Evaluation Of Protein Quality Research Articles

PSI-16 Evaluation of protein quality of defatted black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens) larvae meal compared with traditional protein sources for dogs and cats

Abstract There is increased interest in the use of insects, such as black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens) larvae meal (BSFLM), as an alternative protein source in pet foods. However, additional information is needed to determine how BSFL protein quality compares with traditional pet food protein sources. Thus, the objectives of this study were to determine the chemical composition, amino acid digestibility, and protein quality of defatted BSFLM in comparison with whole egg powder (WEP) and chicken meal (CM) using the precision-fed cecectomized rooster assay. Fifteen cecectomized roosters (n = 5 per substrate) were randomly allocated to the test substrates BSFLM, CM, and WEP. After 26 h of feed withdrawal, 20 g of substrates were crop-fed and excreta were collected for 48 h. Digestible indispensable amino acid score (DIAAS)-like values were calculated using the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO), The European Pet Food Industry Federation (FEDIAF), and National Research Council (NRC) reference values for different life stages of dogs and cats. Data were analyzed using SAS Proc Mixed 9.4 with P ≤ 0.05 significance. On a dry matter basis, CM had the greatest crude protein (70.2%), followed by BSFLM (59.8%), and WEP (51.2%). In general, WEP had greater amino acid digestibility than BSFLM and CM. BSFLM (84%) and CM (84%) had comparable arginine digestibility, but less than WEP (92%). Lysine digestibility was greater for BSFLM (80%) in contrast with CM (74%), but less than WEP (91%). DIAAS-like values were calculated, revealing methionine + cysteine as the first limiting amino acids for growing puppies and adult dogs in BSFLM according to AAFCO, FEDIAF, and NRC, whereas for CM threonine was the first limiting amino acid based on AAFCO, and phenylalanine + tyrosine based on NRC and FEDIAF. NRC identified methionine and cysteine as limiting for all test substrates in adult dogs. Methionine and cysteine were limiting for growing kittens for BSFLM among AAFCO, FEDIAF, and NRC. For CM and WEP, phenylalanine and tyrosine was the first-limiting amino acid by NRC and FEDIAF. For adult cats, phenylalanine and tyrosine were the limiting amino acid for BSFLMand CM according to AAFCO and FEDIAF, with NRC identifying it as limiting across all protein sources. In summary, methionine and cysteine and/or phenylalanine and tyrosine were the primary limiting amino acids among the protein sources evaluated. In general, BSFLM had comparable indispensable standardized amino acid digestibility to CM.

Pig True Ileal Digestible Amino Acid Contents of Individual Ingredients are Additive in Mixed Meals and Allow Accurate Predictions of Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score Values

BackgroundAlthough not every food protein contributes sufficient quantities of all of the indispensable amino acids (AAs) required for human health, the human diet is a mixture of foods. It is therefore important to evaluate protein quality in mixed meals. ObjectivesThe hypothesis was that the true ileal digestible AA content of mixed meals can be predicted from the amounts of digestible AA determined for individual food ingredients, allowing further prediction of the digestible indispensable amino acid score (DIAAS) for meals. MethodsFour diets contained either pea protein isolate (PPI), whey protein concentrate (WPC), or mixtures of PPI:WPC at a ratio of 25:75 (PP25) or 75:25 (PP75). Six ileal cannulated pigs were allocated to a 4 × 6 Latin Square design. Experimental diets at 10% protein and a protein-free diet were fed for 7 d with ileal digesta collection on days 6 and 7. True ileal digestibility (TID) of AA, amount of digestible AA, and DIAAS were calculated for each diet and predicted for the 2 mixed meals. ResultsPredicted and determined digestible AA contents of the mixed diets were not different. The predicted values fell within the confidence interval (95%) of the determined values. DIAAS for PPI was 61% and for WPC it was 96%. DIAAS calculated based on the predicted amounts of digestible AA for PP25 was 104% and for PP75 83%. These values were nearly identical to the determined values of 104% and 84% for PP25 and PP75, respectively. ConclusionsThe amount of digestible AA and DIAAS can be accurately predicted in mixtures of PP and WPC from the AA digestibility values for the individual ingredients.

