In popular culture, two narratives have emerged about people with intersex conditions: female athletes being subjected to sex verification tests and adults born with ambiguous genitalia who had surgery as infants and were not satisfied with the long-term outcomes. A number of scholarly articles critique policy aimed at international calibre athletes who have or have been suspected of having one particular intersex condition (hyperandrogenism). What is missing is the voice of the athletes themselves. Framed within feminist cultural studies and transfeminism, our case study explored the experiences of a U.S. university athlete with an intersex condition. Amanda (a pseudonym), who has congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), competes in U.S. University NCAA Division III soccer. She participated in a semi-structured interview and follow-up e-mail discussion framed using narrative and life history approaches. Our narrative analysis identified three overarching themes presented as vignettes: The Medical Side of CAH tells of her experiences with medical personnel and her treatment. In Personal Experience with CAH Amanda addresses how she manages the discourse surrounding her CAH. The final vignette, the Sporting Experience vignette describes her sport involvement as an athlete with CAH. Overall, Amanda’s experiences are very different from international athletes with intersex conditions whose stories have been revealed in the popular press and other individuals with intersex conditions who were dismayed with their medical treatment.