The commutation principle of Ramírez et al. (SIAM J Optim 23:687–694, 2013) proved in the setting of Euclidean Jordan algebras says that when the sum of a real valued function h and a spectral function $$\Phi $$ is minimized/maximized over a spectral set E, any local optimizer a at which h is Fréchet differentiable operator commutes with the derivative $$h^{\prime }(a)$$ . In this note, we describe some analogs of the above result by assuming the existence of a subgradient in place of the derivative (of h) and obtaining strong operator commutativity relations. We show, for example: if a solves the problem $$\underset{E}{\max }\,(h+\Phi )$$ , then a strongly operator commutes with every element in the subdifferential of h at a; If E and h are convex and a solves the problem $$\underset{E}{\min }\,h$$ , then a strongly operator commutes with the negative of some element in the subdifferential of h at a. These results improve known operator commutativity relations for linear h and for solutions of variational inequality problems. We establish these results via a geometric commutation principle that is valid not only in Euclidean Jordan algebras, but also in a broader setting.
Read full abstract