Ethylene-inducible Genes Research Articles

Profiling gibberellin (GA 3)-responsive genes in mature mandarin fruit using a citrus 22K oligoarray

Gibberellin 3 (GA 3)-responsive genes were investigated with a citrus 22K oligoarray 1 1 The information regarding citrus 22K oligoarray is available at the website http://www.fruit.affrc.go.jp/cgat/. to further the understanding of transcriptional regulation by GA 3 treatment in Satsuma mandarin fruit ( Citrus unshiu Marc.). 213 GA 3-responsive genes were identified that showed a 3-fold or greater expression change after 72 h GA 3 treatment, compared to expression after 72 h air treatment. GA 3 treatment induced expression of pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins and genes that function in photosynthesis, chloroplast biogenesis, resistance, defense and stress. Also, GA 3 treatment reduced the transcription of several ethylene-inducible genes, such as carotenoid metabolic genes, which are associated with fruit ripening. Contrasting effects between GA 3 and ethylene were observed on photosynthesis and chloroplast biogenesis, chlorophyll metabolism, and carotenoid metabolism, indicating that the endogenous GA 3 level might be important for the endogenous regulation of maturation and senescence in mature citrus fruit. It was also found that the GA response pathway was likely to take part in cross-talk with the pathogen-related pathway in mature citrus fruit.

EIN3‐like gene expression during fruit ripening of Cavendish banana (Musa acuminata cv. Grande naine)

Ethylene signal transduction initiates with ethylene binding at receptor proteins and terminates in a transcription cascade involving the EIN3/EIL transcription factors. Here, we have isolated four cDNAs homologs of the Arabidopsis EIN3/EIN3-like gene, MA-EILs (Musa acuminata ethylene insensitive 3-like) from banana fruit. Sequence comparison with other banana EIL gene already registered in the database led us to conclude that, at this day, at least five different genes namely MA-EIL1, MA-EIL2/AB266318, MA-EIL3/AB266319, MA-EIL4/AB266320 and AB266321 exist in banana. Phylogenetic analyses included all banana EIL genes within a same cluster consisting of rice OsEILs, a monocotyledonous plant as banana. However, MA-EIL1, MA-EIL2/AB266318, MA-EIL4/AB266320 and AB266321 on one side, and MA-EIL3/AB266319 on the other side, belong to two distant subclusters. MA-EIL mRNAs were detected in all examined banana tissues but at lower level in peel than in pulp. According to tissues, MA-EIL genes were differentially regulated by ripening and ethylene in mature green fruit and wounding in old and young leaves. MA-EIL2/AB266318 was the unique ripening- and ethylene-induced gene; MA-EIL1, MA-EIL4/Ab266320 and AB266321 genes were downregulated, while MA-EIL3/AB266319 presented an unusual pattern of expression. Interestingly, a marked change was observed mainly in MA-EIL1 and MA-EIL3/Ab266319 mRNA accumulation concomitantly with changes in ethylene responsiveness of fruit. Upon wounding, the main effect was observed in MA-EIL4/AB266320 and AB266321 mRNA levels, which presented a markedly increase in both young and old leaves, respectively. Data presented in this study suggest the importance of a transcriptionally step control in the regulation of EIL genes during banana fruit ripening.

Ethylene-sensitive and insensitive regulation of transcription factor expression during in vitro tomato sepal ripening

Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum, formerly Lycopersicon esculentum) cv. VFNT Cherry sepals, when cultured in vitro between 16 degrees C and 22 degrees C, change their genetic programme to that of ripening fruit. Previously regulation of a number of transcription factors and a putative G-protein-coupled receptor that may be involved in tomato fruit ripening and cool-temperature sepal morphogenesis had been revealed. Many of those genes such as TAG1, TM4, TM6, AP2-like (LeAP2FR), YABBY2-like (LeYAB2), and LeCOR413-PM1 have not been investigated for ethylene regulation. Ethylene-independent, regulated transcripts may be part of an early signalling process induced or de-repressed by cool temperature that causes a switch in the genetic programme of the sepals. In this paper, ethylene regulation of a number of these and other putative signalling factors are investigated during cool-temperature-induced sepal morphogenesis. 1-Methylcyclopropene was used to block ethylene-induced gene expression by interrupting the ethylene signal transduction pathway that occurs in ripening tomato fruits and presumably in ripening sepals. Transcripts of several putative transcription factors previously shown to be up-regulated during cool-temperature-induced sepal morphogenesis (TAG1, TM4, LeAP2FR) were only slightly or not induced in 1-methylcyclopropene-treated sepals, indicating either direct or indirect ethylene regulation. Two genes, VAHOX1, a homeobox domain leucine-zipper-encoding gene, and LeYAB2, a putative zinc-finger transcription factor-encoding gene, increased in treated and untreated sepals indicating regulation by cool temperatures independently of ethylene.

