E D I T O R IA L R E V IE W : E N G L IS H S T U D IE S A T T O R O N T O -Lhe beginning of all wisdom is to look fixedly on clothes, says Herr Professor Teufelsdrockh, brooding, nevertheless, about certain Gouda cows in pyjamas. Pondering the Toronto crest on my jacket with its tree and its motto, velut arbor cevo, I am bemused about which Toronto it symbolically figures forth, which twigs of the tree or rings of its bark. For me, but perhaps not for others, it summons aus der Ewigkeit University College, the Combined Department of English, and Honour English Language and Literature at their peak. I entered as a freshman in 1949 and received my doctorate in 1959, in the meantime having become a professor myself (indeed, after passing the old-style ‘general examinations,’ I must have felt that I had become, like Teufelsdrockh himself, a Professor der Allerley-Wissenschaft, or as we should say in English, ‘Professor of Things in General’) . It is not just a Thackerayan nostalgia for youth that makes me think that was a splendid place and time, nor the fact that economi cally it was very doubtful I should be able to be there at all and that I therefore lapped it up — though these sentiments no doubt have their weight. As Robin Harris’s new book, English Studies at Toronto: A History,* makes clear, that decade was a flowering of admirable tendencies that had been maturing in Toronto for over half a century and that would within less than another decade be wrecked and swept aside by Maoism, bigness, and business efficiency. Harris doesn’t say so. He is learned, thorough, objective, and temperate — though the occasional sentence has a faintly apocalyptic ring to it: “The English Language and Literature course was no more.” For all of us in English, and especially for those interested in what is, or was, distinctively Canadian about our teaching of the subject, this is a very impor tant book. As Harris’s statistics make clear, a significant number of the pro fessorial staff at Toronto were themselves graduates of a Toronto honour course (in 1945, two-thirds of the staff). These people in their turn, since Toronto until the sixties had the only fully developed graduate school for * Robin S. Harris, English Studies at Toronto: A History (Toronto: Governing Council, University of Toronto, 1988). xvi, 310. $25.00. E n g l is h Stu d ie s in C an ad a , x iv , 3, September 1988 English, taught a very large proportion of the people who staffed the English departments of other Canadian universities. The Toronto department under A. S. P. Woodhouse, or Woodhouse himself, was virtually the main employ ment agency for the rest of the country — others might use the analogy of the Colonial Office sending emissaries to man the outposts of empire. Observers less admiring of our powers used to call us ‘the dead hand of Toronto.’ As the Gargantua of Canadian universities, the sheer number of doctorates it has awarded is impressive. Between 1920 and 1984 it graduated 492 Ph.D.’s to the rest of the country’s (eighteen other institutions’) 739 — the closest was Al berta with 84. Toronto’s weighty presence, as supplier of staff, as model, or as bugbear, is clearly significant. Significance, as Teufelsdrockh would remind us, is not simply a matter of statistics and machinery. Ultimately it is the people, what they think, say, and write, that make a university significant. Toronto has been fortunate in them. Alexander, Woodhouse, Frye, Barker, Priestley, McLuhan, Grant, Coburn have had an obvious and powerful influence as minds in our country and abroad, not to mention those who have flourished after my distinguished dec ade : Wilson, Robson, Grosskurth, Leggatt, the Millgates . . . I leave off with a mere beginning of the list. At biographical interest, however, Harris draws the line. He is describing an institution, and he deals with people as they affect the institution or flourish as its ornaments. A good deal of character comes across, particularly where individuals, such as Alexander and Woodhouse...
Read full abstract