The hormonal changes of pregnancy and parturition can trigger robust changes in affective state, particularly among patients with a history of postpartum depression. However, more work is needed to elucidate the temporal dynamics of symptom emergence. The current study explored how quickly hormone-sensitive (HS+) individuals can be differentiated from hormone-insensitive (HS-) controls in the context of a tightly controlled experimental hormone manipulation, and which symptoms demonstrate the most rapid, consistent, and largest response during this protocol. Participants were female, non-pregnant, and euthymic, with a history of DSM-5 major depressive episode with peripartum onset (n = 15) or parous healthy controls with no psychiatric history (n = 15). Perinatal hormonal changes were simulated by inducing hypogonadism, adding back estradiol (E2) and progesterone (P4) to reach first-trimester levels for 8 weeks, and then subsequently withdrawing both hormones. Those reporting a 30% or greater increase during addback or withdrawal on select subscales of the Inventory of Depression and Anxiety Symptoms (IDAS) were identified as HS+. Participants provided daily ratings of symptoms throughout the study via the Daily Record of Severity of Problems. Results indicated that HS+ participants could be differentiated from HS- participants early in the hormone protocol, with many symptoms showing significantly greater change from baseline within the first week of addback. Notably, the most rapid symptom increases were observed for Anger/Irritability, Mood Swings, Overwhelm, Lethargy, Increased Appetite, Joint and Muscle Pain, and Breast Tenderness, reaching 50% of peak group contrast within the first week of hormone addback. The largest group effects were observed for Anger/Irritability, followed by Fatigue and Anxiety, and the most consistent group effects were observed for Anger/Irritability, Interpersonal Conflict, Overwhelm, and Hopelessness. Findings support the role of reproductive hormones in the onset of perinatal affective disorders. The rapid emergence of anger and irritability in HS+ participants suggests that these symptoms may be early indicators of perinatal hormone sensitivity.