Equity In Health Care Delivery Research Articles

A health equity monitoring framework based on process mining.

In the United States, there is a proposal to link hospital Medicare payments with health equity measures, signaling a need to precisely measure equity in healthcare delivery. Despite significant research demonstrating disparities in health care outcomes and access, there is a noticeable gap in tools available to assess health equity across various health conditions and treatments. The available tools often focus on a single area of patient care, such as medication delivery, but fail to examine the entire health care process. The objective of this study is to propose a process mining framework to provide a comprehensive view of health equity. Using event logs which track all actions during patient care, this method allows us to look at disparities in single and multiple treatment steps, but also in the broader strategy of treatment delivery. We have applied this framework to the management of patients with sepsis in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU), focusing on sex and English language proficiency. We found no significant differences between treatments of male and female patients. However, for patients who don't speak English, there was a notable delay in starting their treatment, even though their illness was just as severe and subsequent treatments were similar. This framework subsumes existing individual approaches to measure health inequities and offers a comprehensive approach to pinpoint and delve into healthcare disparities, providing a valuable tool for research and policy-making aiming at more equitable healthcare.

Sustainability and high-level corruption in healthcare procurement: Profiles of Italian contracting authorities

Addressing corruption is crucial for building a sustainable healthcare system that ensures access, quality, and equity in healthcare delivery. Despite that, many current strategies to combat corruption in the healthcare sector do not evaluate high-level corruption, such as corruption risks occurring at sub-national levels. This work bridges this gap by providing corruption risk profiles of Italian contracting authorities responsible for procuring goods and services for healthcare facilities in the public procurement process. Using an array of 14 red flags of corruption risk and an extended Item Response Theory model applied to a big data source made available by the Italian Anti-corruption Authority, our main findings show that: i. the risk of corruption is a multidimensional occurrence, which can be represented as a four-dimensional latent variable; ii. there are eight clusters of contracting authorities, having distinct and well-defined risk profiles over the four ascertained dimensions of corruption risk; iii. the distribution of risk profiles at sub-national level showcases relevant geographic variations and emphasises the need for tailored anti-corruption strategies to effectively address region-specific challenges and risk factors.

Minding the Safety Gap: The Road Towards Global Equity in Health Care Delivery

Minding the Safety Gap: The Road Towards Global Equity in Health Care Delivery

Medical Equity: The Eventual Goal of Health Care

Medical equity is the fundamental principle that all individuals should have equal access to high-quality healthcare services, regardless of their race, ethnicity, gender, socioeconomic status, or geographic location. Achieving medical equity is essential for improving health outcomes and reducing disparities in healthcare delivery. This goal requires addressing systemic barriers such as discrimination, stigma, and lack of access to resources that prevent marginalized populations from receiving appropriate care. Implementing policies and programs that promote medical equity will help ensure that everyone has the opportunity to lead a healthy life. By prioritizing equity in healthcare delivery, we can work towards creating a more just and inclusive society where every individual has the opportunity to achieve optimal health and well-being.

The Heartbeat of Equity: The Crucial Contributions of Nurses in Health Equity

Background: The pursuit of health equity has gained significant attention in recent years, with a focus on eliminating health disparities and addressing social determinants of health. Health equity is crucial in ensuring that everyone has an equal opportunity to attain his/her full potential for well-being and health. Purpose: This paper aimed to conduct a comprehensive analysis of health equity and healthcare disparities, specifically from the perspective of nursing. It also emphasizes the importance of nursing professionals in promoting health equity, addressing health disparities, and advocating for fair and equitable access to healthcare services. Methods: A scoping review was performed to determine applicable international reports and literature published in English. The search was conducted across various electronic databases, including Google Scholar, CINAHL, EBSCO, MEDLINE, and PubMed. Results: The findings revealed that achieving health equity involves addressing the root causes that hinder individuals from attaining optimal health. Social determinants of health play a significant role in shaping health outcomes, and addressing these factors is essential to achieve health equity. Furthermore, the study underscores the need for a community-oriented approach that involves collaboration with community and government sectors to improve social care resources and healthcare delivery. Conclusion: Nurses play multi-faceted roles in promoting health equity through technology, policy, education, research, philosophy and theory context, and disaster response. They have the opportunity to address health disparities and promote health, particularly in underserved communities. Implications for Nursing: Nurses need to be actively involved in advocating for policies and practices that address social determinants of health and promote equity in healthcare delivery. By recognizing the impacts of social, economic, and environmental factors on health outcomes, nurses can play a key role in addressing health disparities and promoting health equity. This involves collaboration with various stakeholders, advocating for resource allocation, and implementing communityoriented approaches to address health inequities Keywords: Health equity, Health disparities, Social determinants, Nursing research, Nursing theories, Nursing policy, Nursing education, Health technology, Disaster response, Jordan.

