Isoform Expression Estimation Research Articles

DELongSeq for efficient detection of differential isoform expression from long-read RNA-seq data.

Conventional gene expression quantification approaches, such as microarrays or quantitative PCR, have similar variations of estimates for all genes. However, next-generation short-read or long-read sequencing use read counts to estimate expression levels with much wider dynamic ranges. In addition to the accuracy of estimated isoform expression, efficiency, which measures the degree of estimation uncertainty, is also an important factor for downstream analysis. Instead of read count, we present DELongSeq, which employs information matrix of EM algorithm to quantify uncertainty of isoform expression estimates to improve estimation efficiency. DELongSeq uses random-effect regression model for the analysis of DE isoform, in that within-study variation represents variable precision in isoform expression estimation and between-study variation represents variation in isoform expression levels across samples. More importantly, DELongSeq allows 1 case versus 1 control comparison of differential expression, which has specific application scenarios in precision medicine (such as before versus after treatment, or tumor versus stromal tissues). Through extensive simulations and analysis of several RNA-Seq datasets, we show that the uncertainty quantification approach is computationally reliable, and can improve the power of differential expression (DE) analysis of isoforms or genes. In summary, DELongSeq allows for efficient detection of differential isoform/gene expression from long-read RNA-Seq data.

Platform-integrated mRNA isoform quantification.

Accurate estimation of transcript isoform abundance is critical for downstream transcriptome analyses and can lead to precise molecular mechanisms for understanding complex human diseases, like cancer. Simplex mRNA Sequencing (RNA-Seq) based isoform quantification approaches are facing the challenges of inherent sampling bias and unidentifiable read origins. A large-scale experiment shows that the consistency between RNA-Seq and other mRNA quantification platforms is relatively low at the isoform level compared to the gene level. In this project, we developed a platform-integrated model for transcript quantification (IntMTQ) to improve the performance of RNA-Seq on isoform expression estimation. IntMTQ, which benefits from the mRNA expressions reported by the other platforms, provides more precise RNA-Seq-based isoform quantification and leads to more accurate molecular signatures for disease phenotype prediction. In the experiments to assess the quality of isoform expression estimated by IntMTQ, we designed three tasks for clustering and classification of 46 cancer cell lines with four different mRNA quantification platforms, including newly developed NanoString's nCounter technology. The results demonstrate that the isoform expressions learned by IntMTQ consistently provide more and better molecular features for downstream analyses compared with five baseline algorithms which consider RNA-Seq data only. An independent RT-qPCR experiment on seven genes in twelve cancer cell lines showed that the IntMTQ improved overall transcript quantification. The platform-integrated algorithms could be applied to large-scale cancer studies, such as The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA), with both RNA-Seq and array-based platforms available. Source code is available at: https://github.com/CompbioLabUcf/IntMTQ. Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Correction of gene model annotations improves isoform abundance estimates: the example of ketohexokinase ( Khk).

Next generation sequencing protocols such as RNA-seq have made the genome-wide characterization of the transcriptome a crucial part of many research projects in biology. Analyses of the resulting data provide key information on gene expression and in certain cases on exon or isoform usage. The emergence of transcript quantification software such as Salmon has enabled researchers to efficiently estimate isoform and gene expressions across the genome while tremendously reducing the necessary computational power. Although overall gene expression estimations were shown to be accurate, isoform expression quantifications appear to be a more challenging task. Low expression levels and uneven or insufficient coverage were reported as potential explanations for inconsistent estimates. Here, through the example of the ketohexokinase ( Khk) gene in mouse, we demonstrate that the use of an incorrect gene annotation can also result in erroneous isoform quantification results. Manual correction of the input Khk gene model provided a much more accurate estimation of relative Khk isoform expression when compared to quantitative PCR (qPCR measurements). In particular, removal of an unexpressed retained intron and a proper adjustment of the 5' and 3' untranslated regions both had a strong impact on the correction of erroneous estimates. Finally, we observed a better concordance in isoform quantification between datasets and sequencing strategies when relying on the newly generated Khk annotations. These results highlight the importance of accurate gene models and annotations for correct isoform quantification and reassert the need for orthogonal methods of estimation of isoform expression to confirm important findings.

