Patient-reported functioning and symptoms are an important component of evaluating orthopedic surgery outcomes. Most joint replacement registries suggest collecting joint-specific and general symptoms, functioning, and health-related quality of life PRO measures. Orthopedic-focused researchers have begun to incorporate PROMIS modules, which presents an opportunity to evaluate the performance of “legacy” joint-specific PROs. Beginning in June 2018, all patients scheduled for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) were sent the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcomes Score – short form (KOOS Jr), PROMIS-Global Health Physical subscale (GH-P), and PROMIS-Physical Functioning (PF) questionnaires through the MyChart website portal at the time of scheduling (i.e., pre-operative) and then at pre-defined post-operative timepoints. Patient responses were collated and reviewed through an Epic database. Pre-operative and post-operative scores were evaluated for distributions, correlations, and change scores within and between measures. One hundred fourteen TKA patients activated on MyChart who answered all pre-operative questionnaires were included in the analysis. Score distributions were generally parametric, with the KOOS Jr showing slightly higher tailedness than the two PROMIS modules. Mean pre-op scores for the KOOS Jr, GH-P, and PF were 51.2 (SD: 12.43), 39.2 (5.02), and 42.7 (6.22), respectively. Correlations between all three measures were good, ranging from r = 0.628 to 0.678. Mean score changes were 15.1 (SD: 14.04) for the KOOS Jr, 2.0 (8.87) for the GH-P, and 1.5 (5.32) for the PF at an average of 94.0 days post-operation. Two patients reported maximum scores of 100 on the KOOS Jr. Correlations and score changes recorded by TKA patients on three PRO measures were similar to recently published results. While the range of pre-op and post-op KOOS Jr scores are much higher and indicative of a ceiling effect, analyses suggest the legacy joint-specific questionnaire is assessing TKA-related impacts on functioning in a manner similar to two PROMIS modules.