Mutational loss of the prohibitin AtPHB3 results in an extreme constitutive ethylene response phenotype coupled with partial loss of ethylene-inducible gene expression in Arabidopsis seedlings

The eer3-1 loss-of-function mutant, which was identified by screening for Arabidopsis mutant seedlings with an enhanced ethylene response, has both increased sensitivity and profound exaggeration of response to ethylene when visually assessed, yet exhibits partial ethylene insensitivity at the molecular level. The eer3-1 mutation represents a conditional allele with an ethylene-dependent phenotype that results from an amino acid substitution in the previously uncharacterized prohibitin, AtPHB3, with complete loss of EER3 function resulting in an extreme constitutive ethylene response in air. Prohibitins in other organisms have diverse roles including transcriptional regulation, with loss of prohibitin function in this capacity associated with tumour formation in mammals. Subcellular localization of AtPHB3 indicates that it is found in several cellular locations, including the nucleus and throughout the cytoplasm. Genetic analysis demonstrates that EER3 functions downstream of EIN2, since an ein2-5;eer3-2 double mutant has the same profound hypocotyl inhibition phenotype seen with the eer3-2 mutant. Based on the presented work, AtPHB3 probably functions as a positive regulator of expression of a subset of ethylene-regulated genes along with a group of genes required to maintain growth in the presence of ethylene.

Possible role of light in the maintenance of EIN3/EIL1 stability in Arabidopsis seedlings

To examine the mechanism of EIN3-mediated gene expression by ethylene, the expression patterns of ethylene-inducible genes by ethylene were monitored in Col-0 and ethylene signaling mutants. In Col-0, the inducibility of ACC oxidase by ethylene in light-grown seedlings was much higher than in dark-grown seedlings. While the expression of ACC oxidase was highly increased by ethylene not only in Col-0 but in ein3-1 under light treatment, this pattern was completely abrogated in etiolated ein3-1 seedlings, suggesting the expression of EIN3-mediated ACC oxidase genes could be affected by light. To check if the level of EIN3 and EIL1 was regulated by light, cell-free degradation assays were performed. This resulted in the rapid degradation of these proteins within 1 h after adding dark-grown cell extracts and this degradation was retarded by light-grown extracts. Here, we propose that light may act as a negative regulator in the destabilization of EIN3/EIL1.

Molecular changes occurring during acquisition of abscission competence following auxin depletion in Mirabilis jalapa.

To understand how auxin regulates sensitivity of abscission zone (AZ) tissues to ethylene, we used a polymerase chain reaction-based subtractive approach to identify gene transcripts in Mirabilis jalapa AZs that changed in abundance during the time the zones became competent to abscise in response to exogenous ethylene. Transcript expression was then examined in leaf and stem AZs over the period they became ethylene competent following indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) depletion either by leaf deblading, treatment with the IAA transport inhibitor naphthylphthalamic acid, or cutting the stem above a node (decapitation). Transcripts down-regulated by deblading/decapitation included Mj-Aux/IAA1 and Mj-Aux/IAA2, encoding Aux/IAA proteins, and three other transcripts showing highest identity to a polygalacturonase inhibitor protein, a beta-expansin, and a beta-tubulin. Application of IAA to the cut end of petioles or stumps inhibited abscission, and prevented the decline in the levels of transcripts in both AZs. Transcripts up-regulated in the AZ following deblading/decapitation or treatment with naphthylphthalamic acid were isolated from plants pretreated with 1-methylcyclopropene before deblading to help select against ethylene-induced genes. Some of the up-regulated transcripts showed identity to proteins associated with ethylene or stress responses, while others did not show homology to known sequences. Sucrose infiltration of stem stumps enhanced abscission following ethylene treatment and also enhanced the induction of some of the up-regulated genes. Our results demonstrate a correlation between acquisition of competence to respond to ethylene in both leaf and stem AZs, and decline in abundance of auxin regulatory gene transcripts.