EFFECT OF CONSUMING PREBIOTIC BISCUIT BASED ON PROTEIN QUALITY EVALUATION BY IN VIVO METHOD

ABSTRACTBackground: Prebiotic biscuits are biscuits made from composite flour consisting of plaintain hump flour, yellow sweet potato flour, black soybean flour and black soybean sprouts flour. The combination of the resulting composite flour is known to have a higher nutritional value when compared to wheat flour. However, prebiotic biscuits contain certain ingredients such as protein or food fiber whose structure must be known in advance to modify their functional properties after consumption. Objective: The evaluation of protein quality was carried out to determine the effect of giving “BonnisA” prebiotic biscuits with different protein sources in increasing the quality of protein in Vivo. Methods: Research method used was experimental which was analyzed descriptively with 4 treatments 5 times. The object used in this experiment are male wistar rats (Sprague Dawley) weighing 150 - 220 g, and the treatments were given were black soybean flour prebiotic biscuits, prebiotic biscuits with black soybean sprouts flour, standard rations and egg white flour. Results: The results obtained showed that the highest increase in body weight of rats was treated with the prebiotic biscuit BonnisA black soybean flour of 13.29%. Furthermore, the evaluation of protein quality on rats was increased in black soybean flour prebiotic biscuits based on true digestibility (TD) (99.21%), biological values (BV) (99.25%), and net protein utilization (NPU) (98.47%).Conclusions: The evaluation of protein quality showed that there was a significant difference (p <0.05) between the provision of black soybean flour prebiotic biscuits and prebiotic biscuits with black soybean sprouts flour and standard rations and egg white flour at true digestibility (TD), biological values (BV) and Net Protein Utilization (NPU).Keywords : Prebiotic biscuits, Evaluation of protein quality, In Vivo

Dietary supplementation of black cumin (Nigella sativa) meal in the formulation of protein-enriched cookies, further invivo evaluation of protein quality with physicochemical and organoleptic characterization.

Nigella sativa has solid historical importance as a medicinal herb and is widely used in the bakery industry. The study revealed that the defatted black cumin meal (DBCM) possesses a high nutritious composition and amino acid profile, such as Leu, Lys, Arg, Phe, and Glu. The supplementation effect of wheat flour with defatted black cumin meal (DBCM) at levels of 5%-25% was explored on the cookies' nutritional, functional, and organoleptic attributes. Moreover, the present work was conducted to assess the invivo protein quality of defatted black cumin meal (DBCM)-supplemented cookies using the albino rat's experimental modeling for 10 days. Rheological characterization suggested a solid elastic behavior for all cookies dough with elevation in G' (138,652-230,926 Pa), G" (34201-45,092 Pa), and G* values due to protein addition. The functional characteristics of the flour blends showed that DBCM addition significantly (p ≤ .05) improved oil (70.56%-165%) and water (84.83%-232.67%) absorption capacities, emulsion, and foaming stability. The physicochemical and organoleptic assessment of the cookies exposed that a 20% level of substitution of DBCM produced acceptable cookies. The net protein utilization (NPU), protein efficiency ratio (PER), true digestibility (TD), and biological value (BV) significantly differ from each other among all the supplementation diet groups with 0%-25% DBCM.

Digestible indispensable amino acid score (DIAAS): 10 years on.

The objective of the review is to revisit the findings of the 2011 Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) Expert Consultation on Dietary Protein Quality Evaluation in Human Nutrition, and to report on progress on uptake of the findings. It is evident that since 2011 there has been a concerted research effort to enhance an understanding of the protein quality of foods. The validity of the growing pig ileal protein digestibility assay has been confirmed and numerous studies reported using the growing pig as a model to give true ileal amino acid digestibility values for foods as consumed by humans. This has allowed for the determination of digestible indispensable amino acid scores (DIAAS) for a range of foods. A new non-invasive true ileal amino acid digestibility assay in humans which can be applied in different physiological states, called the dual-isotope assay, has been developed and applied to determine the DIAAS values of foods. It is concluded that DIAAS is currently the most accurate score for routinely assessing the protein quality rating of single source proteins. In the future, the accuracy of DIAAS can be enhanced by improved information on: the ideal dietary amino acid balance including the ideal dispensable to indispensable amino acid ratio; dietary indispensable amino acid requirements; effects of processing on ileal amino acid digestibility and lysine bioavailability. There is a need to develop rapid, inexpensive in vitro digestibility assays. Conceptual issues relating DIAAS to food regulatory claims, and to holistic indices of food nutritional and health status are discussed. The first recommendation of the 2011 Consultation regarding treating each indispensable amino acid as an individual nutrient has received little attention. Consideration should be given to providing food label information on the digestible contents of specific indispensable amino acids.

