about 21% have been digitally cataloged and made accessible on global platforms, mostly from Western countries. While the technology used for extracting features from digital objects has greatly advanced for studying the size, color and spottiness of eggs (e.g., SpotEgg), the digitized specimens may not be formatted to meet the needs for research, thereby limiting their application. For example, among eight museums with digitized collections, images from six include a scale, but only the Yale Peabody Museum also incorporates a color chart with standardized gray patches for calibration (e.g., Calibrite Color Checker). Furthermore, coordinates obtained through georeferencing are essential for studying environmental influences on egg traits. Yet, fewer than half of the specimens (49%) have been georeferenced. Here we demonstrate how properly digitized specimens—using a dark background, adding a scale, and incorporating a standard color chart in the photo—can be utilized to study the evolution of egg color in birds. We urge the adoption of a standard digitization protocol for bird egg collections, the enhancement of georeferencing for the specimens, and the integration of local databases into global platforms to increase accessibility for the scientific community. These procedures should also be implemented at the early stage of the digitization process to maximize the value of digitized specimens.

Analysis of the Influence of the Size of Color-Calibrated Schlieren Filters on the General Sensitivity of Quantitative Schlieren Systems

The quantitative color schlieren technique is renowned for its capacity to convert deflection angles into color ratios. This technique has been instrumental in providing data on 2D flows. The current study delves into assessing how the geometry and optical characteristics of color filters impact the sensitivity of the schlieren system. At present, there are many papers making the assumption that implementing a larger-sized color filter leads to better system sensitivity. However, having more calibration filter positions can lead to measurement errors due to the difficult calibration process. The present investigation focuses on the type of color filters created with a gradual evolution of colors. A turbulent, round water vapor jet serves as the test case. By comparing the results obtained with two different filter sizes, this analysis gives insight into the compromises made between system sensitivity and ease of calibration, helping one to better understand the trade-offs between the above-mentioned parameters. Moreover, the quantitative and qualitative results of the test case are presented to offer more comprehensive insights into quantitative color-calibrated schlieren.

A new cockroach (Blattodea, Rhipidoblattinidae) from the Toarcian (Lower Jurassic) of Alderton Hill, Gloucestershire, UK, and the earliest likely occurrence of aposematic colouration in cockroaches

AbstractWe describe the seventh valid species of cockroach, Alderblattina simmsi gen. et sp. nov., from insect‐rich strata recording the Toarcian Oceanic Anoxic Event (T‐OAE). The T‐OAE represents a period of extreme global warming and environmental change that drove palaeoecological pressures and evolutionary changes in marine and terrestrial ecosystems. Here, for the first time, we present evidence that this event may also be the driver for the evolution of aposematic colouration, a predator deterrent, in cockroaches. The specimen, an isolated compressed tegmen, was collected at Alderton Hill, Gloucestershire, UK, and is assigned to a new genus and species, based on the following unique combination of characteristics: small forewing; 15 branches of R and 11 branches of M + CuA; strong cross‐vein between R and M; intercalaries; and two well‐defined subspherical maculae (spots) and colouration at the wing tip. Alderblattina simmsi is assigned to the family Rhipidoblattinidae Rohdendorf, primarily based on its small size and the presence of branched anal veins in the clavus. The colouration present on A. simmsi represents the first recorded likely occurrence of aposematism in cockroaches, and provides evidence for the evolution of colour patterning in Blattodea.

A review of plant phenolics and endozoochory.