Overexpression ofGbERF confers alteration of ethylene-responsive gene expression and enhanced resistance toPseudomonas syringae in transgenic tobacco

GbERF belongs to the ERF (ethylene responsive factor) family of transcription factors and regulates the GCC-box containing pathogen-related (PR) genes in the ethylene signal transduction pathway. To study the function of GbERF in the process of biotic stress, transgenic tobacco plants expressing GbERF were generated. Overexpression of GbERF did not change transgenic plant's phenotype and endogenous ethylene level. However, the expression profile of some ethylene-inducible GCC-box and non-GCC-box containing genes was altered, such as PR1b, PR2, PR3, PR4, Osmotin, CHN50, ACC oxidase and ACC synthase genes. These data indicate that the cotton GbERF could act as a transcriptional activator or repressor to regulate the differential expression of ethylene-inducible genes via GCC and non-GCC cis-elements. Moreover, the constitutive expression of GbERF in transgenic tobacco enhanced the plant's resistance to Pseudomonas syringae pv tabaci infection. In conclusion, GbERF mediates the expression of a wide array of PR and ethylene-responsive genes and plays an important role in the plant's response to biotic stress.

Involvement of Ethylene in Stress-Induced Expression of the TLC1.1 Retrotransposon from Lycopersicon chilense Dun.

The TLC1 family is one of the four families of long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons identified in the genome of Lycopersicon chilense. Here, we show that this family of retroelements is transcriptionally active and its expression is induced in response to diverse stress conditions such as wounding, protoplast preparation, and high salt concentrations. Several stress-associated signaling molecules, including ethylene, methyl jasmonate, salicylic acid, and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, are capable of inducing TLC1 family expression in vivo. A representative of this family, named TLC1.1, was isolated from a genomic library from L. chilense. Transient expression assays in leaf protoplasts and stably transformed tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) plants demonstrate that the U3 domain of the 5'-LTR region of this element can drive stress-induced transcriptional activation of the beta-glucuronidase reporter gene. Two 57-bp tandem repeated sequences are found in this region, including an 8-bp motif, ATTTCAAA, previously identified as an ethylene-responsive element box in the promoter region of ethylene-induced genes. Expression analysis of wild-type LTR and single and double ethylene-responsive element box mutants fused to the beta-glucuronidase gene shows that these elements are required for ethylene-responsive gene expression in protoplasts and transgenic plants. We suggest that ethylene-dependent signaling is the main signaling pathway involved in the regulation of the expression of the TLC1.1 element from L. chilense.

Ethylene-induced gene expression, enzyme activities, and water soaking in immature and ripe watermelon ( Citrullus lanatus) fruit

Watermelon fruit exhibit acute softening and placental-tissue water soaking following short exposure to exogenous ethylene. Experiments were performed to address transcript abundance and activities of cell wall and membrane hydrolases in placental tissue in response to treatment of watermelon fruit with ethylene. Watermelon fruit were harvested at immature and full-ripe stages and exposed to 50 microL L(-1) ethylene for 6 days at 20 degrees C. Ethylene affected the abundance of transcripts for PME (EC 3.2.1.11), and alpha-(EC 3.2.1.22) and beta-GAL (EC 3.2.1.23) but these effects were dependent on fruit maturity and appeared not to be associated with the water-soaking syndrome. PG (EC 3.2.1.15) and EXP mRNAs accumulated significantly in response to ethylene exposure. Additionally, the levels of mRNA and activities of LOX (EC 1.13.11.12), PLC (EC 3.1.4.3) and PLD (EC 3.1.4.4) were elevated in fruit of both maturity classes exposed to ethylene and were temporally associated with the visible symptoms of water soaking. The activity trends and transcript abundance in ethylene- compared with air-treated fruit indicate that PG, EXP, LOX, PLC and PLD levels increase with the onset and development of the water-soaking disorder and support the view that catabolic reactions targeting the membranes and cell-walls contribute to the disorder.