Correction of gene model annotations improves isoform abundance estimates: the example of ketohexokinase ( Khk)

Next generation sequencing protocols such as RNA-seq have made the genome-wide characterization of the transcriptome a crucial part of many research projects in biology. Analyses of the resulting data provide key information on gene expression and in certain cases on exon or isoform usage. The emergence of transcript quantification software such as Salmon has enabled researchers to efficiently estimate isoform and gene expressions across the genome while tremendously reducing the necessary computational power. Although overall gene expression estimations were shown to be accurate, isoform expression quantifications appear to be a more challenging task. Low expression levels and uneven or insufficient coverage were reported as potential explanations for inconsistent estimates. Here, through the example of the ketohexokinase ( Khk) gene in mouse, we demonstrate that the use of an incorrect gene annotation can also result in erroneous isoform quantification results. Manual correction of the input Khk gene model provided a much more accurate estimation of relative Khk isoform expression when compared to quantitative PCR (qPCR measurements). In particular, removal of an unexpressed retained intron and a proper adjustment of the 5’ and 3’ untranslated regions both had a strong impact on the correction of erroneous estimates. Finally, we observed a better concordance in isoform quantification between datasets and sequencing strategies when relying on the newly generated Khk annotations. These results highlight the importance of accurate gene models and annotations for correct isoform quantification and reassert the need for orthogonal methods of estimation of isoform expression to confirm important findings.

Correction of gene model annotations improves isoform abundance estimates: the example of ketohexokinase (Khk)

Next generation sequencing protocols such as RNA-seq have made the genome wide characterization of the transcriptome a crucial part of many research projects in biology. Analyses of the resulting data provide key information on gene expression and in certain cases on exon or isoform usage. The emergence of transcript quantification software such as Salmon has enabled researchers to efficiently estimate isoform and gene expressions across the genome while tremendously reducing the necessary computational power. Although overall gene expression estimations were shown to be accurate, isoform expression quantifications appear to be a more challenging task. Low expression levels and uneven or insufficient coverage were reported as potential explanations for inconsistent estimates. Here, through the example of the ketohexokinase (Khk) gene in mouse, we demonstrate that the use of an incorrect gene annotation can also result in erroneous isoform quantification results. Manual correction of the input Khk gene model provided a much more accurate estimation of relative Khk isoform expression when compared to quantitative PCR (qPCR measurements). In particular, removal of an unexpressed retained intron and a proper adjustment of the 5’ and 3’ untranslated regions both had a strong impact on the correction of erroneous estimates. Finally, we observed a better concordance in isoform quantification between datasets and sequencing strategies when relying on the newly generated Khk annotations. These results highlight the importance of accurate gene models and annotations for correct isoform quantification and reassert the need for orthogonal methods of estimation of isoform expression to confirm important findings.

PennDiff: detecting differential alternative splicing and transcription by RNA sequencing.

