Estuarine Food Webs Research Articles

Temporal variability in assimilation of basal food sources by an omnivorous fish at Patos Lagoon Estuary revealed by stable isotopes (2010–2014)

ABSTRACTEstuarine systems are characterized by complex physicochemical and hydrological changes occurring across multiple scales, which determine spatiotemporal variation in distribution and abundance of consumers and their resources. However, little is known about the effects of these biophysical interactions on the interannual dynamics of estuarine food webs. In this work, a five-year stable isotope data set was used to investigate interannual variability in trophic links between basal production sources (seagrass, macroalgae, saltmarsh, particulate organic matter in suspension and in the sediment) and an omnivorous fish (Jenynsia multidentata) in a subtropical estuary emptying in the Southwestern Atlantic. The isotopic variability (δ13C, δ15N) of basal sources and the consumer was analysed seasonally on a mudflat from 2010 to 2014. Jenynsia multidentata showed significant interannual variation in their trophic links with primary producers. In most seasons and years, the consumer relied heavily on benthic-associated food resources, but shifted to pelagic food resources during certain seasons. A ‘green tide’ caused by a massive bloom of vicariant macroalgae occurred on the mudflat, but our findings suggested that the carbon-derived portion of this basal production source was not assimilated by J. multidentata. Instead, seagrass was the most assimilated benthic basal food source in most seasons and years. These results suggest that the intensity of benthic and pelagic trophic pathways sustaining estuarine consumers are not static, but change in response to intra- and interannual variation in the availability of basal production sources. Our findings reinforce the need to account for interannual trends in availability of resources when modelling estuarine food web dynamics.

Modeling the Effects of a Power Plant Decommissioning on an Estuarine Food Web

While a number of studies have looked at the impingement and entrainment impacts of power generation facilities on recreationally and commercially important fish species, few have assessed the effects on forage species or the broader aquatic community. Here, we constructed a trophic-based ecosystem model for the Barnegat Bay, New Jersey estuary, which is home to the Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station. Utilizing this model, we developed two scenarios: a baseline scenario for 1981–2030 and a decommissioning scenario where the generating station substantially reduces its water withdrawals beginning in 2020. The effect on the biomass of an individual species tended to be small (<3 %), and the direction of the change varied by species. Trophic interactions played an important role in determining the overall change in a species’ biomass, as some species directly impacted by the generating station had a reduced biomass in the decommissioning scenario due to increased predation mortality. The differences in results between the static mixed trophic impact analysis and the dynamic simulation analysis highlight the value of dynamic modeling in assessing management strategies.

Metal Bioaccumulation by Estuarine Food Webs in New England, USA.

Evaluating the degree of metal exposure and bioaccumulation in estuarine organisms is important for understanding the fate of metals in estuarine food webs. We investigated the bioaccumulation of Hg, methylmercury (MeHg), Cd, Se, Pb, and As in common intertidal organisms across a watershed urbanization gradient of coastal marsh sites in New England to relate metal exposure and bioaccumulation in fauna to both chemical and ecological factors. In sediments, we measured metal and metalloid concentrations, total organic carbon (TOC) and SEM-AVS (Simultaneously extracted metal-acid volatile sulfides). In five different functional feeding groups of biota, we measured metal concentrations and delta 15N and delta 13C signatures. Concentrations of Hg and Se in biota for all sites were always greater than sediment concentrations whereas Pb in biota was always lower. There were positive relationships between biota Hg concentrations and sediment concentrations, and between biota MeHg concentrations and both pelagic feeding mode and trophic level. Bioavailability of all metals measured as SEM-AVS or Benthic-Sediment Accumulation Factor was lower in more contaminated sites, likely due to biogeochemical factors related to higher levels of sulfides and organic carbon in the sediments. Our study demonstrates that for most metals and metalloids, bioaccumulation is metal specific and not directly related to sediment concentrations or measures of bioavailability such as AVS-SEM.