The novel rice (Oryza sativa L.) gene OsSbf1 encodes a putative member of the Na+/bile acid symporter family.

PCR-based differential screening was used to identify ethylene-induced genes in deep-water rice (Oryza sativa L.). One of the isolated cDNAs represented a novel protein, OsSBF1, with high homology to mammalian Na+/bile acid transporters and to sodium-dependent transporters from bacteria. One highly homologous protein and three less conserved homologues were identified in Arabidopsis thaliana indicating that Sbf proteins exist in monocot and dicot plant species. Expression of OsSbf1 in deep-water rice was shown to be elevated by growth-inducing treatments. Since bile acids have not been found in plants to date a possible function of SBF proteins may be in the transport of structurally related sulphonated brassinosteroids.

Regulation of ethylene-induced transcription of defense genes.

Ethylene-induced gene expression has been studied in systems in which the biosynthesis of ethylene is stimulated during developmental process such as ripening of fruit, senescence of flower petals, or during pathogen infection. Functional analysis of the promoters of these genes revealed that the ethylene-responsive cis-elements of fruit ripening genes and senescence genes differed from that of defense genes whose expression is induced by ethylene in response to pathogen infection. The ethylene-responsive element identified as the GCC box (AGCCGCC) is commonly found in the promoter region of the ethylene-inducible defense genes. The ethylene responsive element binding factors that interact with the GCC box were demonstrated to be the transcription factors, which respond to extracellular signals to modulate GCC box-mediated gene expression positively or negatively.

Competitive Hybridization: Theory and Application in Isolation and Quantification of Differentially Regulated Genes

Competitive hybridization is a simple yet powerful method that was developed to screen cDNA libraries for differentially regulated genes. The method is based on competition between unlabeled cDNA from the mRNA of one sample and labeled cDNA from another sample. By manipulating the amount of competing unlabeled cDNA, background signals from the nonregulated genes can be increased or reduced, enabling the signals from differentially regulated genes to be contrasted and to be identified in a quantitative manner. To demonstrate the feasibility of the method, we screened a citrus cDNA library for ethylene-induced genes and identified three genes with different levels of ethylene induction. The mathematical basis of the method and its possible application in gene chip technology are discussed.

Rhizobacteria-mediated induced systemic resistance (ISR) in Arabidopsis is not associated with a direct effect on expression of known defense-related genes but stimulates the expression of the jasmonate-inducible gene Atvsp upon challenge.

Selected strains of nonpathogenic rhizobacteria from the genus Pseudomonas are capable of eliciting broad-spectrum induced systemic resistance (ISR) in plants that is phenotypically similar to pathogen-induced systemic acquired resistance (SAR). In Arabidopsis, the ISR pathway functions independently of salicylic acid (SA) but requires responsiveness to jasmonate and ethylene. Here, we demonstrate that known defense-related genes, i.e. the SA-responsive genes PR-1, PR-2, and PR-5, the ethylene-inducible gene Hel, the ethylene- and jasmonate-responsive genes ChiB and Pdf1.2, and the jasmonate-inducible genes Atvsp, Lox1, Lox2, Pall, and Pin2, are neither induced locally in the roots nor systemically in the leaves upon induction of ISR by Pseudomonas fluorescens WCS417r. In contrast, plants infected with the virulent leaf pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato (Pst) or expressing SAR induced by preinfecting lower leaves with the avirulent pathogen Pst(avrRpt2) exhibit elevated expression levels of most of the defense-related genes studied. Upon challenge inoculation with Pst, PR gene transcripts accumulated to a higher level in SAR-expressing plants than in control-treated and ISR-expressing plants, indicating that SAR involves potentiation of SA-responsive PR gene expression. In contrast, pathogen challenge of ISR-expressing plants led to an enhanced level of Atvsp transcript accumulation. The otherjasmonate-responsive defense-related genes studied were not potentiated during ISR, indicating that ISR is associated with the potentiation of specific jasmonate-responsive genes.

A GCC element and a G-box motif participate in ethylene-induced expression of the PRB-1b gene.

