Electronic Transport Properties Research Articles

First-principles study of the electron and phonon transport properties in monolayer boron monosulfide

Abstract Motivated by the excellent electronic properties of theoretical proposed monolayer boron monosulfides (BS) binary materials, which belong to a light-element member of the group IIIA chalcogenides family, we have investigated the electron and phonon transport properties of three monolayer phases of BS (α, β and γ) using first-principles and Boltzmann transport theory methods. The calculated electronic structures show that α- and β-BS are semiconductors with indirect bandgaps of 4.01 eV and 3.87 eV, respectively, whereas the γ-BS is a semiconductor with a direct bandgap of 2.97 eV. Additionally, due to their light carrier effective masses, superior high carrier mobilities are observed, thus bringing high Seebeck coefficients. We also find that due to the absence of imaginary phonon frequencies, the three monolayer phases of BS show dynamical stability. The phonon group velocity and relaxation time are also calculated to analyze the phonon thermal conductivity. We find that strong phonon scattering makes γ-BS monolayer possess extremely low phonon thermal conductivity (1.2 and 2.7 Wm−1K−1 along the x and y directions at 300 K, respectively), whereas α- and β-BS monolayers show a relatively high phonon thermal conductivity. Therefore, the highest predicted ZT value of 1.7 ( n -type) at 700 K is obtained for monolayer γ-BS along the x direction. However, α- and β-BS monolayers have extremely low ZT values. Our results reveal that the γ-BS monolayer has wider promising applications in high performance thermoelectric material than α- and β-BS monolayers.

Electrical conductivity of warm dense hydrogen from Ohm’s law and time-dependent density functional theory

Abstract Understanding the electrical conductivity of warm dense hydrogen is critical for both fundamental physics and applications in planetary science and inertial confinement fusion. We demonstrate how to calculate the electrical conductivity using the continuum form of Ohm’s law, with the current density obtained from real-time time-dependent density functional theory. This approach simulates the dynamic response of hydrogen under warm dense matter conditions, with temperatures around 30,000 K and mass densities ranging from 0.02 to 0.98 g/cm³. We systematically address finite-size errors in real-time time-dependent density functional theory, demonstrating that our calculations are both numerically feasible and reliable. Our results show good agreement with other approaches, highlighting the effectiveness of this method for modeling electronic transport properties from ambient to extreme conditions.

First-principles studies of strain-tunable InN monolayer: applications for switching and optoelectronic devices

Abstract Two-dimensional (2D) materials are attracting significant attention for their potential applications in the post-Moore era. In this work, we systematically investigate the effect of strains on the electronic structure, transport and optoelectronic properties of 2D Indium nitride (InN) monolayer using density functional theory and non-equilibrium Green’s function methods. The results show that strains can modulate the electronic properties. Specifically, biaxial strain triggers the transition from semiconductor to metal and indirect to direct band gap. On this basis, the constructed InN-based nanodevice exhibits current switching ratios up to 1010. In addition, the optoelectronic device based on InN monolayer exhibits a robust photoelectric response in the red light. Meanwhile, biaxial strain can improve the optoelectronic performance of InN-based optoelectronic devices. The compressive strains blue-shift the photocurrent peaks of the InN monolayer, which effectively modulates its detection range in the visible light region. These findings underscore the potential applications in nanotechnology, particularly in nano-switches and optoelectronic devices.

Electron transport and quantum phase transitions in cumulene-connected C80H20 fulleryne: DFT and tight-binding studies

Molecular bridges are opening up exciting new applications in diverse fields, improving the efficiency of conductive inks, enhancing the performance of devices such as organic light-emitting diodes and low-cost solar cells, and advancing the development of highly sensitive sensors, chemical reactions, drug delivery systems, and more. In this paper, we study the electron transport properties of a C80H20 fulleryne (dodecahedryne) connected to two cumulene electrodes. Using density functional theory (DFT), we determine the optimal molecular bridge structure. Based on the IR vibration spectra, different stable phases of the molecular bridge are obtained. The corresponding tight-binding (TB) parameters of the cage are obtained by assigning appropriate values of the length and type of bonds for the fulleryne cage through matching the HOMO-LUMO gap between the DFT calculations and the TB parameters. The electron transport for the desired structures is investigated using the obtained tight-binding parameters and the non-equilibrium Green's function (NEGF) method. Finally, it is concluded that among the five possible configurations for the cumulene-dodecahedryne -cumulene molecular bridge, only one specific configuration—where the electrodes are one edge apart—exhibits metallic behavior, while other positions act as insulators. In addition, the system exhibits quantum phase transitions from metal to semiconductor and from insulator to metal in the presence of critical electric fields. The ability to control quantum phase transitions in these molecular systems can be leveraged to develop qubits for quantum computing. The unique properties can be utilized to design advanced molecular electronic devices.