Spatiotemporal patterns in the export of dissolved organic carbon and chromophoric dissolved organic matter from a coastal, blackwater river

We examined seasonal and spatial patterns in dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and chromophoric dissolved organic matter (CDOM) in the Chowan River watershed, North Carolina, a blackwater river which discharges into the second largest estuary in the United States, the Albemarle–Pamlico Estuarine System. From April 2008 to May 2010, DOC concentration did not significantly vary across seasons (range 7.69–30.39 mg L−1); however, CDOM molecular size and aromaticity increased throughout the spring, decreased during the summer and fall, and remained relatively low in the winter. Spectral slope ratios suggested microbial processing of CDOM in the spring and photodegradation of CDOM in the summer and fall. Spatially, DOC and CDOM concentrations were similar in the mainstem and at the mouths of two tributaries, Bennetts Creek and Wiccacon River, but were significantly higher upstream on the tributaries. DOC concentration was positively correlated with CDOM absorbance coefficients at 254 and 350 nm; however, these optical proxies explained only ~60 % of the variance. DOC and CDOM absorption loads to the Albemarle Sound ranged from 2.63 × 1010 g year−1 and 9.84 × 1010 m2 year−1, respectively, in a dry year and 7.9 × 1010 g year−1 and 2.2 × 1011 m2 year−1, respectively, in a wet year, which are comparable to non-blackwater rivers with larger watersheds. Blackwater rivers may therefore represent “hotspots” in coastal carbon chemistry, with seasonal variations in the quality and quantity of DOC and CDOM influencing estuarine food web dynamics and net ecosystem metabolism.

Nitrogen loads influence trophic organization of estuarine fish assemblages

Summary Nutrient (N and P) loading may affect functioning in aquatic ecosystems by restructuring producer assemblages with flow‐on effects to consumers. Trophic niche occupancy and trophic organization of consumers are key components of ecosystem function that have been increasingly investigated using quantitative isotopic niche indices. These indices are based on the premise that the isotopic values of consumer tissues indicate their assimilated diet. Typically, isotopic niche indices are calculated using only consumer isotope data, which limit their application for spatial and temporal comparisons because consumer isotopic niches depend on isotopic variability of available autotrophs. We used measures of isotopic variability of autotrophs to standardize isotopic niche indices, which enabled us to compare trophic organization of fish assemblages in nine estuaries spanning a broad range of nutrient loading. We related standardized isotopic niche indices of fish assemblages to nitrogen and phosphorous loads and hydrological flushing of the estuaries in autumn and spring. The estuarine fish assemblages studied here showed greater trophic diversity and less redundancy given moderate to high inorganic nitrogen loading. Taxonomic richness partly influenced three isotopic niche indices measuring trophic diversity, but not measures of redundancy. Similar patterns may occur in other systems in which nitrogen loads have increased but the diversity of primary producers has not been reduced to a single dominant source. Our results demonstrate bottom‐up controls of estuarine food webs. Effects of inorganic nitrogen loading were transmitted upwards through the food web to affect the trophic organization of higher trophic levels, demonstrating the crucial role of nitrogen for estuarine trophic dynamics.

Modeling Predator–Prey Linkages of Diadromous Fishes in an Estuarine Food Web

AbstractHistorically, multiple species of diadromous fishes served as a coastal food source for commercially valuable nearshore predators. However, severe declines in diadromous fish populations in the nearshore Gulf of Maine (GOM) have impacted trophic dynamics and increased pressure on other estuarine-dependent forage resources. The objective of this study was to compare the trophic positions and interspecific interactions of diadromous fishes as predators and prey in relation to current GOM forage fishes. Empirical biomass data along with diet compositions and vital rates were used to construct a static model of a representative GOM coastal food web: the Saco River estuary (SRE) in Maine. A series of sensitivity analyses based on model outputs was performed to determine the trophic role of diadromous fishes in this estuarine food web. Model results suggested that juvenile marine transients played a greater role as forage species for SRE predators than did the anadromous Blueback Herring Alosa aestivali...

Impacts of Silver Nanoparticles on a Natural Estuarine Plankton Community.

