Entanglement Scaling Research Articles

Universal Time-Entanglement Trade-Off in Open Quantum Systems

We demonstrate a surprising connection between pure steady-state entanglement and relaxation time scales in an extremely broad class of Markovian open systems, where two (possibly many-body) systems, A and B, interact locally with a common dissipative environment. This setup also encompasses a broad class of adaptive quantum dynamics based on continuous measurement and feedback. As steady-state entanglement increases, there is generically an emergent strong symmetry that leads to a dynamical slow-down. Using this, we can prove rigorous bounds on relaxation times set by steady-state entanglement. We also find that this time must necessarily diverge for maximal entanglement. To test our bound, we consider the dynamics of a random ensemble of local Lindbladians that support pure steady states, finding that the bound does an excellent job of predicting how the dissipative gap varies with the amount of entanglement. Our work provides general insights into how dynamics and entanglement are connected in open systems and has specific relevance to quantum reservoir engineering. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Fluctuation-dissipation theorem and entanglement dynamics in one-dimensional low-density Jaynes-Cummings Hubbard model after a quench.

In one-dimensional low-density Jaynes-Cummings Hubbard (JCH) models [Phys. Rev. E 106, 064107 (2022)2470-004510.1103/PhysRevE.106.064107], we proved that the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) is valid when the tunneling strength and coupling strength are of the same order. Surprisingly, at the weak tunneling limit, we observed that the entanglement entropy and scaling law of kinetic energy operators also exhibit obvious quantum chaotic properties, this is an unexpected result. To substantiate these findings, we further discuss their nonequilibrium dynamics in this paper. Our analysis reveals that when the model is a weak tunneling limit after the quench and the initial state is an equilibrium state of chaos, the system reaches an equilibrium state. This observation supports the conclusion that the low-density JCH model at the weak tunneling limit is nonintegrable, corroborating our previous results [Phys. Rev. E 106, 064107 (2022)2470-004510.1103/PhysRevE.106.064107]. Additionally, by discussing the validity of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) and the evolution behavior of entanglement entropy and fidelity, we numerically demonstrate the differences between the one-dimensional low-density JCH model and general nonintegrable systems. Specifically, in the low-density JCH model, when the Hamiltonian after the quench is integrable, the validity of FDT depends on the thermal behavior of the initial Hamiltonian, and a metastable state is observed during the evolution of entanglement entropy. Our research presents an an intriguing and unique nonintegrable model, enriching the current understanding of nonintegrable systems.

Entanglement Dynamics in Monitored Systems and the Role of Quantum Jumps

Monitored quantum many-body systems display a rich pattern of entanglement dynamics, which is unique to this nonunitary setting. This work studies the effect of quantum jumps on the entanglement dynamics beyond the no-click limit corresponding to a deterministic non-Hermitian evolution. To this aim, we introduce a new tool that looks at the statistics of entanglement-entropy gain and loss after and in between quantum jumps. This insight allows us to build a simple stochastic model of a random walk with partial resetting, which reproduces the entanglement dynamics, and to dissect the mutual role of jumps and non-Hermitian evolution on the entanglement scaling. We apply these ideas to the study of measurement-induced transitions in monitored fermions. We demonstrate that significant deviations from the no-click limit arise whenever quantum jumps strongly renormalize the non-Hermitian dynamics, as in the case of models with U(1) symmetry at weak monitoring. On the other hand, we show that the weak-monitoring phase of the Ising chain leads to a robust subvolume logarithmic phase due to weakly renormalized non-Hermitian dynamics. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Probing entanglement in a 2D hard-core Bose-Hubbard lattice.

