Reviewed by: Jonathan Swift—Autor von "Gulliver's Travels," Regierungspublizist, irischer Patriot und Querdenker der Aufklärung. Ein essayistisches Porträt (Jonathan Swift—Author of "Gulliver's Travels," Government Journalist, Hibernian Patriot, and Maverick Thinker of the Enlightenment. An Essayistic Portrait) by Heinz-Joachim Müllenbrock Hermann Josef Real Heinz-Joachim Müllenbrock. Jonathan Swift—Autor von "Gulliver's Travels," Regierungspublizist, irischer Patriot und Querdenker der Aufklärung. Ein essayistisches Porträt (Jonathan Swift—Author of "Gulliver's Travels," Government Journalist, Hibernian Patriot, and Maverick Thinker of the Enlightenment. An Essayistic Portrait) Marburg: Blaues Schloss, 2015. Pp. 47. €8.60. How does one introduce an iridescent, enigmatic figure like the Dean of St. Patrick's, [End Page 180] Dublin, and his multivolume, multilayered work to lay readers expectantly assembled at a soirée in such a way that they will feel tempted, or challenged, or provoked to go on reading him beyond versions of Gulliver's Travels for children or adolescents? The answer, in addition to having THE Dean, the only Dean in the history of Ireland, at one's fingertips, is that one needs to choose wisely. Both criteria are met by Mr. Müllenbrock, who not only shows himself in full command of his material, primary as well as secondary, but who also skillfully lays his groundwork. Having started off with the comic fantasy of Gulliver's first two voyages, he enlarges on the humorous elements pervading Swift's early satires such as A Tale of a Tub, The Battle of the Books, and the Bickerstaff hoax. Mr. Müllenbrock proceeds to flesh out his subsequent framework with elements of Swift's more combative and at times even aggressive ad hominem satire. These early examples culminate in the paradoxical virtuosity of An Argument against Abolishing Christianity and, during Swift's time as chef de propagande for the Tory administration under Robert Harley, in The Examiner's relentless attacks against the whiggish opposition's campaign to continue the War of the Spanish Succession spearheaded by the Duke of Marlborough. After a silence of some ten years in his self-styled Irish "exile," the Dean's volcanic temper flared up again several times in the 1720s, more particularly in the saeva indignatio of Travels, and A Modest Proposal, both impelled by Swift's self-image as a satirist. Mr. Müllenbrock rightly emphasizes the intellectual and moral paradoxes of A Modest Proposal, by which Swift put the inhuman indifference of English mercantilist politics toward the misery of Ireland—and Irish folly in endorsing the very means of its own destruction—rhetorically as well as symbolically in the dock at the same time. Five years earlier, in Gulliver's voyage to the Houyhnhnms, Swift had kicked against the pricks of another, anthropological orthodoxy in an even more fundamental way, humankind's proud and boastful belief in its essential rationality. By making horses the physical manifestations of reason and their visitor, l'homme moyen Gulliver, a Yahoo-like animal, Swift flies in the face of the emerging Enlightenment ideal. However, the Houyhnhnms cannot be regarded as Swift's norm, either. When Gulliver tries to live a life of reason, the consequences are disastrous: he becomes mad and ceases to exist as a social human being. Mr. Müllenbrock's subtly argued, elegantly printed, and nicely illustrated summation of Swift's satires is to be wished every success at the counter. Hermann Josef Real Universität Münster Copyright © 2017 Roy S. Wolper, W. B. Gerard, E. Derek Taylor, and David F. Venturo
Read full abstract