Volatile Additive Assists Binary Layer‐by‐Layer Solution Processing Organic Solar Cells to Achieve 19% Efficiency

Comprehensive SummaryLayer‐by‐layer (LbL) solution processing is an efficient method to realize high performance organic solar cells (OSCs). One of the drawbacks of the LbL‐processed active layer is the large difference in the crystallinity of the donor and acceptor, which will lead to imbalance charge transfer and result in unfavorable charge recombination. Herein, we combined a novel volatile additive 3,5‐dichloro‐2,4,6‐ trifluorobenzotrifluoride (DTBF) with the LbL method to realize high‐efficiency OSCs. DTBF interacts with the non‐fullerene acceptor BTP‐4F by non‐covalent bonding, which enhances the crystallinity and compact stacking of BTP‐4F. DTBF doped OSC has balanced and efficient electron transport properties, longer carrier lifetime, higher exciton dissociation and charge collection efficiencies, lower energetic disorder than the control OSC without any additives. Benefiting from the optimization of charge dynamics and micro‐morphology by DTBF, the binary LbL‐processed OSC achieved synergistic improvements in open‐circuit voltage, short‐circuit current density and fill factor. As a result, a champion power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 19% is realized for DTBF‐optimized OSC, which is superior to the control OSC (17.55%). This work demonstrates a promising approach to modulate active layer morphology and fabricate high performance OSCs.

Polymerization of redox-active alizarin in biomass porous carbon with enhanced cycling stability for supercapacitor

Redox-active organic molecules have optimistic application prospects in energy storage due to their high theoretical capacitance, designable electrochemical activity and environmental friendliness. However, low conductivity and solubility in electrolyte severely hinder their redox activity. Here, alizarin molecules containing carbonyl and phenolic hydroxyl are encapsulated in biomass-derived porous carbon, and stable alizarin polymers are further grown on porous carbon substrate by electrochemical polymerization. Porous carbon as conductive network can improve electron transport properties, and provide suitable accommodation environment for confinement and polymerization of alizarin. The electrochemical polymerization strategy on carbon substrate allows alizarin to be connected by rigid C-O-C bond, which inhibits the dissolution of organic monomers while maintaining redox activity. The optimized polyalizarin/porous carbon composite (PAZ/PC-0.5) exhibits superior charge storage performance, with a specific capacitance of 355.8 F g−1 at 1 A g−1 and 220.8 F g−1 at high current density of 30 A g−1. Moreover, PAZ/PC electrode has more durable long-term charge-discharge stability (capacitance retention is 98 % after 10,000 charge and discharge cycles). The assembled symmetrical supercapacitor exhibits excellent energy-power characteristics (21.4 Wh kg−1 at 700 W kg−1) and durable cycle stability. This work sheds light on the design of stable organic electrode towards high-performance supercapacitor.

Analysis of the high-temperature transport property in GaN-based single and double heterostructures

GaN-based heterostructures have been proved to be excellent candidates for high-voltage, large-power, high-frequency and high-temperature application fields, thanks to their superior material properties. To further improve the carriers’ confinement, using InGaN channel layer or introducing AlGaN back barrier layer is promoted. These structures are also proved to be favorable for the robust electron mobility at high temperature. However, the reason solely rests on the longitudinal optical (LO) phonon scattering and the behind mechanism is still absent. This work compares the temperature-dependent electronic transport properties in three groups of GaN-based heterostructures, including GaN-based single heterostructure (SH) with/without AlN interlayer, GaN-based SH and double heterostructure (DH), and GaN-based DH with AlGaN or GaN channel layer. The advantageous high-temperature mobility is attributed to the enhanced LO phonon energy in heterostructures. By self-consistent calculations of the Schrödinger–Poisson equations, a close relation between the narrow electron distribution in the quantum well with the high LO phonon energy, and consequently superior mobility at high temperature is implied. The results provide a simple strategy for the optimized design of the GaN-based heterostructures outperforming at high temperature.