Entanglement and its propagation are central to understanding many physical properties of quantum systems1-3. Notably, within closed quantum many-body systems, entanglement is believed to yield emergent thermodynamic behaviour4-7. However, a universal understanding remains challenging owing to the non-integrability and computational intractability of most large-scale quantum systems. Quantum hardware platforms provide a means to study the formation and scaling of entanglement in interacting many-body systems8-14. Here we use a controllable 4 × 4 array of superconducting qubits to emulate a 2D hard-core Bose-Hubbard (HCBH) lattice. We generate superposition states by simultaneously driving all lattice sites and extract correlation lengths and entanglement entropy across its many-body energy spectrum. We observe volume-law entanglement scaling for states at the centre of the spectrum and a crossover to the onset of area-law scaling near its edges.

A two-tensor model with order-three

We construct a two-tensor model with order-3 and present its W-representation. Moreover we derive the compact expressions of correlators from the W-representation and analyze the free energy in large N limit. In addition, we establish the correspondence between two colored Dyck walks in the Fredkin spin chain and tree operators in the ring. Based on the classification Dyck walks, we give the number of tree operators with the given level. Furthermore, we show the entanglement scaling of Fredkin spin chain beyond logarithmic scaling in the ordinary critical systems from the viewpoint of tensor model.

Emergent Conformal Boundaries from Finite-Entanglement Scaling in Matrix Product States.

The use of finite entanglement scaling with matrix product states (MPS) has become a crucial tool for studying one-dimensional critical lattice theories, especially those with emergent conformal symmetry. We argue that finite entanglement introduces a relevant deformation in the critical theory. As a result, the bipartite entanglement Hamiltonian defined from the MPS can be understood as a boundary conformal field theory with a physical and an entanglement boundary. We are able to exploit the symmetry properties of the MPS to engineer the physical conformal boundary condition. The entanglement boundary, on the other hand, is related to the concrete lattice model and remains invariant under this relevant perturbation. Using critical lattice models described by the Ising, Potts, and free compact boson conformal field theories, we illustrate the influence of the symmetry and the relevant deformation on the conformal boundaries in the entanglement spectrum.

Operational Metric for Quantum Chaos and the Corresponding Spatiotemporal-Entanglement Structure

Chaotic systems are highly sensitive to a small perturbation and are ubiquitous throughout the biological sciences, the physical sciences, and even the social sciences. Taking this as the underlying principle, we construct an operational notion for quantum chaos. Namely, we demand that the future state of a many-body isolated quantum system is sensitive to past multitime operations on a small subpart of that system. By “sensitive,” we mean that the resultant states from two different perturbations cannot easily be transformed into each other. That is, the pertinent quantity is the complexity of the effect of the perturbation within the final state. From this intuitive metric, which we call the butterfly-flutter fidelity, we use the language of multitime quantum processes to identify a series of operational conditions on chaos; in particular, the scaling of the spatiotemporal entanglement. Our criteria already contain the routine notions, as well as the well-known diagnostics for quantum chaos. This includes the Peres-Loschmidt echo, dynamical entropy, tripartite mutual information, and local-operator entanglement. We hence present a unified framework for these existing diagnostics within a single structure. We also go on to quantify how several mechanisms, such as evolution generated from random circuits, lead to quantum chaos. Our work paves the way to systematically study many-body dynamical phenomena such as many-body localization, measurement-induced phase transitions, and Floquet dynamics. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Absence of logarithmic enhancement in the entanglement scaling of free fermions on folded cubes

This study investigates the scaling behavior of the ground-state entanglement entropy in a model of free fermions on folded cubes. An analytical expression is derived in the large-diameter limit, revealing a strict adherence to the area law. The absence of the logarithmic enhancement expected for free fermions is explained using a decomposition of folded cubes in chains based on its Terwilliger algebra and . The entanglement Hamiltonian and its relation to Heun operators are also investigated.

Validating Phase-Space Methods with Tensor Networks in Two-Dimensional Spin Models with Power-Law Interactions.

