The potential role of psychosocial factors in cancer survival has fascinated clinicians and researchers for several decades. Unfortunately it is an area that has generated a limited number of quality empirical investigations and inconclusive reviews [1–4]. In this issue of the European Journal of Cancer a substantial piece of epidemiological work from this field is presented. The study is a simple 10 year follow-up of a 578 women diagnosed with early breast cancer (stage I and II) aged 18–75 years consecutively recruited from a single centre. At baseline, information was collected on mental adjustment to cancer, anxiety and depression, in addition to standard biological determinants of survival. The study presents new data showing that a high helplessness/hopelessness (HH) response reported at diagnosis was associated with decreased likelihood of disease free survival. At baseline, 91 (16%) of the patients had high HH and 49 (53.8%) of these had a recurrence or died by 10 years compared with 39.9% of those with low HH. The adjusted hazards ratio (HR) for disease free survival at 10 years is 1.53 [1.11–2.11], P = 0.009. This is a sizable effect, although only about one sixth of the women in this sample had low HH at baseline. Through application of criteria for meaningfulness based on statistical significance, the authors dismiss a finding which may well be the most interesting outcome of their endeavours [5]. A baseline depression score of >11 on the Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale (i.e., high probability of psychological morbidity) was associated with a HR for death between 0.97 and 6.10 (i.e., 95% CI), while the point estimate was 2.43 and the P-value was greater than 0.05. This finding may indeed be the most important. The wide and probably
Read full abstract