Evaluation of protein quality of wheat-rye flour blends by use of two small-scale analytical methods

Evaluation of protein quality of wheat-rye flour blends by use of two small-scale analytical methods

Simulated Digestion of Red Sea Cucumber (Parastichopus tremulus): A Study of Protein Quality and Antioxidant Activity

Sea cucumbers from unharvested areas, are underutilized resources which may have the potential to become a future food resource. The aim of this study was to evaluate protein quality and investigate the changes in antioxidant activity from frozen and freeze-dried red sea cucumber (Parastichopus tremulus) subjected to digestion, using an in vitro digestion model. P. tremulus constituted high moisture content (90%), comparable protein (4%) and ash (4%) content, and low lipid (1%) content. The biochemical components in freeze-dried samples were largely retained during the freeze-drying process. Frozen samples showed significantly higher (p < 0.05) antioxidant activity compared to freeze-dried samples (calculated on a dry weight basis). The quantity of essential amino acids was high (31%) and corresponds to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations reference protein. Frozen samples showed an increase in antioxidant activity during digestion measured by three different antioxidant assays. Freeze-dried samples only showed an increase in one of the antioxidant assays. Correlations (p < 0.05) were found between specific free amino acids and antioxidant activity. The amount of free amino acids exceeded the threshold to taste bitter, umami, sour, and sweet flavors. This study showed that P. tremulus constitutes good protein quality, performed antioxidant activity, and has the potential to be used as a flavor-enhancing ingredient.

Current advances for in vitro protein digestibility.

Protein is an essential macronutrient in our diet, source of nitrogen and essential amino acids, but the biological utilization of dietary protein depends on its digestibility and the absorption of amino acids and peptides in the gastrointestinal tract. The methods to define the amount and the quality of protein to meet human nutritional needs, such as the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS), require the use of animal models or human studies. These in vivo methods are the reference in protein quality evaluation, but they are expensive and long-lasting procedures with significant ethical restrictions. Therefore, the development of rapid, reproducible and in vitro digestion methods validated with in vivo data is an old demand. This review describes the challenges of the in vitro digestion methods in the evaluation of the protein nutritional quality. In addition to the technical difficulties to simulate the complex and adaptable processes of digestion and absorption, these methods are affected by similar limitations as the in vivo procedures, i.e., analytical techniques to accurately determine bioavailable amino acids and the contribution of the endogenous nitrogen. The in vitro methods used for the evaluation of protein digestibility, with special attention on those showing comparative data, are revised, emphasizing their pros and cons. The internationally harmonized digestion protocol proposed by the INFOGEST network is being adapted to evaluate protein and amino acid digestibility. The inter-laboratory reproducibility of this protocol was demonstrated for dairy products. The in vivo/in vitro comparability results obtained to date with this protocol for several plant and animal sources are promising, but it requires an extensive validation with a wider range of foods and substrates with known in vivo digestibility. These in vitro methods will probably not be applicable to all foods, and therefore, it is important to identify their limitations, not to elude their use, but to apply them within the limits, by using the appropriate standards and references, and always as a complementary tool to in vivo tests to reduce their number.

A Short Dietary Assessment Instrument to Evaluate Protein Quality and the Diversity of Protein Sources in Malaysian Diets.

The diversity of protein food sources, animal and plant, may be a proxy measure of protein quality and adequate protein nutrition. A population-based sample of 1604 Malaysians aged ≥18 y completed one 24-h dietary recall and a new 29-item protein diversity indicator (PDI). Socio-demographic data were obtained by self-report. Mean total protein intakes were 75.2 g/d from 24-h recalls and 74.9 g/d from PDI. Protein diversity indicator-estimated protein intakes were 36.2% from meat and poultry, 8.8% from fish, 16.0% from eggs and dairy, and 39.0% from plants. Intakes of animal proteins varied with socioeconomic status and ethnicity and were associated with higher protein quality, defined as the adequacy of essential amino acids (EAAs) relative to protein requirements. Protein intakes and protein quality in Malaysia were generally adequate. Protein diversity indicator metrics can complement current methods of dietary assessment and may be useful for monitoring protein diversity and quality in other countries currently undergoing nutrition transition.