Phenolic compounds (phenolics) are secondary metabolites ubiquitous across plants. The earliest phenolics are linked to plants' successful transition from an aquatic to a terrestrial environment, serving as protection against damaging ultraviolet (UV) radiation, and as antioxidants to reduce oxidative stress in an atmosphere with an increasingly high O2:CO2 ratio. In modern plants, phenolics are best known for the defense against fungal and bacterial pathogens and as antifeedants that deter herbivory. Phenolics also play a role in seed dormancy, delaying germination, and lengthening viability in the seed bank. Many plants' seeds are endozoochorous - dispersed by animals, like birds, who eat and later excrete the seeds. Plants send visual signals to attract birds with UV-sensitive (UVS) vision for pollination and seed dispersal. As fruits ripen, antioxidant activity and phenolic content decrease. The waxy cuticle of fruits increases in UV reflection as phenolic rings, which absorb UV light, degrade. The UV contrast that birds detect may act as an honest signal, indicating nutritional changes in the fruit. However, there is little evidence to support the evolution of UV coloration during ripening being driven by frugivore selection. Antioxidant properties of fruit phenolics may be dually adaptive in plants and avian frugivores.

Ecological, genetic and geographical divergence explain differences in colouration among sunbird species (Nectariniidae).

How extravagant ornamental traits evolve is a key question in evolutionary biology. Bird plumages are among the most elaborate ornaments, displaying almost all colours of the rainbow. Why and how birds evolved to be so colourful remains an open question with multiple and sometimes competing hypotheses. Different colours in different patches (i.e. body parts) might have different functions and thus result from different forms of selection (e.g. natural vs. sexual selection). Here we test the influence of three factors on colour diversity in sunbirds: (1) geographical distance, (2) differences in light environment and (3) phylogenetic distances. We show that both natural and sexual selection affect the evolution of sunbird colouration, but that their extent and direction differs between sexes, and varies with the extent of species overlap and across different patches on the body. Even though overlap in light environment partially explains colour differences among species, no colour metric (brightness, hue or chroma) covaries with light environment. Our results suggest that multiple forms of selection influence the colouration of different colour patches in different ways across an organism's body, highlighting the need to investigate colouration as a network of individual but inter-connected colour patches. These results are likely to be generalizable across the multitude of colourful animals.

Influence of a double-stage solar tunnel dryer on the preservation of quality characteristics and the Modelling of colour variations in red chili peppers

In this work, the influence of two-stage solar tunnel drying on the preservation of quality attributes of both chili pepper varieties, Mareko Fana (MF) and Bako Local (BL), was studied. Both varieties were dried in different drying modalities, i.e. solar tunnel and open sun drying. The quality attributes were evaluated during the drying process using FTIR and spectrophotometry techniques. Different colour evolution models were implemented and a suitable model was selected. The results showed that after drying of the Mareko Fana chili variety, the lightness retention was found in the range of 81 %–89 %, the redness retention between 25 % and 42 % and the yellowness retention between 14 % and 38 %. For the Bako Local variety, the values were in the range of 78 %–82 %, 42 %–60 % and 36 %–55 %, respectively. The first order model gave a higher correlation coefficient (R2 > 0.96), which indicated the suitability of the model for predicting the color variation for both varieties. The volatile aromatic compounds in the chili peppers were greatly lost during open sun drying, while solar tunnel drying maintained these compounds for both varieties. However, during the solar tunnel drying process, a significant amount of alkyl halides or alkyl-chlorides were lost. The amount of dihydrocapsaicin and capsaicin from the chili peppers ranged from 10,172 μg/kg to 16,313 μg/kg and 16,676 μg/kg to 27,189 μg/kg for both dihydrocapsaicin and capsaicin, respectively. In tunnel, open-air, and uncontrolled open-air solar drying, the MF chili variety lost copsaicinoid content by 3.4 %, 14.8 %, and 38.3 %, respectively; in the BL variety, comparable losses were 1.8 %, 4.4 %, and 13.6 %. A minimum loss of ascorbic acids was recorded during solar tunnel drying. The results showed that well-designed double stage solar tunnel dryers are important for effective drying processes that preserve quality attributes of the chili pepper.

