In this paper, to better evaluate the flight performance of pilot cadets, a flight performance evaluation index system was constructed based on the task of the traffic pattern, the flight training manual, and interviews with instructors. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model established by the G1 method was used to evaluate the flight performance of pilot cadets. The flight data of 30 flight cadets were collected to verify the applicability of the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model. The results showed that the index system established in this paper can meet the requirements of flight performance evaluation. In addition, the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation results were consistent with the evaluation results of experts. Therefore, the system is effective and feasible for the evaluation of pilot cadets’ flight performance through the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model established by the index system and G1 method.