Operando Tracking of Transport Properties in Na3V2(PO4)2F3 and LiFePO4 Battery Electrodes by In-Plane Measurements

The development of batteries has become a major challenge and requires new operando techniques for tracking reaction kinetics in battery electrodes during operation. Taking Na3V2(PO4)2F3 and LiFePO4 as examples of positive electrode materials, the present work deals with the design of an operando technique to measure the ionic and electronic transport properties of battery electrodes during polarization. In the case of LiFePO4, large electronic resistance changes were revealed when crossing the solid-solution domains. Such resistance changes are consistent with thermodynamic models proposing the existence of a diffuse phase boundary between Li-poor and Li-rich domains, as a result of the non-linear variation of the chemical potential of the LFP particles, which in turn leads to restricted lithium diffusion. Concerning Na3V2(PO4)2F3, the important variations of electronic resistance measured were correlated with different phase changes and superstructures formed during the insertion-disinsertion of Na+ ions, as well as the polarization and entropy heat variations. These results are fully consistent with a substantial correlation of structural changes with transport properties and reaction kinetics, and thus, performances. More generally, this technique shows great promise as a tool to aid in designing battery electrodes with improved ionic and electronic percolations.

Reduced Thermal Conductivity of Constricted Graphene Nanoribbons for Thermoelectric Applications

Graphene nanoribbons (GNRs) hold promise as thermoelectric (TE) materials due to their advantageous electronic properties compared to conventional candidates. However, a key challenge to enhancing the TE performance of GNRs lies in reducing the thermal conductivity while maintaining the electronic transport properties. To address this challenge - this study proposes a GNR-based structure featuring nanoscale constrictions named graphene nano constrictions (GNCs). This work systematically analyzes the thermal transport properties of these GNCs and compares them to conventional GNRs. Non-Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics (NEMD) simulations were employed to evaluate the lattice thermal conductivity of the material, and a marked reduction of thermal conductivity exceeding 74% was observed in the proposed structures. Furthermore, it is revealed that the thermal conductivity of these structures can be further tailored by manipulating their physical geometry, focusing on the length and the constriction dimensions. Additionally, superlattice counterparts of the GNCs composed of graphene and h-BN are explored in this study. Subsequently, an 88% reduction of lattice thermal conductivity is observed in the superlattice counterparts of GNCs compared to GNRs. Overall, this study demonstrates the effectiveness of nanoscale constrictions in manipulating the thermal conductivity of GNR-based structures, creating a path for optimizing their TE performance and potential device applications.

Polymerized non-fullerene small molecular acceptor as a versatile electron-transport material for 24.50 % efficiency inverted perovskite solar cells with extended spectral response

Development of novel non-fullerene electron-transport materials (ETMs) with excellent optoelectronic properties, good thermal and chemical stability, and defect passivation capability is of great significance for improving the device performance of inverted perovskite solar cells (PSCs). In this work, a polymerized non-fullerene small molecular acceptor with narrow bandgap named PY-DFT is rationally designed and synthesized. The resultant materials not only exhibits great hydrophobicity, thermal and chemical stability, but also maintains the excellent electron-transport properties of Y-type small molecule. Moreover, the electron-rich units in PY-DFT finely passivates the surface defects in perovskite. Consequently, an exceptional PCE of 24.50 % has been achieved for the champion device based on PY-DFT ETM, which is the highest efficiency for inverted PSCs based on non-fullerene ETMs to date. Notably, PY-DFT provides an extra current density of 0.25 mA/cm2 in the near-infrared light response region, where the intrinsic perovskite film has no spectral response, demonstrating attractive advantages in rationally utilization of solar spectrum. The target device without encapsulation also demonstrates good long-term operational stability. This work paves a new avenue for designing photo-active non-fullerene electron-acceptor towards efficient and stable inverted PSCs.