Alternative splicing and alternative transcription are a major mechanism for generating transcriptome diversity. Differential alternative splicing and transcription (DAST), which describe different usage of transcript isoforms across different conditions, can complement differential expression in characterizing gene regulation. However, the analysis of DAST is challenging because only a small fraction of RNA-seq reads is informative for isoforms. Several methods have been developed to detect exon-based and gene-based DAST, but they suffer from power loss for genes with many isoforms. We present PennDiff, a novel statistical method that makes use of information on gene structures and pre-estimated isoform relative abundances, to detect DAST from RNA-seq data. PennDiff has several advantages. First, grouping exons avoids multiple testing for 'exons' originated from the same isoform(s). Second, it utilizes all available reads in exon-inclusion level estimation, which is different from methods that only use junction reads. Third, collapsing isoforms sharing the same alternative exons reduces the impact of isoform expression estimation uncertainty. PennDiff is able to detect DAST at both exon and gene levels, thus offering more flexibility than existing methods. Simulations and analysis of a real RNA-seq dataset indicate that PennDiff has well-controlled type I error rate, and is more powerful than existing methods including DEXSeq, rMATS, Cuffdiff, IUTA and SplicingCompass. As the popularity of RNA-seq continues to grow, we expect PennDiff to be useful for diverse transcriptomics studies. PennDiff source code and user guide is freely available for download at https://github.com/tigerhu15/PennDiff. Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

A structured sparse regression method for estimating isoform expression level from multi-sample RNA-seq data.

With the rapid development of next-generation high-throughput sequencing technology, RNA-seq has become a standard and important technique for transcriptome analysis. For multi-sample RNA-seq data, the existing expression estimation methods usually deal with each single-RNA-seq sample, and ignore that the read distributions are consistent across multiple samples. In the current study, we propose a structured sparse regression method, SSRSeq, to estimate isoform expression using multi-sample RNA-seq data. SSRSeq uses a non-parameter model to capture the general tendency of non-uniformity read distribution for all genes across multiple samples. Additionally, our method adds a structured sparse regularization, which not only incorporates the sparse specificity between a gene and its corresponding isoform expression levels, but also reduces the effects of noisy reads, especially for lowly expressed genes and isoforms. Four real datasets were used to evaluate our method on isoform expression estimation. Compared with other popular methods, SSRSeq reduced the variance between multiple samples, and produced more accurate isoform expression estimations, and thus more meaningful biological interpretations.

Estimation of isoform expression in RNA-seq data using a hierarchical Bayesian model.

Estimation of gene or isoform expression is a fundamental step in many transcriptome analysis tasks, such as differential expression analysis, eQTL (or sQTL) studies, and biological network construction. RNA-seq technology enables us to monitor the expression on genome-wide scale at single base pair resolution and offers the possibility of accurately measuring expression at the level of isoform. However, challenges remain because of non-uniform read sampling and the presence of various biases in RNA-seq data. In this paper, we present a novel hierarchical Bayesian method to estimate isoform expression. While most of the existing methods treat gene expression as a by-product, we incorporate it into our model and explicitly describe its relationship with corresponding isoform expression using a Multinomial distribution. In this way, gene and isoform expression are included in a unified framework and it helps us achieve a better performance over other state-of-the-art algorithms for isoform expression estimation. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated using both simulated data with known ground truth and two real RNA-seq datasets from MAQC project. The codes are available at http://www.math.pku.edu.cn/teachers/dengmh/GIExp/.

MetaDiff: differential isoform expression analysis using random-effects meta-regression

BackgroundRNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) allows an unbiased survey of the entire transcriptome in a high-throughput manner. A major application of RNA-Seq is to detect differential isoform expression across experimental conditions, which is of great biological interest due to its direct relevance to protein function and disease pathogenesis. Detection of differential isoform expression is challenging because of uncertainty in isoform expression estimation owing to ambiguous reads and variability in precision of the estimates across samples. It is desirable to have a method that can account for these issues and is flexible enough to allow adjustment for covariates.ResultsIn this paper, we present MetaDiff, a random-effects meta-regression model that naturally fits for the above purposes. Through extensive simulations and analysis of an RNA-Seq dataset on human heart failure, we show that the random-effects meta-regression approach is computationally fast, reliable, and can improve the power of differential expression analysis while controlling for false positives due to the effect of covariates or confounding variables. In contrast, several existing methods either fail to control false discovery rate or have reduced power in the presence of covariates or confounding variables. The source code, compiled JAR package and documentation of MetaDiff are freely available at https://github.com/jiach/MetaDiff.ConclusionOur results indicate that random-effects meta-regression offers a flexible framework for differential expression analysis of isoforms, particularly when gene expression is influenced by other variables.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-015-0623-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A penalized likelihood approach for robust estimation of isoform expression.