Potential effects of metal nanoparticles on aquatic organisms and food webs are hard to predict from the results of single-species tests under controlled laboratory conditions, and more realistic exposure experiments are rarely conducted. We tested whether silver nanoparticles (Ag NPs) had an impact on zooplankton grazing on their prey, specifically phytoplankton and bacterioplankton populations. If Ag NPs directly reduced the abundance of prey, thereby causing the overall rate of grazing by their predators to decrease, a cascading effect on a planktonic estuarine food web would be seen. Our results show that the growth rates of both phytoplankton and bacterioplankton populations were significantly reduced by Ag NPs at concentrations of ≥500 μg L(-1). At the same time, grazing rates on these populations tended to decline with exposure to Ag NPs. Therefore, Ag NPs did not cause a cascade of effects through the food web but impacted a specific trophic level. Photosynthetic efficiency of the phytoplankton was significantly reduced at Ag NPs concentrations of ≥500 μg L(-1). These effects did not occur at relatively low concentrations of Ag that are often toxic to single species of bacteria and other organisms, suggesting that the impacts of Ag NP exposure may not be apparent at environmentally relevant concentrations due to compensatory processes at the community level.

Evaluating trophic and non-trophic effects of shellfish aquaculture in a coastal estuarine foodweb

Evaluating trophic and non-trophic effects of shellfish aquaculture in a coastal estuarine foodweb

Terrestrial dissolved organic carbon subsidizes estuarine zooplankton: An in situ mesocosm study

Freshwater inflows play an important role in delivering dissolved organic carbon (DOC) to estuaries. Episodic inputs of DOC may support increased bacterial production. However, the role of DOC in supporting zooplankton production is widely debated. To evaluate this role we performed an in situ mesocosm experiment in the Bega River estuary, Australia. We added a DOC leachate derived from terrestrial vegetation to 400 L mesocosm bags as treatments of +1.5, +3, and +16 mg C L−1 and monitored changes in carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, bacteria, chlorophyll a (Chl a), and zooplankton over 22 d. Bacterial biomass peaked at day 2 and was highest in the +16 mg C L−1 treatment. Chl a was not significantly different between treatments. Mesozooplankton was dominated by copepodites of Gladioferens pectinatus and Sulcanus conflictus between days 5–9 and by adults between days 9–15. Significantly higher numbers of copepods were present in the +16 treatment followed by the +3 mg C L−1 treatment compared with the controls. Stable carbon isotope signatures of copepods in the +16 mg C L−1 treatment were significantly different from the control and showed leachate carbon supported between 29.3% and 55.8% of copepod biomass. These results suggest that the impact of allochthonous DOC loading events on estuarine zooplankton occurs over short periods, and that the magnitude of response is, in part, controlled by the quantity of bioavailable DOC loaded to the system. Our findings underscore the importance of microbial dynamics stimulated by DOC loading events from freshwater inflows as a trophic path in estuarine food webs.

The Aquatic Trophic Ecology of Suisun Marsh, San Francisco Estuary, California, During Autumn in a Wet Year

doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.15447/sfews.v13iss3art6 Using stable isotopes of carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) and mixing models, we investigated the trophic levels and carbon sources of invertebrates and fishes of a large tidal marsh in the San Francisco Estuary. Our goal was to better understand an estuarine food web comprised of native and alien species. We found the following: (1) the food web was based largely on carbon from phytoplankton and emergent-aquatic and terrestrial vegetation, but carbon from submerged aquatic vegetation and phytobenthos was also used; (2) alien species increased the complexity of the food web by altering carbon-flow pathways and by occupying trophic positions different from native species; and (3) most consumers were dietary generalists.

Life history traits influence in gonad composition of two sympatric species of flatfish

AbstractParalichthys orbignyanus and Paralichthys patagonicus are flatfish with different life history traits, having in common the condition of breeding in seawater. Paralichthys patagonicus remain their whole life in open seawater and Paralichthys orbignyanus are sometimes found in brackish water bodies. As marine and estuarine food webs have different fatty acid (FA) compositions, the aim of this study was to characterize the gonadal maturation of P. orbignyanus and P. patagonicus females through the analysis of lipid content and FA profile in order to understand to what extent life history traits are reflected in the ovarian composition. During gonadal maturation lipid content increased and FA profiles changed in both species, but the lipid increase was greater in P. orbignyanus. The N-3FA and n-3HUFA proportions increased in both species but were higher in P. orbignyanus. The differences between the lifestyles of these species were reflected in the ovarian FA profile mainly as a result of differences in their FA metabolism, causing a greater accumulation of n-3FA and n-3HUFA in P. orbignyanus than in P. patagonicus. The higher lipid accumulation in P. orbignyanus’ ovaries could indicate that this species, feeding in brackish water bodies, has the possibility of storing more energy than P. patagonicus.