Insulator-donor electron wavefunction coupling in pseudo-bilayer organic solar cells achieving a certificated efficiency of 19.18%

Abstract The incorporation of polymeric insulators has led to notable achievements in the field of organic semiconductors. By altering the blending concentration, polymeric insulators exhibit extensive capabilities in regulating molecular configuration, film crystallinity, and mitigation of defect states. However, current research suggests that the improvement in such physical properties is primarily attributed to the enhancement of thin film morphology, an outcome that seems to be an inevitable consequence of incorporating insulators. Herein, we report a general and completely new effect of polymeric insulators in organic semiconductors: the insulator-donor electron wavefunction coupling effect. Such insulators can couple with donor polymers to reduce the energy barrier level and facilitate the intramolecular electron transport. Besides the morphological effects, we observed that this coupling effect is another mechanism that can significantly enhance the electron mobility (up to 100 times) through the incorporation of polymeric insulators in a series of donor systems. With this effect, we proposed a polymeric insulator blending approach to fabricate state-of-the-art pseudo-bilayer organic solar cells, and the PM6/L8-BO device exhibits a high efficiency of 19.50% (certificated 19.18%) with the improved interfacial electron transport property. This work not only offers a novel perspective on the quantum effect of polymeric insulators in organic semiconductors, but also presents a simple yet effective method for enhancing the performance of organic solar cells.

Ultrafast Charge and Exciton Diffusion in Monolayer Films of 9-Armchair Graphene Nanoribbons.

Determining the electronic transport properties of graphene nanoribbons is crucial for assessing their suitability for applications. So far, this has been highly challenging both through experimental and theoretical approaches. This is particularly the case for graphene nanoribbons that are prepared by chemical vapor deposition, which is a scalable and industry-compatible bottom-up growth method that results in closely packed arrays of ribbons with relatively short lengths of a few tens of nanometers. In this study, the experimental technique of spatiotemporal microscopy is applied to study monolayer films of 9-armchair graphene nanoribbons prepared using this growth method, and combined with linear-scaling quantum transport calculations of arrays of thousands of nanoribbons. Both approaches directly resolve electronic spreading in space and time through diffusion and give an initial diffusivity approaching 200 cm2 s-1 during the first picosecond after photoexcitation. This corresponds to a mobility up to 550 cm2 V-1 s-1. The quasi-free carriers then form excitons, which spread with a diffusivity of tens of cm2 s-1. The results indicate that this relatively large charge carrier mobility is the result of electronic transport not being hindered by defects nor inter-ribbon hopping. This confirms their suitability for applications that require efficient electronictransport.

Heteroatom‐Embedded Spiro[Fluorene‐9,9′‐Xanthene]‐Based Electron Transport Materials for Improved Driving Voltage and Efficiency in Phosphorescent Organic Light‐Emitting Diodes

AbstractThe organic material 9,9‐spirobifluorene (SBF) is a useful building block for the construction of organic light‐emitting diodes owing to its rigid molecular structure, good charge transport properties, and high triplet energy. However, the electron transport properties of the SBF‐derived electron transport materials (ETMs) are currently not good enough and should be improved. In this work, two ETMs derived from spiro[fluorene‐9,9′‐xanthene] (SFX) and spiro[cyclopenta[1,2‐b:5,4‐b′] dipyridine‐5,9′‐xanthene] (SPX) is developed to enhance the electron transport properties and triplet energy of the SBF‐derived ETMs. The SFX core can increase the triplet energy by disconnecting the conjugation on the xanthene part and SPX can improve the electron transport properties through the incorporation of two nitrogen atoms in the fluorene part of the SFX core. The SFX and SPX cores are substituted with diphenyltriazine to produce high mobility and high triplet energy ETMs. As a result, the SFX and SPX‐based ETMs showed high triplet energy of over 2.95 eV compared with 2.53 eV of the SBF‐derived ETM; in addition, the SPX‐derived ETM demonstrated higher mobility than the SBF‐derived ETM. As a result, the SPX‐derived ETM achieved lowered driving voltage and increased external quantum efficiency compared to other ETMs derived from SBF and SFX.

"V"-Shaped Changing Electronic Performance of Iodinene-Based Nanoflakes as a Function of Width.

