The approximate calculation methods (SC.ENG1 and SC.ENG2) for the J-integral for pipes with circumferential surface cracks are discussed and three-dimensional elastic–plastic finite element models for circumferentially surface-cracked pipe are conducted to evaluate the accuracy of these methods for different pipe materials used in China. The numerical studies verify that the SC.ENG2 method provides more accurate estimates of J than SC.ENG1. Based on three-dimensional elastic–plastic fracture analysis, the distribution of the local J-integral along the front of a circumferential constant-depth internal surface crack is investigated and the influences of different pipe materials with different yield plateaux on J-integral values are discussed. The validity of SC.ENG1 and SC.ENG2 J-integral estimation methods for pipe steel materials with different yield plateaux used in China are examined in detail and the SC.ENG2 method is found to provide reasonable estimates of J for materials with yield plateaux.