The molecular oxygen concentration in biological material at the time of x-irradiation is an important determinant of the magnitude of observed response of mammalian cells. This has been firmly established by many experiments in several laboratories (Gray, 1961). The data show that two to three times as much x-radiation is required to produce a given effect in anoxic as in oxygenated (> 10 mm. HgO2 tension) biological material. That is, the “oxygen effect” factor for cell lethal damage is between 2 and 3. Changes in radiation sensitivity with variations in oxygen tension occur almost entirely in the range of anoxia to marked hypoxia (0–10 mm. Hg). These findings in biological research are of clinical interest since there are areas of necrosis in nearly all carcinomas of significant size. Such necrotic areas were shown by Thomlinson and Gray (1955) in the bronchogenic carcinomas of their study to be at distances from capillaries which would be predicted to be anoxic on the basis of oxygen diffusion coefficient, oxygen utilization by viable cells, capillary diameter, length, and blood flow. If there are anoxic cells in a carcinoma which are viable and replicating, then those cells would be radiation-resistant in comparison with the surrounding normal cells, due to the difference in oxygen tension. Under these conditions an increased clinical effectiveness of radiation therapy would be expected if the oxygen concentration in all of the normal and malignant cells were made the same. We have initiated a study to evaluate the response to x-irradiation of normal and malignant tissue of distal limbs under conditions of local tissue anoxia produced by placing a tourniquet above the lesion. Preliminary determinations of the effect of the tourniquet application on the radiation sensitivity of the skin in the limb were made. Case I: The volar surface of the forearm of a patient (V. S.) about to be treated for an extensive recurrent squamous-cell carcinoma of the dorsum of the hand, was selected as the test site. Three areas of normal skin were irradiated at 60 kv, 2 cm. TSD; circular fields 1.5 cm. in diameter were used and the doses were 2,000, 2,500, and 3,000 rads. The limb was then drained of blood by application of an Esmarch bandage to the full length of the arm. Following this an orthopedic tourniquet was fixed to the mid portion of the upper arm (300 mm. Hg pressure). Under these conditions a parallel set of three skin fields were given 4,000, 5000, and 6,000 rads respectively. The dose in the two series thus differed by a factor of two. Repeat observations revealed that the reaction in the areas treated with normal oxygen tension was a little more severe than in the areas treated while the tourniquet was in place. These results show the “oxygen effect factor” for 60 kv as being ≥2.0.
Read full abstract