Race, Ethnicity, and Other Patient and Clinical Encounter Characteristics Associated with Patient Experiences of Access to Care.

The Press Ganey (PG) Outpatient Medical Practice Survey measures patients' experiences of healthcare access in the U.S. We aimed to identify differences in experiences of access to care by patient race, ethnicity, and other sociodemographic characteristics, an important first step in informing health policy and ensuring equitable healthcare delivery. We performed a cross-sectional analysis of PG surveys for adult outpatient visits within the University of Pennsylvania Health System from 2014-2017, including 119,373 unique patients. Compared with White patients, Black (odds ratio [OR] 0.84; 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.80-0.87), Asian (OR 0.62; 95% CI 0.58-0.66), and other/unknown race patients (OR 0.83; 95% CI 0.72-0.94) were each less likely to report the maximum score for timely access to care. Patients of all minoritized groups, as well as those whose primary language was not English, reported lower scores in secondary access measures related to communication and respect, compared to White and primarily English-speaking patients, respectively. Efforts to improve the experience of access to care among racial and ethnic minoritized patients are imperative to achieve equity in healthcare delivery.

All talk…only a little action: a reflection on embedding equity into integrated care models in Ontario, Canada

Background: Ontario Health Teams (OHTs) are a recently introduced model of delivery intended to integrate services to deliver connected care to defined populations in Ontario, Canada. The Quadruple Aim advocates for improving patient experience, reducing cost, advancing population health, and improving the provider experience; it is meant to be a guide for OHTs for performance outcomes and as a framework for evaluation and reporting. The Quintuple Aim, incorporating an added focus on health equity, has recently been introduced to OHTs, where equity is also built into continuous quality improvement requirements. As embedded OHT research fellows, we recognize our key role in supporting equity in healthcare delivery and programs. However, we also observe the challenges to generating actionable initiatives to integrate equity into OHTs.
 Objective: The objective of this presentation is to describe equity initiatives being incorporated in four OHTs in Ontario, Canada and to identify the barriers and facilitators at the micro, meso and macro levels. This presentation is aimed at those involved in integrated care research, policy, practice, and education.
 Methods: We will use a multiple case study design to describe the contexts of four integrated care models representing large, mid, and small urban regions of the province. This work is guided by the Rainbow Model for Integrated Care, which conceptualizes different domains of integrated care. We will include multiple data sources from each OHT, including key documents, formal and informal community partnerships, the level and nature of engagement with equity-deserving groups in governance processes, the extent to which equity is emphasized in strategic plans and other documents, and the resources available, we share insights gleaned on barriers and facilitators to applying an equity lens. 
 Key Results: We identify challenges related to data availability for health equity decision making and health systems planning. Specifically, difficulties exist in accessing meaningful and linked data to understand OHT attributed populations; these difficulties are compounded when seeking data specific to equity deserving groups and when attempting to link equity relevant indicators to health system indicators. Furthermore, meaningful engagement with equity deserving groups in order to build relationships requires time and resources that are difficult to source; such engagement is particularly challenging in an environment of limited financial resources, where frequent reporting and pressure to quickly deliver outcomes is emphasized. OHTs are collaborative governance models composed of representation from member organizations, patients, and academics; this collaborative approach to governance can be a facilitator to embedding equity deserving groups into the structure of OHTs.
 Next Steps: Ontario Health Teams require support in creating comprehensive equity approaches that are specific to the needs of their communities and teams; further work is needed to better understand the needs of OHTs in this regard.

Clinicians' Perspectives on Equitable Health Care Delivery in Group Well-Child Care.