Impact of high sensitizer doping on the transient multiband upconversion luminescence in β-NaYF4:Yb/Ho microcrystals

Under intense near-infrared light excitation, upconversion luminescence (UCL) nanomaterials exhibit multiband emission and high sensitizer quenching concentration, indicating the potential to enhance upconversion (UC) quantum efficiency. In comparison to other common activator ions (e.g. Er3+, Tm3+, Ho3+), Ho3+ possesses abundant energy levels. However, previous studies mostly focused on the red (Ho3+:5F5 → 5I8) and green (Ho3+:5F4,5S2 → 5I8) emissions. In this paper, we have examined the transient UCL characteristics of β-NaYF4:Yb/Ho microcrystals (MCs) excited by a high-power 976 nm ns pulsed laser (∼0.32 GW/cm2). The energy transfer (ET) pathways with varying Yb3+ doping (20–98 mol%) are determined by the time evolution spectra. In high Yb3+ doping system (98 mol%), the electron population of Ho3+ accelerates, and the multiband UC rise is shortened by 6 times (from ∼3 μs to ∼500 ns). We identified a new pathway for electron populating with higher Yb3+ doping ( ≥ 40 mol%), which is Yb3+:2F5/2 + Ho3+:3L9 → Yb3+:2F7/2 + Ho3+:3M9. As Yb3+ concentration increases, the varying lifetime and intensity distribution of UCL leads to variations in the luminescence color evolution. Our result shows that altering the Yb3+ doping concentration provides a way to control the energy flow between energy levels of Ho3+, which can modulate the rise time and color evolution of Yb–Ho co-doped UC MCs. This study is expected to promote the advancement of fast-respond optoelectronic devices, UC displays, and micro-nano lasers. Kewordsmultiband upconversion luminescence; high-power excitation; upconversion luminescence dynamics; high sensitizer concentration; upconversion pathways.

Rapid assessment of acetophenone using an anti-interfering triple-emission Ln3+-functionalized HOF@MOF sensor

The development of high-performance sensors for rapidly detecting acetylacetone (AP) in water samples is necessary because its release into the environment can result in many vital problems for human health and environment. Herein, we first designed a hybrid by integrating HOF with ZIF-8 through a sequential growth strategy. By separately introducing blue-emitting SiQDs and green- and red-emitting Tb3+ and Eu3+ into ZIF-8 and HOF, the resultant ZIF-8@SiQDs@HOF@Eu3+@Tb3+ comprised three emission peaks at 484, 545 and 620 nm, all of which could be employed as switch-off responsive peaks to low concentrations of AP with a detection limit of 0.79 ppm. However, in environments with high concentrations of AP, a turn-on signal at 484 nm was observed. Thereupon, the ratiometric fluorescence intensity of the ternary emission varied within different concentration ranges, accompanied by the fluorescence color evolution from red to salmon to plum to purple to final blue. Moreover, a portable sensing film was fabricated for rapid warning, sensitive and visual determination of AP in complicated environments. Therefore, this triple-emission sensor with wide color variations and strong anti-interference advantages could promote further research to improve the selectivity, sensitivity and inherent self-correction of multimodal fluorescence detection and the ease of sensing operation.

Size differences among canaries, goldfinches and allies may explain correlated evolution of song and colour.

Sexual signals such as colour ornamentation and birdsong evolve independently of each other in some clades, and in others they evolve positively or negatively correlated. We rarely know why correlated evolution does or does not occur. Here, we show positively correlated evolution between plumage colour and song motor performance among canaries, goldfinches and allies, associated with species differences in body size. When controlling for body size, the pattern of correlated evolution between song performance and colour disappeared. Syllable diversity was not as strongly associated with size, and did not evolve in a correlated manner with colour. We argue that correlated evolution between song and colour was mediated by large size limiting song motor performance, likely due to constraints on the speed of moving heavier bills, and by larger species having less saturated plumage colour, possibly due to life-history traits of larger birds (e.g. longevity, stable pairs) contributing to weaker sexual selection. Results are consistent with the hypothesis that correlated evolution between sexual signals is influenced by how, in a clade, selective pressures and constraints affecting each type of signal happen to be co-distributed across species. Such contingency helps explain the diversity in clade-specific patterns of correlated evolution between sexual signals.