Resource Use of an Aquacultured Oyster (Crassostrea gigas) in the Reverse Estuary Bahía San Quintín, Baja California, México

Shellfish aquaculture is prominent in many coastal and estuarine environments and has both ecological and economic impacts. Bahia San Quintin is a reverse estuary in Baja California, Mexico, where Pacific oysters (Crassostrea gigas) are cultivated. While oysters likely feed heavily on phytoplankton especially during upwelling periods, we hypothesized that other forms of organic matter such as seagrass (Zostera marina) and macroalgae (Ulva spp.) must also be used by the oysters, especially in the most inshore portions of the bay. We measured the carbon and hydrogen stable isotope composition of oysters and their potential food resources at upper, mid, and lower bay sites during upwelling and non-upwelling seasons and applied a Bayesian mixing model to evaluate resource use. Hydrogen isotopes provided a large separation between potential food resources. Although we did not find any strong seasonal effects due to upwelling, there was a strong spatial gradient in resource use. Phytoplankton were most important at the lower (oceanic) site (median resource use for two sampling times, 68 and 79 %) and decreased up the estuary as macroalgae became more important (43 and 56 % at the upper site). At all sites for both sampling times, seagrass was an unimportant resource for oysters. The contrast between high phytoplankton use at the lower site and increased macroalgal use at the upper site is likely due to available resource biomass. Results indicate the adaptability of oysters to varying resource availability and the possibility of a higher system carrying capacity than that based on phytoplankton alone given multiple potential food sources. This study also highlights the utility of hydrogen isotopes in estuarine food web research.

Drivers of spatial and temporal variability in estuarine food webs

Drivers of spatial and temporal variability in estuarine food webs

Trophic relationships in an estuarine environment: A quantitative fatty acid analysis signature approach

In order to better understand the functioning of aquatic environments, it is necessary to obtain accurate diet estimations in food webs. Their description should incorporate information about energy flow and the relative importance of trophic pathways. Fatty acids have been extensively used in qualitative studies on trophic relationships in food webs. Recently a new method to estimate quantitatively single predator diet has been developed. In this study, a model of aquatic food web through quantitative fatty acid signature analysis was generated to identify the trophic interactions among the species in the Rocha Lagoon. The biological sampling over two consecutive annual periods was comprehensive enough to identify all functional groups in the aquatic food web (except birds and mammals). Heleobia australis seemed to play a central role in this estuarine ecosystem. As both, a grazer and a prey to several other species, probably H. australis is transferring a great amount of energy to upper trophic levels. Most of the species at Rocha Lagoon have a wide range of prey items in their diet reflecting a complex food web, which is characteristic of extremely dynamic environment as estuarine ecosystems. QFASA is a model in tracing and quantitative estimate trophic pathways among species in an estuarine food web. The results obtained in the present work are a valuable contribution in the understanding of trophic relationships in Rocha Lagoon.

Feeding Habitats, Connectivity and Origin of Organic Matter Supporting Fish Populations in an Estuary with a Reduced Intertidal Area Assessed by Stable Isotope Analysis

