(1) A NEW edition of “Shipley and MacBride” will receive a welcome from students and teachers of zoology, for the original work published in 1901-took at once a distinct place among text-books on account of the freshness and individuality of the authors' method. The present volume exceeds in length its forerunner by 100 pages, and many improvements have been introduced. For example, the groups of the flatworms, nemertines, rotifers, and nematodes have been brought from their former position at the end of the volume following after the mammalia, and placed before the annelida. The arrangement, which startled readers of the first and second editions, was intended to emphasise the authors' opinion that these groups are not coelomata, and this opinion is still set forth, perhaps too dogmatically, in the clear “Introduction to the Coelomata” that precedes immediately the account of the annelids. The authors have accepted Goodrich's distinction-now familiar to zoologists-between true nephridia and ccelomo-ducts(such as the excretory tubes of arthropods, molluscs, and vertebrates). They also revert to the “orthodox” interpretation of the mammalian ear-ossicles, and in connection with this problem supply a valuable diagram of the temporal region of the skull in theromorphous reptiles for comparison with the mammalia. The book still neglects, to a great extent, palaeontological as well as embryological facts, but these are invoked where questions of morphology and relationship are discussed. Indeed, the last half of the volume comprises an excellent introduction to the comparative anatomy of vertebrates. As regards systems of classification, there is always room for differences of opinion, but we believe that most students of the Mollusca will object to the removal of the Chitons from association with Chaetoderma and Neomenia, and their replacement in the Gastropoda; while among the arthropods, the unnatural group of the “Myriapoda” is still retained, and appears in the same class with the insects and the peripatids-an altogether indefensible association. The introduction has been lengthened by two pages for the inclusion of a necessarily imperfect sketch of recent work on heredity. (1) Zoology: An Elementary Text-Book. By Dr. A. E. Shipley Dr. E. W. MacBride. Third edition. Pp. xx + 752.(Cambridge: At the University Press, 1915.) Price 12s. 6d. net. (2) Elementary Text-book of Economic Zoology and Entomology. By Prof. V. L. Kellogg Prof. R. W. Doane. Pp. x + 532.(New York: H. Holt and Co., 1915.) Price 1.50 dollars.
Read full abstract