Context and Perspectives for Establishing a Novel Database for Protein Quality of Human Foods, as Proposed by a Joint Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations/International Atomic Energy Agency Expert Technical Meeting in October 2022

United Nations agencies have a long history of leading work on establishing global human nutrient requirements. Dietary protein contributes to metabolism and homeostasis and plays an essential role in human health for growth, maintenance, reproduction, and immune function (or immunity). Accurately defining the quantity and quality of protein provided by foods and diets required to meet human nutritional needs is essential to achieving global environmental and nutrition goals. There have been many scientific developments related to protein quality over the past decades, with the preferred method being the scoring approach that relates the capacity of protein sources to provide an adequate amount and proportion of nitrogen and indispensable amino acids (IAAs) in a bioavailable form (often referred to as digestibility). Questions surrounding the scoring approach and IAA metabolic availability have been discussed during past and recent expert consultations. Recently, an Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations/International Atomic Energy Agency technical meeting, held in Vienna, 10–13 October, 2022, reviewed and updated evidence and related methods on protein requirements and protein quality assessment and designed a framework for the development of a Protein Digestibility Database to aid dialog on the evaluation of protein quality and protein sufficiency in different populations. The database should be a living document and align with national food compositional databases.

Compositional and nutritional evaluation of viscera from commercially harvested wild-caught Australian abalones (Haliotis spp.)

Discarded abalone viscera accounts for 25–42 % weight of total abalone waste and represents a cost-burden to producers. Previous research has identified these discarded abalone viscera as having the potential for pharmaceutical, nutraceutical and therapeutical outcomes, which have not been investigated in Australian varieties. Thus, comprehensive nutritional evaluation was conducted on the viscera of four commercially harvested wild-caught abalone in Australia; roe's abalone (Haliotis roei), greenlip abalone (Haliotis laevigata), brownlip abalone (Haliotis rubra conicopora), and blacklip abalone (Haliotis rubra rubra) collected from various locations and processors. Proximate composition, amino acid, fatty acid and protein and fat algorithmic quality evaluation were investigated. Protein and fat quality evaluation demonstrated the opportunity for utilizing abalone viscera to potentially improve the health status of aging populations, as well as exercise performance. Such evaluations included high essential amino acid index (EAAI) (81–85), predicted biological value (p-BV) (77–81) and predicted protein efficiency ratio (p-PER) (2.44–2.48). Samples were shown to have a unique docosapentaenoic acid (DPA) and arachidonic acid (ARA)-dominated polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) profile leading to a favorable index of atherogenicity (IA), index of thrombogenicity (IT), health-promoting index (HPI), and hypocholesterolemic/hypercholesterolemic (HH) values (0.95–1.36, 0.42–0.76, 0.74–1.05, 1.02–1.56). Challenges to valorisation in maintaining product consistency were identified with the noted variation in proximate composition (moisture: 72.96–79.97 %, protein: 55.82–68.04 % carbohydrates: 9.96–28.82 %, ash: 10.02–16.75 %, fat: 3.12–13.37 %). Multi-categorical regression identified external factors predominantly determine compositional results. The exception was amino acids characterization which remained consistent within and between species. This study provided an arching overview of the opportunities and challenges in utilizing abalone processing waste, as well as identifying future research directions in commercialization of viscera products. Such directions may include simultaneous hydrolytic recovery of macronutrients.

An Overview of Importance and Nutritional Evaluation of Food Protein Quality

An Overview of Importance and Nutritional Evaluation of Food Protein Quality

Protein Quality and Biochemical Evaluation of Unripe Banana Based Complementary Food Fortified with Crab Meat in Rats

Protein Quality and Biochemical Evaluation of Unripe Banana Based Complementary Food Fortified with Crab Meat in Rats