Stable isotopes (δ13C and δ15N) were used to analyse the food web downstream of the largest estuary on the French coast: the Gironde. The different sources of organic matter supporting the most abundant and commercially important fish species were determined, as well as habitat connectivity for fish. Stable isotope analysis was performed in different producers (marine, freshwater and local sources), primary consumers (zooplankton and macrozoobenthos) and nine fish species (Alosa alosa, Engraulis encrasicolus, Sprattus sprattus, Liza ramada, Pomatoschistus minutus, Platichthys flesus, Solea solea, Dicentrarchus punctatus and Argyrosomus regius) in three habitats of the downstream area of the estuary in June–July 2012. All sources and invertebrates had significantly different isotopic signatures in different habitats. Only sole, S. solea, presented distinct dual isotopic signatures, indicating a higher feeding location fidelity, no other fish species showed significant differences in isotopic signatures. This overlap was interpreted as evidence that fish had not been feeding exclusively in the habitat where they were collected, instead ingesting food with different isotopic signatures, reflecting high habitat connectivity for these fish. As the base of the fish food web significantly differed among habitats, the present study indicated the suitability of stable isotopes in tracing fish movements and their fidelity/connectivity for habitats separated by less than 10 km, particularly estuarine habitats without salinity differences but located on opposite banks. The SIAR mixing model estimations of organic matter contribution to fish diets in the Gironde estuary were quite similar for the fish species investigated. The major organic source was marine-derived POM, with contributions >75 % for each species. Freshwater and local POM (generally indicated as the sources structuring estuarine food webs) contributed little to the overall fish food webs in the Gironde estuary. Only flounder, P. flesus, and shad, A. alosa, migratory amphihaline species, utilised freshwater POM in greater proportion than marine. The observed low freshwater POM-high marine POM contribution to the fish food web seems to be explained by the reduced intertidal surface of the system. This characterization of the trophic base and habitat connectivity for the most important Gironde estuary fish provides a novel insight for future management of the estuary, especially in the current context of global change.

Possible predation by the striped weakfish Cynoscion guatucupa on estuary-associated fishes in an Argentinian coastal lagoon

Cynoscion guatucupa is one of the most important coastal fishery resources of Argentina and Uruguay, with both juveniles and adults being recorded in Mar Chiquita coastal lagoon, a shallow-water estuarine lagoon in Argentina. Cynoscion guatucupa enters and exits the lagoon following tidal cycles, with residence time within the lagoon lasting only for the duration of a tidal cycle. The main objectives of this study were to determine the diet composition of Cynoscion guatucupa captured in the lagoon, and to determine if different size-classes of this species differentially utilize available food resources during their residency within the coastal lagoon. The diet of 511 specimens of C. guatucupa was analysed. The most important prey item in %IRI was Peisos petrunkevitchi, followed by juvenile teleosts including those of Micropogonias furnieri, Odontesthes argentinensis and Mugil platanus. Cynoscion guatucupa enters the lagoon to feed on a variety of invertebrates as well as juvenile teleost fishes. Diet composition showed ontogenetic changes: smaller individuals predominantly consume crustaceans, and as size increases they begin to prey more on teleosts, with the largest fishes specializing on fish. The present study reinforces the role of estuaries for marine fishes as both feeding grounds for juveniles and adults and as refuge areas for juveniles. Furthermore, this study also highlights the importance of food habit studies for understanding the trophic ecology of fishes and estuarine food web dynamics.

The use of flow cytometric applications to measure the effects of PAHs on growth, membrane integrity, and relative lipid content of the benthic diatom, Nitzschia brevirostris

This laboratory study measured the direct effects of three polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) compounds (naphthalene, pyrene, and benzo(a)pyrene) upon cell growth, membrane integrity, and BODIPY-stained lipid fluorescence intensity of the benthic diatom Nitzschia brevirostris using flow cytometry as an analysis tool. Previous field and laboratory studies have reported reductions in algal populations following PAH exposure, but specific, functional responses of the microalgae to these pollutants could not be revealed by cell numbers alone. Using flow-cytometric measurements, we confirmed that maximal cell densities in PAH-exposed diatom cultures were significantly lower compared to controls; however, we also discovered increases in lipids and cells with compromised membranes in PAH-exposed cultures. These results highlight new tools for measuring the direct effects of organic pollutants upon the physiology of taxa comprising microphytobenthic communities important in estuarine food webs.