Ultra high-throughput sequencing of transcriptomes (RNA-Seq) has enabled the accurate estimation of gene expression at individual isoform level. However, systematic biases introduced during the sequencing and mapping processes as well as incompleteness of the transcript annotation databases may cause the estimates of isoform abundances to be unreliable, and in some cases, highly inaccurate. This paper introduces a penalized likelihood approach to detect and correct for such biases in a robust manner. Our model extends those previously proposed by introducing bias parameters for reads. An L1 penalty is used for the selection of non-zero bias parameters. We introduce an efficient algorithm for model fitting and analyze the statistical properties of the proposed model. Our experimental studies on both simulated and real datasets suggest that the model has the potential to improve isoform-specific gene expression estimates and identify incompletely annotated gene models.

PennSeq: accurate isoform-specific gene expression quantification in RNA-Seq by modeling non-uniform read distribution

Correctly estimating isoform-specific gene expression is important for understanding complicated biological mechanisms and for mapping disease susceptibility genes. However, estimating isoform-specific gene expression is challenging because various biases present in RNA-Seq (RNA sequencing) data complicate the analysis, and if not appropriately corrected, can affect isoform expression estimation and downstream analysis. In this article, we present PennSeq, a statistical method that allows each isoform to have its own non-uniform read distribution. Instead of making parametric assumptions, we give adequate weight to the underlying data by the use of a non-parametric approach. Our rationale is that regardless what factors lead to non-uniformity, whether it is due to hexamer priming bias, local sequence bias, positional bias, RNA degradation, mapping bias or other unknown reasons, the probability that a fragment is sampled from a particular region will be reflected in the aligned data. This empirical approach thus maximally reflects the true underlying non-uniform read distribution. We evaluate the performance of PennSeq using both simulated data with known ground truth, and using two real Illumina RNA-Seq data sets including one with quantitative real time polymerase chain reaction measurements. Our results indicate superior performance of PennSeq over existing methods, particularly for isoforms demonstrating severe non-uniformity. PennSeq is freely available for download at http://sourceforge.net/projects/pennseq.

Joint estimation of isoform expression and isoform-specific read distribution using multisample RNA-Seq data

RNA-sequencing technologies provide a powerful tool for expression analysis at gene and isoform level, but accurate estimation of isoform abundance is still a challenge. Standard assumption of uniform read intensity would yield biased estimates when the read intensity is in fact non-uniform. The problem is that, without strong assumptions, the read intensity pattern is not identifiable from data observed in a single sample. We develop a joint statistical model that accounts for non-uniform isoform-specific read distribution and gene isoform expression estimation. The main challenge is in dealing with the large number of isoform-specific read distributions, which potentially are as many as the number of splice variants in the genome. A statistical regularization via a smoothing penalty is imposed to control the estimation. Also, for identifiability reasons, the method uses information across samples from the same region. We develop a fast and robust computational procedure based on the iterated-weighted least-squares algorithm, and apply it to simulated data and two real RNA-Seq datasets with reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction validation. Empirical tests show that our model performs better than existing methods in terms of increasing precision in isoform-level estimation. We have implemented our method in an R package called Sequgio as a pipeline for fast processing of RNA-Seq data.