Perspective: Developing a Nutrient-Based Framework for Protein Quality

The future of precision nutrition requires treating amino acids as essential nutrients. Currently, recognition of essential amino acid requirements is embedded within a generalized measure of protein quality known as the PDCAAS (Protein Digestibility-Corrected Amino Acid Score). Calculating the PDCAAS includes the FAO/WHO/UNU amino acid score, which is based on the limiting amino acid in a food, that is, the single amino acid with the lowest concentration compared to the reference standard. That “limiting” amino acid score is then multiplied by a bioavailability factor to obtain the PDCAAS, which ranks proteins from 0.0 (poor quality) to 1.0 (high quality). However, the PDCAAS has multiple limitations: it only allows for direct protein quality comparison between 2 proteins, and it is not scalable, transparent, or additive. We therefore propose that shifting the protein quality evaluation paradigm from the current generalized perspective to a precision nutrition focus treating amino acids as unique, metabolically active nutrients will be valuable for multiple areas of science and public health. We report the development and validation of the Essential Amino Acid 9 (EAA-9) score, an innovative, nutrient-based protein quality scoring framework. EAA-9 scores can be used to ensure that dietary recommendations for each essential amino acid are met. The EAA-9 scoring framework also offers the advantages of being additive and, perhaps most importantly, allows for personalization of essential amino acid needs based on age or metabolic conditions. Comparisons of the EAA-9 score with PDCAAS demonstrated the validity of the EAA-9 framework, and practical applications demonstrated that the EAA-9 framework is a powerful tool for precision nutrition applications.

Solid-state Fermentation of Cottonseed Meal with Saccharomyces cerevisiae for Gossypol Reduction and Nutrient Enrichment

Background: An experiment was conducted to study the effect of solid-state fermentation (SSF) of cottonseed meal (CSM) with Saccharomyces cerevisiae on anti-nutritional factors and amino acid profile. Methods: A finely ground CSM was fermented with baker’s yeast for 48 h at room temperature with periodic observations of pH, temperature and moisture. The fermented substrate was partially sun-dried and nutritional values were observed. Result: After the SSF process on dry basses, the protein content of CSM increased from 8.74% to 12.67%. Besides increasing the nutritional value, the SSF showed a clear significant effect in reducing the anti-nutritional factors content of raw CSM like total gossypol from 0.28% to 0.21%, phytic acid from 3.3% to 0.3% and total tannin from 1.42% to 0.68%. CSM fermented with S. cerevisiae improved concertations of essential amino acids viz., histidine, isoleucine, valine, methionine and phenylalanine. The protein quality evaluation showed a significant increase in its nutritional value. Based on the present result, it can be concluded that the fermentation of CSM with S. cerevisiae decreases the anti-nutritional factors and improves essential nutrients.

Coupling the benefits of grassland crops and green biorefining to produce protein, materials and services for the green transition

AbstractCompared with annual grain and seed crops, perennial grassland has significantly lower losses of nutrients and low pesticide requirements, whilst also supporting soil carbon build‐up. Until now grassland crops have almost exclusively been fed to ruminants and horses. Our experiments on biorefining forages have produced protein of a quality equal to soybean meal. Forage crops can deliver high yields of biomass as well as protein with a well‐balanced amino acid profile. In grass crops from unfertilised permanent grassland, focus has to be on the fibre part of the grass due to a low protein yield. With current techniques we have recovered up to 40% of the forage protein into a protein concentrate with around 50% protein. In addition, a fibre fraction containing 15%–18% protein of dry matter can be produced and used as ruminant feed, bioenergy, or further biorefined into chemical building blocks or bio‐materials. Our feeding experiments have shown that biorefined grassland protein can provide a substitute for soybean meal for poultry and pigs without negative effects on animal performance. The first industrial scale biorefineries on green biomass for feed and bioenergy are now established in Denmark, although more research is needed in order to evaluate protein quality for both feed and food applications. In addition, a full EFSA approval has to be obtained for the application for food. The green biorefinery concept opens new markets for grassland and opportunities for increasing the grassland area to obtain associated ecosystem services.

An Evaluation of the Protein Requirements of Japanese Young Men by Consuming Two Types of Dairy Proteins Using the Indicator Amino Acid Oxidation Method.

The indicator amino acid oxidation method is a relatively new method for determining protein requirements. Our hypothesis was that the protein requirement of the casein-whey protein mixture (70% casein and 30% whey protein) was lower than the protein requirement of plain casein, because casein and whey proteins compensate for the lack of the first-limiting amino acids. The optimal mixing ratio was determined based on the amino acid scoring pattern which is used to calculate the digestible indispensable amino acid score. In this study, digestibility was not considered to determine the optimal mixing ratio because dairy protein is a good source of digestible protein. This study aimed to evaluate the protein requirements of Japanese young men by consuming casein and casein-whey protein mixture. Ten healthy young men (22±0.2 y old) participated in 12 experiments according to a graded protein intake (0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 1.0, 1.2, 1.4 g/kg/d) of casein and casein-whey protein mixture. The mean protein requirement was calculated as the breakpoint of breath 13CO2 enrichment using change-point regression models. The mean protein requirements of Japanese young men by consuming casein and casein-whey protein mixture were estimated to be 1.00 g/kg/d and 0.90 g/kg/d, respectively. These estimated requirements were consistent with the protein quality expected from the amount of the first-limiting amino acids. The indicator amino acid oxidation method may be useful to evaluate protein quality.