Phytoplankton Community Shifts and Harmful Algae Presence in a Diversion Influenced Estuary

River water entering estuaries affects the physical and chemical environment at irregular intervals creating a highly dynamic aquatic habitat. Phytoplankton are important primary producers in estuaries that respond quickly to their changing environment. Over a 12-month period, the phytoplankton response was examined in terms of biomass, abundance, community composition, and potential phycotoxin production to seasonal changes in river input entering the Breton Sound Estuary in Louisiana. Chlorophyll a (chl a) measurements estimated phytoplankton biomass and light microscopy identified phytoplankton abundance and community composition. Phycotoxins were measured using ultra-sensitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). During the study period, chl a and cell abundances exhibited an inverse relationship with the seasons, which were determined by temperature and diversion input rates. The community was dominated by cyanobacteria for most of the year, mainly corresponding to the warm-low flow season. For the rest of the year, cyanobacteria decreased while chlorophytes and centric diatoms increased to approximately equal contributions. Overall, the phytoplankton community composition was most commonly moderated by temperature, salinity, and dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) availability using BIO-ENV. Microcystins (MCs) were detected throughout the year ranging from below detection to 2.92 μg MCs l−1. MC levels were highest during the warm-low flow season and toward the lower estuary. The detection of MCs for the first time in the Breton Sound Estuary illustrates a potential risk to human health and economically important estuarine food webs.

Measuring sensitivity of robustness and network indices for an estuarine food web model under perturbations

Robustness is a universal feature of ecological systems which promotes sustainability over time. Robustness of an aquatic ecosystem, specifically an estuarine system, is investigated here using indicators derived from ecological network analysis. Estuaries provide us with many ecosystem services and these are consequently prone to face anthropogenic stresses. In South Africa, temporarily open/closed estuaries occupy a significant percentage of coastal boundaries. One of the South African estuaries, namely Mdloti, is studied here using network-based, Ecopath software. The estuarine energy flow networks are perturbed following different scenarios, which are assumed to be a result of selected anthropogenic stresses (eutrophication, overfishing) to the system. Several network indices such as total system throughput (TST), redundancy (R), Finn’s Cycling Index (FCI) and ascendency over development capacity ratio (A/C) are calculated and analyzed for the original field-based network and three perturbed networks under different scenarios (change of autotrophic biomass, fish yield, and detritus import). The change of ecosystem robustness from the unperturbed network is more pronounced in the perturbed networks of fish biomass change and detritus import than change in autotrophic biomass scenario. These indicators reliably reflected the relative change of flow pattern if any changes occur and magnitude in the networks in different scenarios. From the present study, we show that certain common network indices as mentioned above provide a measure of robustness and can be used for the assessment of ecosystem organization and function. ENA properties and also robustness change depending on the type and magnitude of stress imposed on the system.

Sexual sterilization of the daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio (Decapoda: Palaemonidae) by the bopyrid isopod Probopyrus pandalicola (Isopoda: Bopyridae).

Probopyrus pandalicola is a bopyrid isopod that infects several palaemonid shrimp species, including the daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio . The parasite can have several negative effects on its host, including loss of hemolymph, reduced reproductive potential, and decreased molting frequency and growth. To date, there are conflicting reports on whether Probopyrus pandalicola affects the reproductive capability of both male and female daggerblade grass shrimp. The purpose of this study was to determine whether infection by Probopyrus pandalicola resulted in the sexual sterilization of Palaemonetes pugio , and if the reproductive capability of male and/or female shrimp was restored after the bopyrid was removed. We found that parasitized and deparasitized males were able to fertilize the eggs of unparasitized females successfully, as 18.9 ± 7.1% and 42.7 ± 5.2% of the females paired with them became ovigerous in 4 wk, respectively. Neither parasitized nor deparasitized females became ovigerous when placed with unparasitized males during the 4-wk period. However, 45.4 ± 20.6% of deparasitized females did become ovigerous within 10 wk. Despite the fact that female shrimp are able to reproduce again when no longer parasitized, the majority of females remain infected with the bopyrid for their entire lives. Therefore, the sexual sterilization of female shrimp could potentially have a significant impact on estuarine food webs, as grass shrimp are conduits of detrital energy and a food source for many recreationally and commercially important species in estuaries on the East Coast of the United States and in the Gulf of Mexico.