Special structures and prominent performance make 2D iodinene more appealing and valuable at the molecular level. Here, new-type electronic devices have been constructed with iodinene-based nanoflakes in different sizes and are theoretically studied for electronic transport properties. Our findings reveal that iodinene-based nanoflakes possess great electron transport suppression, achieving the same function as SiO2 on single molecule scale. Such transport suppression shows surprisingly nonlinear "V"-shaped trend with the width of the iodinene-based nanoflake. The medium-width iodinene-based nanoflake exhibits the strongest electron transport suppression, while the narrowest and widest ones display the largest electron transmission coefficients due to delocalized transmission eigenstates. Essentially, the weakest electron transport originates from an extremely small DOS and wide HOMO-LUMO gap. Specifically, increasing the width would diminish the extension of electronic states for the dominant transport orbitals, resulting in more butterfly-like electronic states. In non-equilibrium, negative differential resistance effect can be observed in iodinene-based devices, caused by the weakening and staying away from the Fermi level of transmission peaks influenced by the bias. Our findings provide insights into the relationship between the width of iodinene-based nanoflake and electronic transport properties, and lay a foundation in the device design and applications in molecular insulators and controllable-functional devices.

Synergistic effect of lone-pair electron and atomic distortion in introducing anomalous phonon transport in layered PbXSeF (X= Cu, Ag) compounds with low lattice thermal conductivity

Using first-principles calculations, self-consistent phonon theory and Boltzmann transport theory, the crystal structure, phonon and electronic transport, and thermoelectric (TE) properties of PbXSeF (X = Cu, Ag) compounds are comprehensive explored in the current work. The heterogeneous bonding characteristics along the in-plane and out-of-plane directions lead to low lattice thermal conductivities in PbXSeF (X = Cu, Ag) compounds. The low lattice thermal conductivity is primarily attributed to strong anharmonicity caused by the lone-pair electrons of Pb. Notably, the PbCuSeF compound, despite the lighter mass in comparison with PbAgSeF, exhibits relatively lower lattice thermal conductivity. Such finding can be attributed to the distortion introduced by Cu atom, which leads to strong quartic anharmonicity, and thereby suppressing the heat-carrying phonons through the rattling-like behavior of Cu atom. The lone-pair electrons of Pb2+ and the heterogeneous bonding characteristics in PbXSeF (X = Cu, Ag) compounds contribute the multi-valley band degeneracy, resulting the decoupling of Seebeck coefficient and electrical conductivity with carrier concentration while generating in a high power factor. Our current work not only illustrates the fundamental insights into the low lattice thermal conductivity and related anomaly of layered PbXSeF (X = Cu, Ag) compounds based on the four-phonon scattering and multiple carrier scattering rates, but also highlights the anisotropic feature of electronic and thermal transport properties.

Simulating graphene-based single-electron transistor: incoherent current effects due to the presence of electron–electron interaction

Carbon-based nanostructures have unparalleled electronic properties. At the same time, using an allotrope of carbon as the contacts can yield better device control and reproducibility. In this work, we simulate a single-electron transistor composed of a segment of a graphene nanoribbon coupled to carbon nanotubes electrodes. Using the non-equilibrium Green's function formalism we atomistically describe the electronic transport properties of the system including electron-electron interactions. Using this methodology we are able to recover experimentally observed phenomena, such as the Coulomb blockade, as well as the corresponding Coulomb diamonds. Furthermore, we separate the different contributions to transport and show that incoherent effects due to the interaction play a crucial role in the transport properties depending on the region of the stability diagram being considered.

Engineering of in-plane SnS2–SnO2 nanosheets heterostructures for enhanced H2S sensing

In-plane heterostructures has attracted considerable interest due to exceptional electron transport properties, high specific surface area, and abundant active sites. However, synthesis of in-plane SnS2–SnO2 heterostructures are rarely reported, and the deep investigation of the fine structure on reactivity is of great significance. Here, we propose partial in-situ oxidation strategy to construct the in-plane SnS2–SnO2 heterostructures and the surface properties, the ratio of two components can be finely tuned by precisely adjusting the treatment temperature. In particular, the SnS2–SnO2 heterostructures formed after annealing of SnS2 nanosheets at 350 °C exhibits a unique electronic structure and surface properties due to rich grain boundaries, which exhibits excellent gas sensing performance to H2S (Ra/Rg = 169.81 for 5 ppm H2S at 160 °C, fast response and recovery dynamic (41/101 s), excellent reliability (σ = 0.01) and sensing stability (φ = 0.11 %)). Notably, the in-plane heterostructures endow the material with abundant grain boundaries and effectively regulates the electronic structure of the Sn p-orbital, which facilitate the formation of active oxygen species (O−(ad)), thus contributing to the sensing performance. Our work provides a promising platform to design in-plane heterostructures for various advanced applications.