PSXI-8 Evaluation of Nutrient Composition and Protein Quality Using the Precision fed Cecectomized Rooster Assay of Novel Avian Protein Sources for pet Nutrition

Abstract Alternative protein sources are being incorporated in companion animal diets as a response to the market demand for high quality products. Chicken is a commonly used protein in pet food and was used as a comparison for emerging alternatives goose, quail, duck, and emu which have been evaluated in the current study. All protein sources were analyzed for chemical composition, and amino acid (AA) standardized digestibility and calculation of digestible indispensable amino acid scores (DIAAS-like) were determined by using the precision fed cecectomized rooster assay. Dry matter values ranged from 95% to 98% and were similar for all proteins. Crude protein was least for goose meat and greatest in emu meat (42% and 95%, respectively). Emu meat produced the least fat content while quail produced the most (4.7% and 42%, respectively). Standardized AA digestibility values for the novel proteins were above 60% for indispensable AA. The DIAAS-like calculation applied reference proteins based on Association of American Feed Control officials (AAFCO) recommended nutrient profile and National Research Council (NRC) recommended allowances for adult dogs and cats at maintenance. The DIAAS-like values for cats for AAFCO and NRC were >100%. Tryptophan was identified to be the first-limiting AA in every protein source except for goose meat where methionine was first-limiting using NRC recommended values for adult dogs.

PSXI-10 Macronutrient and Protein Quality Evaluation of Novel Mammalian Proteins for Canine and Feline Nutrition

Abstract The use of novel protein sources has become a popular human food trend and with the continued humanization of pets, these trends have been followed in the petfood industry. There is limited data regarding the macronutrient composition and overall quality of novel mammalian proteins. In this study, beef, yak, camel, kangaroo, and wild boar were analyzed for chemical composition, amino acid (AA) digestibility, and calculation of digestible indispensable amino acid scores (DIAAS-like) by application of the precision fed cecectomized rooster assay. Dry matter values were >90% and crude protein was greatest in yak meat (95%). Yak meat also contained the least amount of total fat at 11% whereas the greatest amount was found in beef at 57%. The standardized AA digestibility values were determined to be highly digestible as all values were >81%. The reference proteins used for DIAAS-like calculations were based on the Association of American Feed Control officials (AAFCO) nutrient profile and National Research Council (NRC) recommended allowances for adult dogs and cats at maintenance. The DIAAS-like values were >100% for yak and camel meat and were determined to be high quality for dogs. In cats, all proteins received DIAAS-like scores >100% except for wild boar. Tryptophan and methionine were most often the first-limiting acids for both dogs and cats.

The Use of Post-Natal Skeleton Development as Sensitive Preclinical Model to Test the Quality of Alternative Protein Sources in the Diet.

Dietary protein is necessary throughout all life stages. Adequate intake of protein during juvenile years is essential to enable appropriate synthesis of bone matrix and achieve the full peak bone mass (PBM). Due to socio-demographic changes, accompanied by environmental damage and ethical problems, a transition to the consumption of different and alternative protein sources in the human diet must occur. This transition requires the precise evaluation of protein quality. Here, we utilize a preclinical model of young rats during their post-natal developmental period to define the nutritive quality of a number of alternative protein sources (soy, spirulina, chickpea, and fly larvae) by their health impact on growth performance and skeletal development. We indicate that when restricted (10% of calories) not one of the tested alternative protein sources have succeeded in causing optimal growth, as compared to the referenced source, casein; yet fly larvae protein followed by chickpea flour were found to be superior to the rest. Growth-plate histology and µ-CT analyses demonstrated a number of changes in growth patterns and bone morphometric parameters. Bone mechanical testing, by three-point bending analyses, was sensitive in demonstrating the effect of the reduction in the amount of the dietary protein. Moreover, the rats’ weight and length, as well as their eating patterns, were found to reflect the proteins’ quality better than their amino acid composition. Hence, our study emphasizes the importance of evaluating protein as a whole food source, and suggests a new approach for this purpose.