Using a recently developed extension of the time-dependent variational principle for matrix product states, we evaluate the dynamics of 2D power-law interacting XXZ models, implementable in a variety of state-of-the-art experimental platforms. We compute the spin squeezing as a measure of correlations in the system, and compare to semiclassical phase-space calculations utilizing the discrete truncated Wigner approximation (DTWA). We find the latter efficiently and accurately captures the scaling of entanglement with system size in these systems, despite the comparatively resource-intensive tensor network representation of the dynamics. We also compare the steady-state behavior of DTWA to thermal ensemble calculations with tensor networks. Our results open a way to benchmark dynamical calculations for two-dimensional quantum systems, and allow us to rigorously validate recent predictions for the generation of scalable entangled resources for metrology in these systems.

Entanglement propagation and dynamics in non-additive quantum systems

The prominent collective character of long-range interacting quantum systems makes them promising candidates for quantum technological applications. Yet, lack of additivity overthrows the traditional picture for entanglement scaling and transport, due to the breakdown of the common mechanism based on excitations propagation and confinement. Here, we describe the dynamics of the entanglement entropy in many-body quantum systems with a diverging contribution to the internal energy from the long-range two body potential. While in the strict thermodynamic limit entanglement dynamics is shown to be suppressed, a rich mosaic of novel scaling regimes is observed at intermediate system sizes, due to the possibility to trigger multiple resonant modes in the global dynamics. Quantitative predictions on the shape and timescales of entanglement propagation are made, paving the way to the observation of these phases in current quantum simulators. This picture is connected and contrasted with the case of local many body systems subject to Floquet driving.

Channeling Quantum Criticality.

We analyze the effect of decoherence, modeled by local quantum channels, on quantum critical states and we find universal properties of the resulting mixed state's entanglement, both between system and environment and within the system. Renyi entropies exhibit volume law scaling with a subleading constant governed by a "g function" in conformal field theory, allowing us to define a notion of renormalization group (RG) flow (or "phase transitions") between quantum channels. We also find that the entropy of a subsystem in the decohered state has a subleading logarithmic scaling with subsystem size, and we relate it to correlation functions of boundary condition changing operators in the conformal field theory. Finally, we find that the subsystem entanglement negativity, a measure of quantum correlations within mixed states, can exhibit log scaling or area law based on the RG flow. When the channel corresponds to a marginal perturbation, the coefficient of the log scaling can change continuously with decoherence strength. We illustrate all these possibilities for the critical ground state of the transverse-field Ising model, in which we identify four RG fixed points of dephasing channels and verify the RG flow numerically. Our results are relevant to quantum critical states realized on noisy quantum simulators, in which our predicted entanglement scaling can be probed via shadow tomography methods.

Logarithmic, fractal and volume-law entanglement in a Kitaev chain with long-range hopping and pairing

Thanks to their prominent collective character, long-range interactions promote information spreading and generate forms of entanglement scaling, which cannot be observed in traditional systems with local interactions. In this work, we study the asymptotic behavior of the entanglement entropy for Kitaev chains with long-range hopping and pairing couplings decaying with a power law of the distance. We provide a fully-fledged analytical and numerical characterization of the asymptotic growth of the ground state entanglement in the large subsystem size limit, finding that the truly non-local nature of the model leads to an extremely rich phenomenology. Most significantly, in the strong long-range regime, we discovered that the system ground state may have a logarithmic, fractal, or volume-law entanglement scaling, depending on the value of the chemical potential and on the strength of the power law decay.

