Quantification of the stable isotopes within a compound aids forensic investigations as it provides a fingerprint which can determine that compound's source substrates, synthetic route, and possible mechanisms of degradation. Previous stable isotope studies have explored 13C and 2H measurements of the sarin precursors methylphosphonic dichloride (DC) and methylphosphonic difluoride (DF) as forensic signatures. However, these measurements required different sample preparations and measurement techniques. Orbitrap isotope ratio mass spectrometry (Orbitrap-IRMS) is a developing technique which can characterize multiple stable isotopes simultaneously. Here, we apply Orbitrap-IRMS to simultaneously observe the 13C and 2H content of methylphosphonic acid (MPA), the hydrolysis product of DC and DF, which can be used as a proxy for the isotopic content of DC and DF. Our method requires 20 min analyses and consumes ≈60 nmol of sample, with precisions of ≈0.9 ‰ (13C) and ≈3.6 ‰ (2H). We apply our method to both commercially acquired MPA and MPA obtained from the hydrolysis of commercially acquired DC. We validate our methods via comparison to elemental-analyzer isotope ratio mass spectrometry (EA-IRMS). The combined 13C and 2H measurement creates a more robust forensic tool than either isotope individually. Our results demonstrate the viability of Orbitrap-IRMS for chemical forensic measurements.