NURD: an implementation of a new method to estimate isoform expression from non-uniform RNA-seq data

BackgroundRNA-Seq technology has been used widely in transcriptome study, and one of the most important applications is to estimate the expression level of genes and their alternative splicing isoforms. There have been several algorithms published to estimate the expression based on different models. Recently Wu et al. published a method that can accurately estimate isoform level expression by considering position-related sequencing biases using nonparametric models. The method has advantages in handling different read distributions, but there hasn’t been an efficient program to implement this algorithm.ResultsWe developed an efficient implementation of the algorithm in the program NURD. It uses a binary interval search algorithm. The program can correct both the global tendency of sequencing bias in the data and local sequencing bias specific to each gene. The correction makes the isoform expression estimation more reliable under various read distributions. And the implementation is computationally efficient in both the memory cost and running time and can be readily scaled up for huge datasets.ConclusionNURD is an efficient and reliable tool for estimating the isoform expression level. Given the reads mapping result and gene annotation file, NURD will output the expression estimation result. The package is freely available for academic use at http://bioinfo.au.tsinghua.edu.cn/software/NURD/.

Identifying differentially spliced genes from two groups of RNA-seq samples

Recent study revealed that most human genes have alternative splicing and can produce multiple isoforms of transcripts. Differences in the relative abundance of the isoforms of a gene can have significant biological consequences. Identifying genes that are differentially spliced between two groups of RNA-sequencing samples is an important basic task in the study of transcriptomes with next-generation sequencing technology.We use the negative binomial (NB) distribution to model sequencing reads on exons, and propose a NB-statistic to detect differentially spliced genes between two groups of samples by comparing read counts on all exons. The method opens a new exon-based approach instead of isoform-based approach for the task. It does not require information about isoform composition, nor need the estimation of isoform expression. Experiments on simulated data and real RNA-seq data of human kidney and liver samples illustrated the method's good performance and applicability. It can also detect previously unknown alternative splicing events, and highlight exons that are most likely differentially spliced between the compared samples.We developed an NB-statistic method that can detect differentially spliced genes between two groups of samples without using a prior knowledge on the annotation of alternative splicing. It does not need to infer isoform structure or to estimate isoform expression. It is a useful method designed for comparing two groups of RNA-seq samples. Besides identifying differentially spliced genes, the method can highlight on the exons that contribute the most to the differential splicing. We developed a software tool called DSGseq for the presented method available at http://bioinfo.au.tsinghua.edu.cn/software/DSGseq.

Modeling RNA degradation for RNA-Seq with applications

RNA-Seq is widely used in biological and biomedical studies. Methods for the estimation of the transcript's abundance using RNA-Seq data have been intensively studied, many of which are based on the assumption that the short-reads of RNA-Seq are uniformly distributed along the transcripts. However, the short-reads are found to be nonuniformly distributed along the transcripts, which can greatly reduce the accuracies of these methods based on the uniform assumption. Several methods are developed to adjust the biases induced by this nonuniformity, utilizing the short-read's empirical distribution in transcript. As an alternative, we found that RNA degradation plays a major role in the formation of the short-read's nonuniform distribution and thus developed a new approach that quantifies the short-read's nonuniform distribution by precisely modeling RNA degradation. Our model of RNA degradation fits RNA-Seq data quite well, and based on this model, a new statistical method was further developed to estimate transcript expression level, as well as the RNA degradation rate, for individual genes and their isoforms. We showed that our method can improve the accuracy of transcript isoform expression estimation. The RNA degradation rate of individual transcript we estimated is consistent across samples and/or experiments/platforms. In addition, the RNA degradation rate from our model is independent of the RNA length, consistent with previous studies on RNA decay rate.

Statistical inferences for isoform expression in RNA-Seq

The development of RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) makes it possible for us to measure transcription at an unprecedented precision and throughput. However, challenges remain in understanding the source and distribution of the reads, modeling the transcript abundance and developing efficient computational methods. In this article, we develop a method to deal with the isoform expression estimation problem. The count of reads falling into a locus on the genome annotated with multiple isoforms is modeled as a Poisson variable. The expression of each individual isoform is estimated by solving a convex optimization problem and statistical inferences about the parameters are obtained from the posterior distribution by importance sampling. Our results show that isoform expression inference in RNA-Seq is possible by employing appropriate statistical methods.