To explore clinicians' perspectives about the impact of group well-child care (GWCC) on equitable health care delivery. In this qualitative study, we conducted semistructured interviews with clinicians engaged in GWCC recruited via purposive and snowball sampling. We first conducted a deductive content analysis using constructs from Donabedian's framework for health care quality (structure, process, and outcomes) followed by inductive thematic analysis within these constructs. We completed 20 interviews with clinicians who deliver or research GWCC in 11 institutions across the United States. Four major themes around equitable health care delivery in GWCC emerged from clinicians' perspectives: 1) shifts in power dynamics (process); 2) enabling relational care, social support, and a sense of community (process, outcome); 3) centering multidisciplinary care delivery around patient and family needs (structure, process, and outcomes); and 4) unaddressed social and structural barriers limit patient and family participation. Clinicians perceived that GWCC enhances equity in health care delivery by shifting hierarchies in clinical visits and promoting relational, patient, and family-centered care. However, potential opportunities exist to further address provider implicit bias in group care delivery and structural inequities at the level of the health care institution. Clinicians underscored the need to address barriers to participation so that GWCC can more fully enhance equitable health care delivery.

Refining 2SVCA method for measuring telehealth accessibility of primary care physicians in Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Equity in health care delivery is a longstanding concern of public health policy. Telehealth is considered an important way to level the playing field by broadening health services access and improving quality of care and health outcomes. This study refines the recently developed “2-Step Virtual Catchment Area (2SVCA) method” to assess the telehealth accessibility of primary care in the Baton Rouge Metropolitan Statistical Area, Louisiana. The result is compared to that of spatial accessibility via physical visits to care providers based on the popular 2-Step Floating Catchment Area (2SFCA) method. The study shows that both spatial and telehealth accessibilities decline from urban to low-density and then rural areas. Moreover, disproportionally higher percentages of African Americans are in areas with higher spatial accessibility scores; but such an advantage is not realized in telehealth accessibility. In the study area, absence of broadband availability is mainly a rural problem and leads to a lower average telehealth accessibility than physical accessibility in rural areas. On the other side, lack of broadband affordability is a challenge across the rural-urban continuum and is disproportionally associated with high concentrations of disadvantaged population groups such as households under the poverty level and Blacks.

A Policy Framework for the Growing Influence of Private Equity in Health Care Delivery

This Viewpoint details how and why improved oversight of private equity acquisition of physician practices and hospitals is needed to mitigate the effects on health care costs, clinicians’ jobs, and patients’ access to care.

EHealth Literacy and Patient Portal Use and Attitudes: Cross-sectional Observational Study.

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, patient portals have become more widely used tools of patient care delivery. However, not all individuals have equivalent access or ability to use patient portals. The aim of this study is to evaluate the relationships between eHealth literacy (eHL) and patient portal awareness, use, and attitudes among hospitalized patients. Inpatients completed patient portal surveys; eHL was assessed (eHealth Literacy Scale). Multivariable logistic regression analyses adjusted for age, self-reported race, gender, and educational attainment were completed with significance at P<.006 (Bonferroni correction). Among 274 participants, most identified as Black (n=166, 61%) and female (n=140, 51%), mean age was 56.5 (SD 16.7) years, and 178 (65%) reported some college or higher educational attainment. One-quarter (n=79, 28%) had low eHL (mean 27, SD 9.5), which was associated with lower odds of portal access awareness (odds ratio 0.11, 95% CI 0.05-0.23; P<.001), having ever used portals (odds ratio 0.19, 95% CI 0.10-0.36; P<.001), less perceived usefulness of portals (odds ratio 0.20, 95% CI 0.10-0.38; P=.001), and lower likelihood of planning to use portals in the coming years (odds ratio 0.12, 95% CI 0.06-0.25; P<.001). As time through the COVID-19 pandemic passed, there was a trend toward increased perceived usefulness of patient portals (53% vs 62%, P=.08), but average eHL did not increase through time (P=.81). Low eHL was associated with less awareness, use, and perceived usefulness of portals. Perceived usefulness of portals likely increased through the COVID-19 pandemic, but patients' eHL did not. Interventions tailored for patients with low eHL could ensure greater equity in health care delivery through the COVID-19 pandemic.

Can digital finance mitigate trust issues for chronically ill patients because of relative deprivation of income?