The PRB-1b gene codes for a basic-type pathogenesis-related protein and is activated at the transcriptional level by the plant hormone ethylene. To identify cis-acting DNA elements essential for ethylene induction, deleted and mutant forms of the PRB-1b promoter, fused to the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) coding region, were introduced in transgenic tobacco plants. A 73 bp fragment (X1 region) of the PRB-1b promoter, located between positions -213 and -141, was sufficient to confer ethylene responsiveness to the reporter gene. The X1 region contains a TAAGAGCCGCC motif (GCC-box) well conserved in several ethylene-inducible genes. A substitution mutation in this sequence, in the context of a 213 bp PRB-1b promoter, completely abolished ethylene induction in transgenic tobacco, defining this conserved motif as part of a cis-acting element responsive to ethylene. Three other mutations in the X1 region caused a pronounced decrease in the PRB-1b promoter activity in transgenic plants, but did not affect ethylene inducibility. One of them, localized in a G-box like motif (CACGTG), disrupted the binding site for a nuclear factor, as observed in gel-shift analysis. Interestingly, the mobility of the complex formed on the G-box element was dependent on its phosphorylation state. These results suggest that a cis-acting element involved in the perception of the ethylene signal resides in a GCC motif and acts in concert with additional elements in the regulation of ethylene-induced PRB-1b expression.

The Tomato Never-ripe Locus Regulates Ethylene-Inducible Gene Expression and Is Linked to a Homolog of the Arabidopsis ETR1 Gene

Fruit ripening represents a complex system of genetic and hormonal regulation of eukaryotic development unique to plants. We are using tomato ripening mutants as tools to elucidate genetic components of ripening regulation and have recently demonstrated that the Never-ripe (Nr) mutant is insensitive to the plant growth regulator ethylene (M.B. Lanahan, H.-C. Yen, J.J. Giovannoni, H.J. Klee [1994] Plant Cell 6:521-530). We report here ethylene sensitivity over a range of concentrations in normal and Nr tomato seedlings and show that the Nr mutant retains residual sensitivity to as little as 1 part per million of ethylene. Analysis of ripening-related gene expression in normal and mutant ethylene-treated fruit demonstrates that Nr exerts its influence on development at least in part at the level of ethylene-inducible gene expression. We have additionally used cloned tomato and Arabidopsis sequences known to influence ethylene perception as restriction fragment length polymorphism probes, and have identified a tomato locus linked to Nr that hybridizes to the Arabidopsis ETR1 gene at low stringency, suggesting the possibility that Nr may be homologous to ETR1.

A modified procedure for PCR-based differential display and demonstration of use in plants for isolation of genes related to fruit ripening

We have modified and optimized PCR-based differential display for efficient identification and isolation of genes whose expression patterns are correlated with changes in growth, development, physiology, and/or environmental response. This protocol is general in nature and can be applied for analysis of virtually any plant tissues from which several μg of total RNA can be extracted. We report here the use of tomato fruit ripening as a model system in which to test and optimize differential display in plants. Specifically, mRNA from ripe, early breaker, mature green, and ethylene-treated mature green tomato fruit were examined to identify and distinguish non-ethylene-inducible from ethylene-inducible genes related to ripening. DNA-free total RNA was utilized as template for synthesis of first-strand complementary DNA using each of 12 possible 5′-T11 XY-3′ anchor primers (X=A, C, or G; Y=A, C, G, or T). PCR amplification products of the resulting cDNA populations were generated via use of random primers in combination with the corresponding anchor primer employed for cDNA synthesis. We demonstrate that degenerative anchor primers are useful for making representative cDNA populations, but are not effective for representative display-PCR. cDNA, resulting from degenerative anchor primer synthesis, yielded substantially fewer ripening-related display-PCR products when amplified with the same degenerative anchor primer employed in cDNA synthesis, versus the corresponding set of specific anchor primers. Amplification products specific to ripe fruit cDNA were isolated directly from display gels, reamplified, cloned, and confirmed for ripening-related gene expression via RNA gel-blot analysis.

A novel fruit-expressed trypsin inhibitor I gene from a wild species of tomato.