Entanglement complexity of the Rokhsar-Kivelson-sign wavefunctions

Entanglement comes in different forms, some more complex than others. In this paper we study the transitions of entanglement complexity in an exemplary family of states---the Rokhsar-Kivelson-sign wavefunctions---whose degree of entanglement is controlled by a single parameter. This family of states is known to feature a transition between a phase exhibiting volume-law scaling of entanglement entropy and a phase with subextensive scaling of entanglement, reminiscent of the many-body-localization transition of disordered quantum Hamiltonians. We study the singularities of the Rokhsar-Kivelson-sign wavefunctions and their entanglement complexity across the transition using several tools from quantum information theory: fidelity metric, entanglement spectrum statistics, entanglement entropy fluctuations, stabilizer R\'enyi entropy, and the performance of a disentangling algorithm. Across the whole volume-law phase the states feature universal entanglement spectrum statistics. Yet a ``superuniversal'' regime appears for small values of the control parameter in which all metrics become independent of the parameter itself, the entanglement entropy as well as the stabilizer R\'enyi entropy appear to approach their theoretical maximum, the entanglement fluctuations scale to zero as in output states of random universal circuits, and the disentangling algorithm has essentially null efficiency. All these indicators consistently reveal a complex pattern of entanglement. In the sub-volume-law phase, on the other hand, the entanglement spectrum statistics is no longer universal, entanglement fluctuations are larger and exhibiting a nonuniversal scaling, and the efficiency of the disentangling algorithm becomes finite. Our results, based on model wavefunctions, suggest that a similar combination of entanglement scaling properties and of entanglement complexity features may be found in high-energy Hamiltonian eigenstates---a very strong candidate being offered by the many-body localization transition of disordered lattice-spin models.

Charge fluctuation and charge-resolved entanglement in a monitored quantum circuit with U(1) symmetry

We study a ($1+1$)-dimensional quantum circuit consisting of Haar-random unitary gates and projective measurements, both of which conserve a total $U(1)$ charge and thus have $U(1)$ symmetry. In addition to a measurement-induced entanglement transition between a volume-law and an area-law entangled phase, we find a phase transition between two phases characterized by bipartite charge fluctuation growing with the subsystem size or staying constant. At this charge-fluctuation transition, steady-state quantities obtained by evolving an initial state with a definitive total charge exhibit critical scaling behaviors akin to Tomonaga-Luttinger-liquid theory for equilibrium critical quantum systems with $U(1)$ symmetry, such as logarithmic scaling of bipartite charge fluctuation, power-law decay of charge correlation functions, and logarithmic scaling of charge-resolved entanglement whose coefficient becomes a universal quadratic function in a flux parameter. These critical features, however, do not persist below the transition, in contrast to a recent prediction based on replica field theory and mapping to a classical statistical mechanical model.

Logarithmic entanglement scaling in dissipative free-fermion systems

We study the quantum information spreading in one-dimensional free-fermion systems in the presence of localized thermal baths. We employ a nonlocal Lindblad master equation to describe the system-bath interaction, in the sense that the Lindblad operators are written in terms of the Bogoliubov operators of the closed system, and hence are nonlocal in space. The statistical ensemble describing the steady state is written in terms of a convex combination of the Fermi-Dirac distributions of the baths. Due to the singularity of the free-fermion dispersion, the steady-state mutual information exhibits singularities as a function of the system parameters. While the mutual information generically satisfies an area law, at the singular points it exhibits logarithmic scaling as a function of subsystem size. By employing the Fisher-Hartwig theorem, we derive the prefactor of the logarithmic scaling, which depends on the parameters of the baths and plays the role of an effective "central charge". This is upper bounded by the central charge governing ground-state entanglement scaling. We provide numerical checks of our results in the paradigmatic tight-binding chain and the Kitaev chain.

Entanglement scaling for λϕ24

We study the $\ensuremath{\lambda}{\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ model in $0+2$ dimensions at criticality, focusing on the scaling properties originating from the UV and IR physics. We demonstrate that the entanglement entropy, the correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and order parameters $\ensuremath{\phi}$ and ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{3}$ exhibit distinctive double scaling properties that prove a powerful tool in the data analysis. The calculations are performed with boundary matrix product state methods on tensor network representations of the partition function to which the entanglement scaling hypothesis is applied, though the technique is equally applicable outside the realm of tensor networks. We find the value ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{c}=11.09698(31)$ for the critical point, improving on previous results.