The relative deprivation of income among chronically ill patients may create a perception of inequity in their access to quality healthcare, which may lead to a decline in patients' trust and further increases the burden of chronic diseases. Digital finance could be the antidote. To promote equity in healthcare delivery, this study explores the mitigating effect of digital finance by elucidating the relationship between relative deprivation of income and chronically ill patients' trust. Using data from the China Family Panel Study, a Poisson regression model was applied to assess the effect of relative deprivation of income on chronically ill patients' trust. A marginal effect analysis was used to verify the effect and a two-stage least squares method was used to test robustness. Chronically ill patients' trust was at a medium level (5.98 ± 2.05). Relative deprivation of income significantly reduced patients' trust (β=-0.056, p < 0.1). The digital finance had a positive effect on patients' trust (β=0.035, p < 0.01) and alleviated the negative effect of relative deprivation of income on patients' trust (β=0.105, p < 0.01). The instrumental variable estimation results confirmed the robustness of the benchmark regression results. The inequity resulting from relative deprivation of income undermines patients' trust. Digital finance has a long-term effect on alleviating perception of inequity among chronically ill patients. The government should promote the integration of digital finance and smart healthcare to enhance patients' trust and contribute to equality in healthcare delivery. Limitations include self-reported data and an insufficient correlation between selected indicators and healthcare services.

AcceSS and Equity in Transplantation (ASSET) New Zealand: Protocol for population-wide data linkage platform to investigate equity in access to kidney failure health services in New Zealand.

BackgroundKidney transplantation is considered the ideal treatment for most people with kidney failure, conferring both survival and quality of life advantages, and is more cost effective than dialysis. Yet, current health systems may serve some people better than others, creating inequities in access to kidney failure treatments and health outcomes. AcceSS and Equity in Transplantation (ASSET) investigators aim to create a linked data platform to facilitate research enquiry into equity of health service delivery for people with kidney failure in New Zealand.MethodsThe New Zealand Ministry of Health will use patients’ National Health Index (NHI) numbers to deterministically link individual records held in existing registry and administrative health databases in New Zealand to create the data platform. The initial data linkage will include a study population of incident patients captured in the Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry (ANZDATA), New Zealand Blood Service Database and the Australia and New Zealand Living Kidney Donor Registry (ANZLKD) from 2006 to 2019 and their linked health data. Health data sources will include National Non-Admitted Patient Collection Data, National Minimum Dataset, Cancer Registry, Programme for the Integration of Mental Health Data (PRIMHD), Pharmaceutical Claims Database and Mortality Collection Database. Initial exemplar studies include 1) kidney waitlist dynamics and pathway to transplantation; 2) impact of mental illness on accessing kidney waitlist and transplantation; 3) health service use of living donors following donation.ConclusionThe AcceSS and Equity in Transplantation (ASSET) linked data platform will provide opportunity for population-based health services research to examine equity in health care delivery and health outcomes in New Zealand. It also offers potential to inform future service planning by identifying where improvements can be made in the current health system to promote equity in access to health services for those in New Zealand.

Shattering Glass Ceilings: Three Black Women Surgeons Ascend to Chairs of Departments of Surgery.

Shattering Glass Ceilings: Three Black Women Surgeons Ascend to Chairs of Departments of Surgery.

Implementation and first evaluation of a nationwide oncology navigation program.