A member of the proteinase inhibitor I gene family encoding an inhibitor I protein with a novel trypsin-specific reactive site was isolated from the wild tomato species Lycopersicon peruvianum (L.) Mill. (LA107). The nucleotide sequence of the gene was identical to a previously isolated cDNA clone from L. peruvianum fruit (Wingate, V.P.M., Broadway, R. M., and Ryan, C. A. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 17734-17738) with the exception of one nucleotide 3 base pairs upstream from the 5' terminus of the cDNA. S1 nuclease protection experiments and RNA blot hybridization analysis show that the gene is developmentally regulated in L. peruvianum fruit and is not the same inhibitor I gene that is wound inducible in leaves. Nucleotide sequences are present in the 5'-flanking sequences of the fruit-specific L. peruvianum gene inhibitor I gene which share similarity with regulatory sequences that have been associated with the regulation of several known elicitor- and ethylene-inducible genes. However, the L. peruvianum motifs are not identical with those of other genes and are probably not functional. Because inhibitor I genes are not expressed or are expressed in very low levels in modern tomato fruit before the onset of ripening but expressed at high levels in fruit of the wild L. peruvianum species, a unique fruit-specific signaling system must therefore be present in L. peruvianum fruit for the transcriptional regulation of the inhibitor I gene which is not present in the fruit of the modern tomato, L. esculentum.

Regulation of Gene Expression by Ethylene in Wild-Type and rin Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) Fruit

Levels of ethylene biosynthesis and ethylene-inducible gene expression in wild-type tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) fruit and in nonripening fruit from the tomato mutant rin (ripening inhibitor) were compared in order to investigate the mechanism of ethylene action. Whereas wild-type tomato fruit dramatically increase the rate of ethylene biosynthesis at the onset of ripening, rin fruit constitutively produce ethylene at a low basal level. We have compared the mRNA levels and transcription rates of four cloned ethylene-inducible genes (JE Lincoln, S Cordes, E Read, RL Fischer 1987 Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 2793-2797) during wild-type and rin fruit development. In wild-type fruit, both mRNA levels and transcription rates of these genes increase. The effect of the rin mutation on gene expression is different for each ethylene-inducible gene. In one case expression is completely suppressed, while in other instances it is either partially inhibited or relatively unaffected by the mutation. The mRNA levels of each of these genes in response to exogenous ethylene in rin fruit was also measured. The mRNAs for all four genes accumulate to similar levels in both ethylene treated rin and ethylene treated wild-type fruit. These results are discussed with regard to the response of plants to ethylene hormone at the level of gene expression.

Ethylene-Induced Gene Expression in Carnation Petals

Exposure of carnation (Dianthus caryophyllus L.) flowers to ethylene evokes the developmental program of petal senescence. The temporal relationship of several aspects of this developmental program following treatment with ethylene was investigated. Exposure of mature, presenescent flowers to 7.5 microliters per liter ethylene for at least 6 hours induced petal in-rolling and premature senescence. Autocatalytic ethylene production was induced in petals following treatment with ethylene for 12 or more hours. A number of changes in mRNA populations were noted in response to ethylene, as determined by in vitro translation of petal polyadenylated RNA. At least 6 mRNAs accumulated following ethylene exposure. The molecular weights of their in vitro translation products were 81, 58, 42, 38, 35, and 25 kilodaltons. Significant increases in abundance of most mRNAs were observed 3 hours following ethylene exposure. Ethylene exposure resulted in decreased abundance of another group of mRNAs. Treatment of flowers with competitive inhibitors of ethylene action largely prevented the induction of these ethylene responses in petals. An increase in flower age was accompanied by an increase in the capacity for ethylene to induce petal in-rolling, autocatalytic ethylene production, and changes in mRNA populations suggesting that these responses are regulated by both sensitivity to ethylene and ethylene concentration. These results indicate that changes in petal physiology resulting from exposure to ethylene may be the result of rapid changes in gene expression.

Diverse mechanisms for the regulation of ethylene-inducible gene expression.

We have investigated the mechanism of action of the plant hormone ethylene by analyzing the expression of ethylene-inducible genes isolated from tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum). We have found that the expression of each cloned gene is regulated by ethylene in a unique manner. That is, for certain genes ethylene affects transcriptional processes, while for another gene it affects both transcriptional and post-transcriptional processes. Furthermore, induction of gene transcription by ethylene is organ specific for one gene, while for others it is not. In addition, we have measured gene expression as a function of ethylene concentration and have found that each gene displays a unique ethylene dose-response curve. Our results suggest that ethylene modulates gene expression by a variety of mechanisms.