Entanglement and Charge-Sharpening Transitions in U(1) Symmetric Monitored Quantum Circuits

Monitored quantum circuits can exhibit an entanglement transition as a function of the rate of measurements, stemming from the competition between scrambling unitary dynamics and disentangling projective measurements. We study how entanglement dynamics in non-unitary quantum circuits can be enriched in the presence of charge conservation, using a combination of exact numerics and a mapping onto a statistical mechanics model of constrained hard-core random walkers. We uncover a charge-sharpening transition that separates different scrambling phases with volume-law scaling of entanglement, distinguished by whether measurements can efficiently reveal the total charge of the system. We find that while R\'enyi entropies grow sub-ballistically as $\sqrt{t}$ in the absence of measurement, for even an infinitesimal rate of measurements, all average R\'enyi entropies grow ballistically with time $\sim t$. We study numerically the critical behavior of the charge-sharpening and entanglement transitions in U(1) circuits, and show that they exhibit emergent Lorentz invariance and can also be diagnosed using scalable local ancilla probes. Our statistical mechanical mapping technique readily generalizes to arbitrary Abelian groups, and offers a general framework for studying dissipatively-stabilized symmetry-breaking and topological orders.

Field Theory of Charge Sharpening in Symmetric Monitored Quantum Circuits.

Monitored quantum circuits (MRCs) exhibit a measurement-induced phase transition between area-law and volume-law entanglement scaling. MRCs with a conserved charge additionally exhibit two distinct volume-law entangled phases that cannot be characterized by equilibrium notions of symmetry-breaking or topological order, but rather by the nonequilibrium dynamics and steady-state distribution of charge fluctuations. These include a charge-fuzzy phase in which charge information is rapidly scrambled leading to slowly decaying spatial fluctuations of charge in the steady state, and a charge-sharp phase in which measurements collapse quantum fluctuations of charge without destroying the volume-law entanglement of neutral degrees of freedom. By taking a continuous-time, weak-measurement limit, we construct a controlled replica field theory description of these phases and their intervening charge-sharpening transition in one spatial dimension. We find that the charge fuzzy phase is a critical phase with continuously evolving critical exponents that terminates in a modified Kosterlitz-Thouless transition to the short-range correlated charge-sharp phase. We numerically corroborate these scaling predictions also hold for discrete-time projective-measurement circuit models using large-scale matrix-product state simulations, and discuss generalizations to higher dimensions.

Monitoring-induced entanglement entropy and sampling complexity

The dynamics of open quantum systems is generally described by a master equation, which describes the loss of information into the environment. By using a simple model of uncoupled emitters, we illustrate how the recovery of this information depends on the monitoring scheme applied to register the decay clicks. The dissipative dynamics, in this case, is described by pure-state stochastic trajectories and we examine different unravelings of the same master equation. More precisely, we demonstrate how registering the sequence of clicks from spontaneously emitted photons through a linear optical interferometer induces entanglement in the trajectory states. Since this model consists of an array of single-photon emitters, we show a direct equivalence with Fock-state boson sampling and link the hardness of sampling the outcomes of the quantum jumps with the scaling of trajectory entanglement.

Entanglement transitions from stochastic resetting of non-Hermitian quasiparticles

We put forward a phenomenological theory for entanglement dynamics in monitored quantum many-body systems with well-defined quasiparticles. Within this theory entanglement is carried by ballistically propagating non-Hermitian quasiparticles which are stochastically reset by the measurement protocol with rate given by their finite inverse lifetime. We write down a renewal equation for the statistics of the entanglement entropy and show that depending on the spectrum of quasiparticle decay rates different entanglement scaling can arise and even sharp entanglement phase transitions. When applied to a Quantum Ising chain where the transverse magnetization is measured by quantum jumps, our theory predicts a critical phase with logarithmic scaling of the entanglement, an area law phase and a continuous phase transition between them, with an effective central charge vanishing as a square root at the transition point. We compare these predictions with with exact numerical calculations on the same model and find an excellent agreement.