e13532 Background: Navigation in oncology has demonstrated benefits for people at risk for or diagnosed with cancer. These include a shorter time to diagnosis and start of treatment, better adherence to recommended care, and improved quality of life. Implementing a nurse navigation program can be challenging in developing countries, especially when involving nationwide health care networks. This study describes the implementation of a pioneering oncology navigation program in Brazil. Methods: Rede D’Or São Luiz (RDSL) is Brazil's largest integrated private health care network, comprising 63 general tertiary hospitals and 50 oncology clinics in 13 states. In 2018 a comprehensive oncology navigation program was started. The first phase focused on identifying suspected or diagnosed cancer patients who attended general hospitals to improve their care coordination. A trained nurse was allocated to support each hospital, supervised by a regional nurse coordinator and physician. A web-based system was created, by the participants, to integrate data collected from all hospitals. Epidemiological, social, and clinical data were obtained, including time to establish a cancer diagnosis and start of treatment. A national virtual meeting is held every two weeks to present anonymous data, compare results, and create solutions to address national and local barriers. Results: From 2018 to 2022, a total of 25,862 potential patients were identified by the navigation program. Of these, 10,951 ended with a diagnosis of cancer. Currently 32 hospitals from 6 different cities are involved. In the beginning, most patients (38%) were identified at Inpatient Clinical Units, after a cancer diagnosis. Over time the number of patients identified at surgical and diagnostic centers increased from 365 to 589 and 282 to 542, respectively. Cancer epidemiology was comparable to Brazilian data. Most patients had breast cancer (13%), followed by prostate cancer (12%) and colon cancer (7%). These numbers were slightly different according to hospital location. The number of patients recruited at Emergency rooms is still low (9%) comparable to other facilities. A total of 2,391 patients required an inpatient treatment approach, supported by the oncology team. Conclusions: The goal of the navigation program is to reduce cancer morbidity and mortality by eliminating barriers to timely access to cancer care, which may be financial, social, logistical, or related to communication and equity of health care delivery. These results show that RDSL National Oncology Navigation Program is feasible. After this implementation phase, a comprehensive database was built to guide care coordination, and there was a shift to earlier identification of potential patients. In the future, we expect that data collected from this project may help individual patients and families but also address cancer care disparities over the country.

Acceptability, Feasibility, and Quality of Telehealth for Adolescent Health Care Delivery During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Cross-sectional Study of Patient and Family Experiences.

BackgroundData regarding the acceptability, feasibility, and quality of telehealth among adolescents and young adults (AYA) and their parents and caregivers (caregivers) are lacking.ObjectiveThe aim of this study was to assess the noninferiority of telehealth versus in-person visits by comparing acceptability with respect to efficiency, effectiveness, equity, patient-centeredness, and confidentiality.MethodsCross-sectional web-based surveys were sent to caregivers and AYA following video visits within an Adolescent Medicine subspecialty clinic in May-July 2020. Proportions of AYA and caregivers who rated telehealth as noninferior were compared using chi-squared tests. Feasibility was assessed via items measuring technical difficulties. Deductive thematic analysis using the Institute of Medicine dimensions of health care quality was used to code open-ended question responses.ResultsSurvey response rates were 20.5% (55/268) for AYA and 21.8% (123/563) for caregivers. The majority of the respondents were White cisgender females. Most AYA and caregivers rated telehealth as noninferior to in-person visits with respect to confidentiality, communication, medication management, and mental health care. A higher proportion of AYA compared to caregivers found telehealth inferior with respect to confidentiality (11/51, 22% vs 3/118, 2.5%, P<.001). One-quarter (14/55) of the AYA patients and 31.7% (39/123) of the caregivers reported technical difficulties. The dominant themes in the qualitative data included advantages of telehealth for efficiency and equity of health care delivery. However, respondents’ concerns included reduced safety and effectiveness of care, particularly for patients with eating disorders, owing to lack of hands-on examinations, collection of vital signs, and laboratory testing.ConclusionsTelehealth was highly acceptable among AYA and caregivers. Future optimization should include improving privacy, ameliorating technical difficulties, and standardizing at-home methods of obtaining patient data to assure patient safety.

Historicizing medical drones in Africa: a focus on Ghana

While the genesis of the drone technology is not clear, one thing is ideal: it emerged as a military apparatus and gained much attention during major wars, including the two world wars. Aside being used in combats and to deliver humanitarian services, drones have also been used extensively to kill both troops and civilians. Revolutionized in the 19th century, the drone technology was improved to be controlled as an unmanned aerial devices to mainly target troops. A new emerging field that has seen the application of the drone technology is the healthcare sector. Over the years, the health sector has increasingly relied on the device for timely transportation of essential articles across the globe. Since its introduction in health, scholars have attempted to address the impact of drones on healthcare across Africa and the world at large. Among other things, it has been reported by scholars that the device has the ability to overcome the menace of weather constraints, inadequate personnel and inaccessible roads within the healthcare sector. This notwithstanding, data on drones and drone application in Ghana and her healthcare sector in particular appears to be little within the drone literature. Also, few attempts have been made by scholars to highlight the use of drones in African countries. By using a narrative review approach, the current study attempts to address the gap above. Using this approach, a thorough literature search was performed to locate and assess scientific materials that focus on the application of drones in the military field and in the medical systems of Africa and Ghana in particular. With its sole responsibility to deliver items, stakeholders of health across several parts of the world have relied on drones to transport vital articles to health centers. Countries like Senegal, Madagascar, Rwanda and Malawi encouraged Ghana to consider the application of drones in her mainstream healthcare delivery. Findings from the study have revealed that Ghana’s adoption of the drone policy has enhanced the timely delivery of products such as test samples, blood and Personal Protective Equipment to various health centres and rural areas in particular. Drones have contributed to the delivery of equity in healthcare delivery in Ghana. We conclude that with the drone policy, the continent has the potential to record additional successes concerning the over-widened gap in healthcare between rural and urban populations.