Coexistence of linear and non-linear thermoelectricity in graphene-superconductor tunnel junctions

We theoretically analyze the electronic transport properties of a monolayer graphene/insulator/superconductor (GIS) tunnel junction subject to a temperature gradient. For intrinsic graphene, the system shows always dissipative charge transport even in the presence of an electronic temperature difference between the two leads. Differently, the GIS produces a thermoelectric response when the graphene electrochemical potential is lifted to energies comparable to the zero-temperature gap of the superconductor, i.e., the system is particle–hole asymmetric. Indeed, the thermally biased GIS system is able to produce both a short-circuit Peltier current and an open-circuit Seebeck voltage. This thermoelectric effect is made of a linear conventional component, due to the intrinsic particle–hole asymmetry of the system, and a non-linear contribution, due to a further spontaneous particle–hole symmetry breaking. In most of the thermal and charge configurations of the GIS system, the linear component prevails. Concluding, the GIS system could be employed in the design of thermometers, electromagnetic radiation sensors, and heat engines with profound influence in superconducting quantum technologies.

First-principles studies on the electronic and thermal transport properties of twin graphene and its analogues

The novel two-dimensional (2D) carbon allotropes with various carbon networks have provided an unprecedented platform to explore fascinating device applications beyond graphene. In this work, the electronic and thermal transport properties of the twin graphene and its structural analogues, i.e., γ-graphyne, twin T-graphene, and twin 4–8 graphene, have been systematically revealed through first-principles calculations. Our results confirm the energetic and dynamical stability of the twin graphene family, and the intrinsic semiconducting nature of these 2D carbon sheets superior to graphene. Based on the solution of the phonon Boltzmann transport equation, the evaluated thermal conductivity of the considered 2D carbon sheets indicates that the absence of acetylenic linkages in carbon networks leads to a relatively enhanced heat transfer capacity, i.e., a higher thermal conductivity in the twin graphene family than the γ-graphyne case. More interestingly, a way to effectively tune thermal transport properties in the twin graphene family has been proposed via the utilization of atom-embedded carbon nanocages. Our results indicate that a notable 63.8% reduction in thermal conductivity can be achieved for twin graphene through the embedding of Ti atoms into the nanocages, exhibiting great potential for robust thermal management in low-dimensional carbon networks.

Matched Electron-Transport Materials Enabling Efficient and Stable Perovskite Quantum-Dot-Based Light-Emitting Diodes.

Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) based on perovskite quantum dots (QDs), abbreviated as P-QLEDs have been regarded as significantly crucial emitters for lighting and displays. Efficient and stable P-QLEDs still lack ideal electron transport materials (ETM), which could efficiently block hole, transport electron, reduce interface non-radiative recombination and possess high thermal stability. Here, we report 2,4,6-Tris(3'-(pyridine-3-yl) biphenyl-3-yl)-1,3,5-triazine (TmPPPyTz, 3P) with strong electron-withdrawing moieties of pyridine and triazine to modulate the performance of P-QLEDs. Compared with commonly used 1,3,5-Tris(1-phenyl-1H-benzimidazol-2-yl)benzene (TPBi), the pyridine in 3P have a strong interaction with perovskites, which can effectively suppress the interface non-radiative recombination caused by the Pb2+ defects on the surface of QDs. In addition, 3P have deep highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) (enhancing hole-blocking properties), matched lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) and excellent electron mobility (enhancing electron transport properties), realizing the carrier balance and maximizing the exciton recombination. Furthermore, high thermal resistance of 3P obviously improves the stability of QDs under variable temperature, continuous UV illumination, and electric field excitation. Resultantly, the P-QLEDs using the 3P as ETM achieved an outstanding performance with a champion EQE of 30.2 % and an operational lifetime T50 of 3220 hours at an initial luminance of 100 cd m-2, which is 151 % and about 11-fold improvement compared to control devices (EQE=20 %, T50=297 hours), respectively. These results provide a new concept for constructing the efficient and stable P-QLEDs from the perspective of selective ETM.