Equity in clinical practice requires organisational and system-level change – The role of nurse leaders

ABSTRACT Background In the International Year of the Nurse and Midwife 2020, nurses in Australia and around the world are being encouraged to lend their voices to lead change. The COVID-19 global health crisis has highlighted the critical role of nurses in our community in ensuring that the challenges to our health care system are being met and overcome. It has also brought attention to existing health inequities in our community, in particular the poorer health of refugees, some culturally and linguistically diverse communities and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. Aim To call on nurses and nurse leaders to take greater action to improve health equity. Methods This paper presents a discussion with regard to the importance of equitable and safe clinical practice and the urgent need to address organisational and system-level barriers to the provision of equitable health care. Findings Clinicians’ abilities and capacities to provide equitable care is ultimately shaped by health care organisations and the broader historical, political, social and economic context of our community. Discussion Equity should not only be reflected in clinical practice, but also in organisational policies and procedures, embedded in key performance indicators and supported by adequate funding and resources. Conclusion Systemic inadequacies are likely to be further amplified during times when the health system is under additional pressure. Nurses and nurse leaders should take this opportunity to reflect upon the integral role they play in addressing organisational and system-level change to ensure equity in health care delivery. We call on nurse leaders and the nursing profession to lead us all to a more equitable health care system and society.

Hospital efficiency and equity in health care delivery: A study based in China

Hospital efficiency and equity in health care delivery are two enduring research topics. Yet little research has been done to examine the relationship between them. This paper studies the impact of hospital efficiency on equity in health care delivery based on a proprietary dataset of hospital characteristics and 630,000 inpatient records from 149 public hospitals in a representative Chinese city. To measure the hospitals' efficiencies, this study takes the hospitals' operational features and case-mix indexes into account, and computes the efficiency levels using data envelopment analysis with bootstrapping. Through regressions that control for a variety of the patients’ personal characteristics (e.g., age, disease, residence, hospital visit frequency), this study shows that the gap between hospitalization expenses of urban and rural inpatients in more efficient hospitals is smaller than those in less efficient hospitals. Thus efficiency enhances equity in expenditure between urban and rural patients. But the dwindling urban-rural gap in expenditure is achieved by raising the spending of rural patients, thereby undermining their access to health care. This pattern is more conspicuous in large and sophisticated high-tier hospitals. Further analysis shows that hospital efficiency impacts equity of health care delivery by inducing different lengths of stay and uncovered parts of total expenditure for urban and rural groups. The findings imply that an efficiency-oriented health care policy may lead to social benefit loss.

Advancing Social Mission in Nursing Education: Recommendations From an Expert Advisory Board

Social mission refers to a set of concepts and perspectives that promote health equity in health care delivery and within health professions. Little is known about social mission within the context of nursing education. This article clarifies the role of social mission in nursing education, offers current applications, and identifies future opportunities to maximize social mission within nursing to foster a more just culture of health. A multidisciplinary advisory board of experts in nursing education convened to review pertinent literature, current case exemplars, and craft a conceptual framework of social mission in nursing education. The resulting framework consisted of three action-oriented domains to implement social mission into nursing education: board accreditation, curriculum building and faculty training, and developing institutional culture. Successful implementation of social mission into nursing education, and subsequently the nursing workforce, offers the opportunity to further embed equity into health care. [J Nurs Educ. 2020;59(8):433-438.].